r/tmobile • u/staystrongalways99 • 16h ago
Discussion T-Mobile sent me this as a “certified” warranty replacement under Protection 360
My S23 Ultra developed severe battery drain, so T-Mobile processed a warranty replacement through my Protection 360 coverage.
This is what arrived.
The replacement was visibly used, dirty, poorly packaged, and still had the previous owner’s scratched and peeling screen protector attached. I did not remove it, activate the phone, or transfer any data.
Support offered me a $20 credit and ordered another device, which the automated text explicitly identified as CPO. I canceled that order because I no longer trust the replacement inventory and will keep using my current phone until I upgrade.
I understand that warranty replacements may be refurbished. My issue is that a device presented as certified pre-owned should at least be cleaned, inspected, and properly packaged. Leaving another customer’s damaged screen protector attached means nobody could have properly inspected the actual display.
Is this seriously T-Mobile’s current replacement standard?
UPDATE: Clarification: This replacement was processed directly through T-Mobile’s warranty exchange process, not as an Assurant damage claim. T-Mobile created the order, shipped the device, handled the return, and issued the account credit. I had already returned this device and canceled the second replacement before posting.