My husband and I met at a kinky-swingers club. At that time, both of us had sexual partners. After four months seeing each other, we decided to become romantic partners, and we ended with our sexual partners. We've been together around two years now, married for one, and things have been going well, for the most part. But we forgot to explain what we expected of our relationship. Stupid mistake, I know.
He had been in the liberal world way longer than I had, and he doesn't belive in monogamy. He doesn't consider himself poly per se, because he believes he can have sexual partners, have a good time with them, but want nothing more to do with them, and then come home back to me, with whom he says wants to have the romantic relationship and sees a future with.
I know I can have multiple partners and see people, only as long as I had not 100% committed emotionally (a bit of an avoidant here, I know it was wrong). I have had multiple partners at some points in my life, but I was always the one that came into an existing open relationship, never opened a relationship myself. Around 8 months ago, I realised I actually wanted a fairly monogamous relationship with him when he casually said that I could do and talk and see whomever I want, and I don't even have to tell him about it.
First and foremost, I have no desire of seeing anyone else. Secondly, the idea of him seeing and having sex and flirting with someone else feels uncomfortable to me (and I've told him so). Lastly, if we were, in fact, open, I would like him to tell me about it, to check in on me. I don't want to vet, but I would like to be informed. He is against that. He says he is his own person and owes me no explanations or my permission (which yeah, he doesn't need my permission, but...)
We've spoken about this topic a couple of times. He says he wants and will continue speaking with other women. Thats non negotiable. He also says he would like to go back "hunting" and be with other women, but it is not a necessity *as of now*. He says he has thought about having a relationship with two women (unicorn hunting) and is something he would like but doesn't need right now. He says he understands my POV but doesn't share it. I understand his but don't feel comfortable with it. We reached no agreement. The conversation finished there.
I am feeling wildly uncomfortable and emotionally activated. I have been in poly relationships before but, as I said, I was always the one that came into it. And I am not sure how to determine if this uncomfortableness is something I have to work on and push through to be able to meet him where he's at, or if it's me disregarding my own needs and we are just not compatible.
I am a firm believer discomfort is important, necessary and not something to avoid but to learn about and work through, and I do love and want to stay with him. But this conversation was two days ago, and as much as I've thought, meditated, and felt through it, I cannot seem to reach any conclusions on how to move forward. I don't know how to approach this. If anyone could give me some advice, some insights... I would greatly appreciate.