r/camping • u/MakrineCcebera • 15h ago
Ice in coolers—first or last?
So, does anyone put ice in the cooler first, and then shove their drinks/food into the ice? I have a friend who does it that way. I was curious if anyone else does this besides him. Perhaps he only does this at parties or fishing trips and not for actual camping.
Growing up, my parents taught me to put all the drinks and food into the cooler, and then put a block of ice on top because blocks of ice stay frozen longer and keep everything cooler. We had a place right around the corner from our house that sold blocks. (Naturally if you didn’t want something squished then you could lay that item on top, or put it into a tray that sits on top. Our Coleman cooler had a tray.)
My parents taught me when using bags of ice, put all the drinks and food into the cooler, then pour bags of loose ice cubes in that fills in the cracks to the top of the cooler and across the whole surface so you can’t really see anything without digging for it.
(I read in another couple posts that jugs of frozen water work better to keep cool than loose ice cubes. Makes sense to me; acts like a block of ice. I also read in a post that the liquid water after the ice melts keeps the cooler colder than the loose cubes so it should be left in the cooler if possible rather than being drained and refilled with ice. I understand it’s been scientifically proven. But I would have thought that once the ice melts, then it’s no longer 32 degrees Fahrenheit in the cooler anymore.)
Ps—it drives me nuts that he shoves food and drinks into the ice and leaves a ton of space around them or above them. The ice only goes around halfway up the cans . . . Lots of air still available. Also he doesn’t completely cover the drinks with ice either. I figured the wisdom was to put ice in last. But that’s just the way my parents did it so I assumed.