r/stepparents • u/NorthZealousideal883 • 3h ago
Advice Did I overstep?
I had a situation with my stepson Zack (15) over the weekend. It was my birthday. When it's a family member's birthday, that person chooses the activities they would like to do to celebrate. Everyone else participates happily to help the birthday person feel celebrated. Zack is included in this. For my birthday, I specifically chose an activity I knew would appeal to Zack because he can be difficult when the activity is not his preference. Historically, Zack himself has chosen this same activity for his birthday.
Prior to and during the activity, Zack began what I consider to be passive-aggressive tantrums. The behavior includes pretending not to hear when he is spoken to, pretending to be asleep when he is not, responding to genuine questions or requests sarcastically and/or with an argument, etc. Then there's the open, frequent, and loud complaining about "having to" participate. In essence, Zack can really bring down a celebration when he would prefer not to be there. My husband expressed some annoyance with Zack about the behavior, but he did not address it specifically or directly with expectations for improvement.
During one part of the activity, Zack needed to make a specific choice about something in order to participate further. He was sitting there pretending to be asleep, holding everyone else up. Like, he was acting as if he had dozed off and his head was dropping forward. My husband tried to get Zack's attention twice, and Zack ignored him. My husband asked a third time, and Zack pretended like he hadn't heard and that he was startled awake. It was clearly fake and ridiculous.
I had enough of it at that point. I told Zack to step away from the group with me for a minute. I took him to a separate area, and I reminded him that it was my birthday and that was why we were doing this activity. I reminded him that when it is his birthday, we all -- me included -- do whatever he chooses, and we participate fully. I then reminded him that I had spent the entire previous day doing an activity he had chosen, and I did it happily. I told him that I expected the same from him. That's what is fair. He replied with, "I'm trying." And I said, "Try more." Then I told him to go back to where the group. When we returned, my husband asked me if everything was okay. I said, "It will be now."
A little while later, I told my husband about the exchange with Zack. I told him I would understand if he believed I overstepped or if I needed to do anything with Zack to correct what I'd said. My husband said he thought I'd handled it well. He said Zack's behavior was poor, and he was glad I addressed it.
Later, Zack continued to pout, and he separated himself from the rest of the group. I decided that as long as he wasn't creating problems for everyone else, he could sit over there on his own. I didn't address that. My husband, however, became very concerned that Zack was sad or whatever, and that became the excuse to end the activity. Zack got what he wanted, right? So frustrating. Zack hasn't spoken to me for three days now.
So, do you think I overstepped my bounds by addressing Zack the way I did? This is difficult for me because I never had these behavioral issues with my son (25). It has always just been expected and accepted that we behave positively on someone else's birthday to help them have a good day.