I didn't know what flair to post this under, because it's both a happy one and a vent / support request.
I (48F) have had a new partner for about four months. Let's call him Cedar.
I've lived with Aspen for over two decades and have been in a long-term relationship with Birch for 8 years, and all that has been going great. When I first got together with Birch, I had massive NRE. I basically wanted to leave everything behind to be with her. It was a huge, happy feeling, but I also knew it for what it was, so I just bid my time, and sure enough about a year in, it stabilized and led to 7 years of happiness.
When I met Cedar, I wasn't looking for someone new, and neither was he, but we completely fell into each other. We just had this overwhelming desire to be together. I think he's amazing, and we're building something great.
But I've been struggling with NRE.
It's not like it was with Birch. I'm not proud of that, but with Birch early on we had ill-advised conversations about how in a different life we may have gotten married or had children. We were very enthusiastic with our scheduling, which occasionally required some adjustments with our respective NPs (nothing very bad!) We were completely in our little bubble of joy.
With Cedar, I guess we both know better, so we don't make promises we can't keep or fantasize about futures that won't come to pass. We're older and wiser. We're careful about how we plan our relationship to do right by our partners. We're caring and sweet to each other, but we're also good with our boundaries and existing commitments.
All that is happy stuff!
Except I think about him all the time. When we don't see each other for a few days, I almost physically hurt. I keep wondering what it would have been like to meet each other ten, twenty years ago, and it makes me a little sad that I didn't get to know him back then. There are many things we won't get to have together, and I'm often nostalgic of them. I feel very protective and a bit possessive of him.
It's definitely NRE, but among the joyful feelings, it's got that painful flavor, like I keep wishing for something I can't have. And I don't understand why I feel that way, because I'm getting everything I want! It's starting to weigh on me that I can't seem to just enjoy it.
I guess I'm looking for words of wisdom and support here, to help regulate myself and ground myself into the joy of having this great new person in my life, in addition to my other amazing relationships.