Hi, Reddit! Not using a throwaway because my husband knows my account and is completely on board with me. I'm mostly looking for advice on how to handle this kindly.
My (33F) husband (34M) and I eloped in California (where we live) in December 2025. We'd already been together for eight years, I was starting a new job, he unexpectedly lost his health insurance, and it just made sense to sign the paperwork. We always planned to celebrate later with a ketubah signing (we're Jewish) and some sort of wedding celebration.
Backtrack a bit . . . we got engaged in September 2025. My husband and I have a great relationship btw, we just realized we'd been having a somewhat funny miscommunication for EIGHT YEARS lol. I'd always said I didn't want a "big wedding" and my husband agreed that he didn't want a "big wedding" either. I had no idea that our definitions of "big wedding" were different!
Me: Big wedding = a lot of people
Husband: Big wedding = formal event
So once we realized that, we compromised. My dream was an intimate, experience-based wedding with our closest people—think a villa in Italy with cooking classes, breakfast together, a ketubah signing, and maybe 20 guests. His dream was celebrating with everyone. Our compromise became: a small Italy wedding, plus maybe a larger New Jersey celebration afterward so his extended family could celebrate too (since they mostly live there), and we mentioned that to his parents. This isn't as easy for my family, who lives all over the States and Central America. We were clear it was a possibility only, and we'd let them know.
(Also worth adding: Our budget is $20k. I wanted to be flexible on more people, but we can't afford that. Nor can we afford many more people in the states, either...)
Unfortunately, after 6 months of research (and communication with our families the whole time), the Italy celebration is no longer possible as we're too nervous with the current climate and international travel, and two of our best friends have announced pregnancies so wouldn't be able to travel.
I'll admit I've been grieving that decision more than I expected. I'm very happy to be married, but I never got to shop for a wedding dress or have any of the bridal experiences I'd imagined, and I'm realizing I really was looking forward to those.
My husband has been wonderful through all of this, and we're completely on the same page that there's no rush for when we eventually will do something--maybe a five year vow renewal when the world climate is different, we've saved up more money, etc. But it's on pause for now.
Unfortunately, my MIL seems to have treated the New Jersey celebration as a certainty because that's what she wants.
She wants to host a "celebration" for us at the clubhouse in the neighborhood where she and my FIL recently moved to. Apparently it's only $150 to rent, which I don't believe, but my husband's family doesn't have thousands to give us, and so that's what they can contribute, Which I am not knocking at all! But my mom gave us $10k with no rules . . . we added an additional $10k . . . and it's not fair that she thinks she can stronghold us into doing something because she's "paying for it."
(And FWIW, I detest this clubhouse. I find it rather ugly, and I don't particularly care for their new town . . . but obviously don't want to say that as I don't want to be mean.)
She wants to invite extended family, neighbors, and her entire book club. Every time I say I don't want a large party, she starts listing people who "aren't that many," like, "oh it's just X. And her husband Y. And then Z and her husband. And three more people."
If it were a big wedding, that's fine! But I've said for 8 years that is not for me!
We're visiting New Jersey in October because my husband has several music shows he's playing there, and I'll already be on the East Coast running a work event in Pennsylvania (which is a four-day long, high stress, overnight workshop event that I'm completely planning/running). We have exactly one collective free day on this trip, and that's the day she wants to hold this celebration.
I found out because yesterday, my mom texted my MIL to wish her a happy birthday. During that conversation, my MIL asked my mom to help "make me" agree to the party.
My mom read the conversation out loud to me. The words "make [OP agree]" were verbatim there. My mom replied that she can't make me do anything. I'm 33!
MIL can be extremely direct and sometimes phrases things poorly, so I'm trying not to assume bad intentions. I genuinely believe she loves me and is excited to celebrate us. We have a good relationship, and I don't think she's trying to be malicious. But asking my mom to convince me after I'd already said no felt manipulative, even if that wasn't her intent.
For additional context, I don't enjoy being the center of attention. I'm in therapy for anxiety, have been for 6 years, and I've known my entire life that large celebrations centered on me are something I tolerate rather than enjoy. That's why I've always been so clear that a "big wedding" isn't for me, but I still want to do SOMETHING. An experience-based wedding would be my ideal: the idea of our immediate families being together for cooking classes and breakfast is what I wanted vs. an organized event. I love hosting, I love celebrating other people, but being the guest of honor at a big event is very different for me. My husband agrees, he just doesn't want to exclude anybody--and budget is an issue. If we could have 100 people at a villa, even a winery in CA, we would, no questions asked. For $20k. Lol.
My husband feels stuck in the middle because he loves his parents but also completely supports me. His actual ideal at this point is "let's all just go to the beach and figure it out," which honestly sounds more appealing to both of us than a clubhouse reception, albeit too loose for me.
I do want to celebrate our marriage someday. But it must be our celebration, the way we want it, not anyone else's.
Having a clubhouse party in New Jersey—planned by someone else, with a guest list I don't want, during a stressful work trip—feels like I'd be doing only the "compromise" half of the original plan while giving up the part I was actually excited about, while simultaneously mourning said original plan, while simultaneously needing to pop a Xanax or something to even go.
Am I being unreasonable for saying no? And if you've navigated something similar with family, how did you hold your boundary without damaging the relationship? I obviously know I need to talk to her directly, I just don't want to hurt her feelings.