r/ProjectHailMary Mar 12 '26

Movie Discussion - Movie Spoilers Inside! Movie Discussion Megathread Spoiler

Post image
332 Upvotes

Hello, Leaky Space Blobs.

I'm making this post now since some lucky individuals within the community have been fortunate enough to see the movie before release.

Have at it. For the rest if us plebs, next week can't come fast enough.

Beware: obvious movie spoilers within, and there may be book spoilers as well when people compare the movie to the book.


r/ProjectHailMary 22d ago

Book Discussion FAQ

267 Upvotes

This subreddit has a few very frequently asked questions, so here are some answers.

1. How did it only take 4 years for the Hail Mary to travel 11 lightyears?

Answer: Time Dilation.

The Hail Mary uses very efficient engines to approach the speed of light. At those speeds, time is not constant. On Earth, it took the Hail Mary 13.7 years to travel to Tau Ceti. For Ryland Grace, it only took about 4 years. Don't be an Eridian, learn more about Time Dilation and Special Relativity!

2. Why couldn't they just wait for the Astrophage to double, and then do a return trip?

Answer: It would take longer than 8 days, and they would need more than double the fuel.

a. Whilst small amounts of Astrophage in a lab can double every 8 days, the limit for Project Hail Mary was the amount of energy it takes. Eva Stratt devoted a quarter of the Sahara Desert to be covered in 'Blackpanels', little Astrophage breeding solar panels. This allowed them to make one metric tonne of Astrophage every day.Astrophage os very hungry for energy, and to use Astrophage for fuel, it needs to be 'enriched', or made so that every single cell is full of energy.

b. It would take more than double the fuel. For a return trip on a rocket, the fuel to get back, 2 million kilograms for the Hail Mary, is the payload to get there. The Hail Mary had a 20 to 1 fuel mass ratio, so 2 million kilograms could get 100 thousand kilograms of food, ship and Ryland Grace to Tau Ceti. A return trip would have a payload of at least 2 million kilograms, so they would need another 40 million kilograms of fuel. This would take 20 times as long as it took to make fuel for a suicide mission.

3. Why couldn't they make more Astrophage on the way there?

Answer: Astrophage is really hungry!

To make the 2 million kilograms of Astrophage for a one way trip, they needed a lot of energy. They got this energy from the Sun. During interstellar travel, the Sun, and other stars, would be way too dim to feed Astrophage. The Hail Mary also has a far smaller area to collect any solar power, so it would take many decades, if not centuries to make enough Astrophage. Astrophage also requires physical matter to grow, such as Carbon Dioxide. The Hail Mary couldn't carry all of that CO2 on the way there without a whole lot more fuel.

4. How can Eridians see the Petrova line, and stars?

Answer: Eridian science has come a long way!

While Eridians can't see light themselves, they have developed technology to detect light. They haven't figured it all out yet, as they don't know about Special Relativity and the speed of light, but they can detect light and use radio waves for radar and communications. They used this technology to learn more about their Petrova line, and find out about Tau Ceti.

Eridian scientists likely theorised about their star, because just like on Earth, all of the energy comes from the Sun. The only difference is that Erid's thick atmosphere means that the ecosystem starts all the way up in the clouds, and gradually transfers energy downwards. Eventually, when they built a space elevator, they would have found out a whole lot more about stars and planets. We don't know whether they did this before or after the Astrophage crisis started.

5. How did Eridians not know about space radiation, if they do know about light?

Answer: Space radiation is a bit different!

In Space, especially interstellar space, the most dangerous type of radiation is cosmic rays. These are very fast moving particles, such as protons and electrons, which when they hit Human or Eridian ships at nearly the speed of light, can sometimes pass through the material of the ship, and damage DNA. Eridians don't know about these because their planet's massive magnetic field protected them from all radiation, even when they're on their space elevator. Light is a different type of radiation, and some of it is dangerous, gamma rays, and most of it is not. There is also radiation from radioactive materials, but we don't know if the Eridians have learned about those. So, to summarise, even though the Eridians know about light radiation, they didn't know that space was filled with cosmic rays.

6. Why didn't they collect Astrophage from the Petrova line, at Venus, or at Tau Ceti?

Answer: Space is big!

'You just won't believe how vastly, hugely, mind-bogglingly big it is.' While the Petrova line contains enormous quantities of Astrophage, it is also very, very sparse. The Petrova Taskforce sent a probe to Venus, and could only collect and return 100 cells to Earth. To fuel the Hail Mary requires 2 million kilograms, which would be many, many more cells. The collector would have to be many kilometres in diameter, or wait for many years, to collect enough for a one-way trip. Such a collector would be too large and heavy to send to Tau Ceti.

7. What happens to the other stars near Earth?

Answer: Not much! (credit to u/Equivalent-Board206)

Astrophage, when left completely unchecked, dims a star by a maximum of 10%. That is just barely noticeable to the naked eye, looking up at the night's sky.

Lowered solar output would force the habitable zone (sometimes called the Goldilocks zone) closer to the sun. This may result in previously habitable planets being thrust into glacial ice ages and rendering them entirely uninhabitable. In theory, it could allow previously uninhabitable planets to become habitable, but habitability requires more than just being in the habitable zone.

For Earth, the lowering solar output was leading to a global average temperature drop of about 8°C which would result in rapid glaciation and global agriculture collapse.

Mars too would be colder. Venus has a permanent runaway greenhouse effect and would see no perceptible difference. Nor would the gas giants as they already receive less than 5% of the sunlight that Earth receives.

Beyond impacts to weather and habitability, a drop in solar output would not have any effects on the planets themselves or their orbits.

8. How does Rocky understand Grace?

Answer: Eridians are really smart!

Eridians have extremely good memory, due to the way their brains work. This is especially true for audio memory, because that is the main way in which they interact with the world. At the same time that Grace was recording sounds on his laptops, and writing definitions, Rocky was listening to Grace's words, and remembering them with their respective definitions. They started with charades, but later on they were able to ask each other for definitions of words, and how they are said in English or Eridian.

Disclaimer: Zero AI was used in this post. Not even spell check. (I just added bold text to make it look a bit better).

Note: All redditors that frequent this subreddit, please please rewrite these answer, and I will put them in the post body. Also please add more Q&A, because I can only remember these two FAQ off the top of my head.


r/ProjectHailMary 9h ago

Question? When Grace went to Rocky's ship...

Post image
1.3k Upvotes

How much oxygen could there be in the suit Rocky made him. Is that why we see very little of the ship? Because Grace had very little time? Is that hump on his back some sort of oxygen tank?


r/ProjectHailMary 5h ago

Fist My Bump When Rocky walked into a Swedish liquor store he saw...

Post image
341 Upvotes

r/ProjectHailMary 1h ago

Keeping The Space Blob

Post image
Upvotes

He's got a bad case of scurvy at the moment but he's fineeeee


r/ProjectHailMary 2h ago

Fist My Bump My Ryland Grace cosplay & Rocky

Thumbnail
gallery
193 Upvotes

While watching the movie, I asked my partner to sew me a yellow jumpsuit and she did! I made the mission patches and built Rocky to complete my Ryland Grace cosplay. I'm really happy with how it all came together and wanted to share here. I have some videos on my socials as well.


r/ProjectHailMary 5h ago

‘The Odyssey’ Proves It: Audiences Want Movies Made the Hard Way | This year's breakouts like 'Project Hail Mary' and 'Obsession' were made by filmmakers who sweated. While CG-stuffed franchise disappointments such as 'Supergirl,' 'Moana,' and 'The Mandalorian and Grogu' looked lazy.

Thumbnail
hollywoodreporter.com
134 Upvotes

r/ProjectHailMary 10h ago

Saw this and immediately thought that this is similar to how eridians would percieve human bodies

286 Upvotes

r/ProjectHailMary 5h ago

Movie Discussion - Movie Spoilers Inside! Why didn’t you tell me?

102 Upvotes

After watching the movie multiple times, something struck me. When Grace finally admits he’s not going back to Earth and will die in space, Rocky says “Why didn’t you tell me?” Not “Why you not tell me, question?—as you would expect him to say and is the grammatical structure he uses just before and after this. At first I thought that maybe the phrase was recorded at a later date and the actor forgot how to make Rocky sound like Rocky. But then it made me wonder if it’s intentional. Since there are other references to movies throughout this one, is it a nod to Luke Skywalker’s question at the end of The Empire Strikes Back: “Ben, why didn’t you tell me?” Honestly, I have to go with this explanation otherwise it’s quite a glaring inconsistency.


r/ProjectHailMary 46m ago

Someone convince me it’s not this serious💔

Thumbnail
gallery
Upvotes

I’m like a fucking detail freak and, turns out, I accidentally bought the wrong model and can’t change it back due to having already customized the shoelaces before I noticed. I feel so idk annoyed ITS NOT THAT BAD RIGHT..?


r/ProjectHailMary 2h ago

I see it everywhere

Post image
52 Upvotes

r/ProjectHailMary 1d ago

Fist My Bump A meme I found and thought I'd share

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

3.0k Upvotes

Since it seems that this fandom is allergic to happiness (I'm looking at you 'grace gets old and dies' comics) you get a funny meme.


r/ProjectHailMary 2h ago

Movie Discussion - Movie Spoilers Inside! Love the detail that the blueprint of the Hail Mary at the start of the movie is the same as the book

Post image
34 Upvotes

r/ProjectHailMary 20h ago

Fist My Bump 😭👎🏻👎🏻👎🏻✨

Thumbnail
gallery
1.0k Upvotes

r/ProjectHailMary 9h ago

Fan Art - No selling Some of my doodles

Thumbnail
gallery
100 Upvotes

I love Rocky and Adrian. These span over a while, my artstyle is super inconsistent. Also it features mark watney who I’ve made a whole AU for with friends (go Rylark!!!!). I took the Grace one more seriously lol, I had to edit some shorts onto my boy. I did it in about 3 hours on Roblox it was very fun!!


r/ProjectHailMary 3h ago

Question? Why do SO MANY people treat Stratt's actions as an indictment of her entire species, or even all the life in Earth? Did the movie not make it clear enough that she and that one handful of her men were acting in secret?

35 Upvotes

r/ProjectHailMary 4h ago

Book Discussion Best PHM Book quotes Bingo Day 1: What is the funniest quote from the book?

Post image
37 Upvotes

Thanks to u/Fantastic-Contest957 for the template!


r/ProjectHailMary 10h ago

Fist My Bump 👎🏻👎🏻👎🏻🥺✨

Post image
87 Upvotes

r/ProjectHailMary 9h ago

Fan Art - No selling 👎art by a beginner who rarely draws

Thumbnail
gallery
71 Upvotes

drew pic1 in the semi dark, just to show my sibling the meme. sibling still isn't convinced that they should watch phm :( sad sad sad

pic2 was the first attempt. he's coming for you 👊


r/ProjectHailMary 21h ago

Fan Art - No selling Grace being disgust.

Post image
413 Upvotes

r/ProjectHailMary 50m ago

Fan Art - No selling Dr. Captain Ryland Grace, Gera, digital art, 2026

Post image
Upvotes

r/ProjectHailMary 22h ago

Fist My Bump My wife wants me to have an MRI

419 Upvotes

I’ve started saying ‘question’ at the end of every question I ask my wife then stomping my foot twice. My wife wants me to have an MRI now. She won’t watch the movie.
Jokes on her cuz I don’t even care.


r/ProjectHailMary 23h ago

Fan Art - No selling You favourite PHM obsessed book binder is back with even more editions! I've made six in total now. I might need an intervention!

Thumbnail
gallery
434 Upvotes

r/ProjectHailMary 20h ago

Fist My Bump Look what I got🥹❤️

Post image
235 Upvotes

So I asked my grandma to crochet it to see if she could make this little Earth from the movie for me. She wasn't crocheting anymore, but she asked someone she knew to do it and handed it to me a few days ago. I absolutely fell in love with this little ball and I pick it up all the time. It makes me a bit sad when I show it to some people at work and they have no idea what it is.


r/ProjectHailMary 3h ago

Fist My Bump Share your PHM jokes?

12 Upvotes

Why did Grace get lost on the Blip-A?

Because it was a - maze.