r/papermario May 28 '26

Discussion Don't play recut. Trust me.

159 Upvotes

So there was a Paper Mario recomp released a few days ago, and I’m not gonna lie, the whole thing feels really weird to me.

The current N64 recomp situation already makes Paper Mario an odd target because of TLB stuff, so I was already curious how this was working. Then I actually looked at the project and some of the choices are strange.

My issues are:

  1. The widescreen exists, but it looks terrible.

  2. The ROM check is very questionable. I put in a Mario Kart 64 ROM and the game still booted. Maybe it was using cached setup data, but either way that is not a good look for something that claims it needs a valid Paper Mario ROM.

  3. Control remapping exists, but it is hidden behind a top bar you only see after pressing F1. I originally thought it had no remapping at all because the UI does not make this obvious.

  4. The generated recomp code is sitting in the repo. Example: https://github.com/SMCGames/Paper-Mario-ReCut/blob/e46497efe3ee1e2870ca8eac560380e6a335bd1b/rsp/n_aspMain.cpp

  5. The repo was made extremely recently, which makes the whole thing feel rushed.

  6. The README says not to commit or distribute ROMs, generated ROM output, local dumps, replacements, or user folders, but the project structure still makes me wonder where the line is supposed to be lmao. Especially when there are built-in texture/resource-looking files involved.

I’m not saying people can’t play it. If you just want Paper Mario on PC and it works for you, cool. But from what I’ve seen, it feels more like a rushed proof-of-concept than a carefully handled recomp release like what Paper Mario deserves.

I would not be shocked if it gets taken down or heavily cleaned up soon.

Also, it is Windows-only right now. It might work in Wine, but that is still a huge turnoff for me.

(edited)


r/papermario May 24 '26

Announcement A ban on generative AI

979 Upvotes

r/papermario as a community has focused on propping up and sharing the best the community has to offer, including the artists within the community. In recent years generative AI has come out and there has been significant issue within the artist community with it's existence.

Given that we focus on making this place have a minimum standard of quality we believe that something that uses art without consent of the artists as inherently hostile to the artists within our community and falls below our standards as a community. We are explicitly adding generative AI as low quality content for rule 4.

Starting today and here on forward any post containing generative AI will be removed from the subreddit. This will be somewhat retroactive as well as it is found and reported.


r/papermario 16h ago

Meme Happy 22nd Anniversary of Paper Mario: The Thousand-Year Door

Post image
439 Upvotes

r/papermario 16h ago

Miscellaneous Paper Mario painting I saw at a restaurant today

Thumbnail
gallery
189 Upvotes

genuinely had to double take when i saw this


r/papermario 2h ago

Fan Art Check out this awesome art I commissioned from @SigDowee! Triple bisexuals!

Post image
10 Upvotes

You can find her at @/SigDowee on Twitter. I highly recommend commissioning her.


r/papermario 10h ago

Fan Art A shadow's comfort (OC)

Post image
15 Upvotes

I did some very basic shading for this piece, might be something I might so more of in future 2D art stuff.


r/papermario 5h ago

Fan Art Paper Mario partner concepts (Pyrra the Ember) and (Grim Guy the Shy Guy)

Post image
3 Upvotes

I don't really have a story for these folks, but I was thinking of a somewhat grim, hehe, darker Paper Mario game, almost like an entire game based on some Hell-scape like the Underwhere.

Mario has lived countless lives, and this grim reaper aociety of shyguys is tired of it, sending one of their lackeys to follow Mario around.

Once he finds a bottomless pit to fall in, that'd when Grim Guy is supposed to take Mario's soul. However, as most creatures do, he took a shine yo Mario and started following him around.

As for Pyrra, I dont know what her role would be, but she's a very spunky, fiery spirit, and instead of glowing typical red or orange, its more bright colors, a bright yellow, orange, pink that rotates around her body.


r/papermario 23h ago

Fan Art Shunned Guy

Post image
93 Upvotes

r/papermario 56m ago

Fan Art Happy 22th anniversary to Paper Mario thousand year door

Post image
Upvotes

Today, it's day where Paper Mario TTYD appeared 22 July after I was born, and it's always my only favorite game, Goombella is my only favorite, and I'm always playing this game, since my console Nintendo has fixed, my brother plays this game too, and you guys, can you tell me when you start play it ?


r/papermario 1h ago

Discussion Fracktail is the first boss, yet I still haven't figured out how to even hurt him.

Thumbnail
Upvotes

r/papermario 18h ago

Music Does anyone else think this tune from Super Paper Mario is an intentional homage to the item fanfare heard throughout the Metroid series?

3 Upvotes

r/papermario 20h ago

Help Does anyone have a save file from before the petey piranha boss fight

4 Upvotes

I don't wanna replay the whole game to get to this moment and all of the save files I found are 100%


r/papermario 21h ago

Discussion I want to replay paper mario 64, do you have any mods or rom hacks to suggest?

3 Upvotes

I don't want it to deviate too much from the original, something with more content and a small difficulty increase would be perfect


r/papermario 1d ago

Miscellaneous The coolest thing about the TTYD Remake is that it's a great basis engine for Nintendo to use for future games, and of course, fans can make new Paper Mario games that look actually up to modern standards.

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

120 Upvotes

r/papermario 2d ago

Fan Art Paper Mario Divorce

Post image
216 Upvotes

r/papermario 1d ago

Help Essential/QoL mods for TTYD? (GCN/Dolphin)

2 Upvotes

I'm going in mostly blind but I do know the game is in 4:3 (obviously) (so widescreen hack probably), has some infamous backtracking (not sure how bad it is so not sure if I should go out of my way to do anything about it), and had some censorship in localization (so I definitely want to get rid of that).

Does that about cover it for a "vanilla but slightly nicer/more convenient" experience?


r/papermario 2d ago

Discussion Between 64 and TTYD which game do you think is better?

Post image
273 Upvotes

I love both games to death, and from the top of my head here are some things each game does better than the other:

64 - Better difficulty, better level design

TTYD - Better story, better partners, more complex battle system

I personally prefer 64, but TTYD is still a fantastic game


r/papermario 1d ago

Discussion What's your honest opinion of Sticker Star's Secret Doors?

Post image
10 Upvotes

I personally like the concept of using them to open secret rooms in each level, but it can get tedious as they are only available in one shop. I don't think anyone has ever used them for escaping battle.


r/papermario 1d ago

Discussion If you could fix one thing with sticker star what would it be ?

11 Upvotes

I would get rid of the difficulty spikes.


r/papermario 2d ago

Miscellaneous TTYD is my all time favorite

Thumbnail
gallery
207 Upvotes

I was lucky enough to be in the UK when it released, so I got the pre-order bonus of the battle stage to build.
And I had attended the launch event in NY, which was the same day I had flown out too funny enough.
Genuinely couldn’t miss it, I grew up on the GameCube and namely with TTYD, Super Mario Sunshine, and Luigi’s Mansion as childhood favorites.
When TTYD got announced for a remaster, I went legit crazy lol


r/papermario 2d ago

Miscellaneous Vivian canonically has plushies of her sold in the Mario universe.

Post image
61 Upvotes

I wonder how much she makes in royalties?


r/papermario 1d ago

Meme Big and O'Chunky

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

26 Upvotes

r/papermario 1d ago

Miscellaneous The dark truth about Goombella.

Post image
31 Upvotes

r/papermario 2d ago

Discussion Seeing this dialogue in 2026 makes me feel...sad?

Thumbnail
gallery
418 Upvotes

Is that the right word for it? A weird mix of sadness, Nostalgia, and something else...Goombario comments on how hes seen all our adventures and wants to be just like us, but at this point we are basically JUST A YOUNGUN!!! goombario cant comprehend what present day Mario had been through!!


r/papermario 2d ago

Discussion If you have no life, and nothing better to do...play Paper Mario and read all of the dialogue.

Post image
156 Upvotes

I'm serious. That's what im doing. It won't even be that long. So much thought and effort was out into these characters that is often skipped over by even hard core Mario gamers...why is that? Even people who like a good story and like characters will not bother to read all of this flavor text...me included.

So now im going and reading every last piece of dialogue in the first two games myself. I grew up with ttyd but not the original, so tbh this is very interesting!!!