Writing this after the 1000000th "you are not a nihilist, you are just depressed" post.
If you are genuinely happy with your life and your happiness has no meaning, that's not a reason to be depressed. You are happy, after all.
If you are NOT happy with your life, you are constantly miserable and that misery has no meaning, that is ABSOLUTELY a reason to be depressed.
And the fact that it's meaningless absolutely CAN make you even more miserable and less willing to go through it.
Stop invalidating depressed nihilists just because you are happy with your life.
And quit acting like there's no correlation between nihilism and depression.
The two things are very connected.
The suffering we experience is one major reason why "meaning" is such a big deal to humans in the first place.
There's no such thing as a "correct" way to experience nihilism.
Nihilism says there is no objective meaning to anything, period.
Where you go from there is entirely up to you.
If you are happy with your life, you don't suffer a lot, don't care about meaning, and you actually find the absence of meaning liberating, that's FANTASTIC. Good for you. There's nothing wrong with that.
If you go through some suffering, but you are still able to live a fulfilling life despite the absence of objective meaning, because there are things in your life that give YOU purpose and that YOU genuinely care about, that's good. You are also doing nothing wrong.
If someone feels constantly miserable and the absence of meaning makes them feel even worse, because they have genuinely nothing in their life to hold onto (or, if they have something, it's not enough to outweigh their suffering), they are doing nothing wrong, and depression is a perfectly rational response.
Yes, suicidal ideation can logically follow from constant misery and absence of meaning (both objective AND subjective).
- No, being suicidal doesn't automatically make someone wrong.
- No, depression is not exclusive to edgy teenagers who just broke up with their girlfriend.
- No, Camus' works are NOT objective and infallible manuals for coping with suffering and defeating existential dread.
And neither are Schopenhauer, Nietzsche or Sartre's works.
Just because Camus cared about rebelling against a non-conscious and silent universe that doesn't even know you exist and couldn't care less about you and your rebellion, that doesn't mean everyone has to care about it.
Just because Camus thought that giving up is a bad thing, it doesn't mean everyone has to think the same.
Just because Schopenhauer cared about art, and art was enough for him to be able to get through life, that doesn't mean it will be enough for everyone.
If you think those things have intrinsic value regardless of what the individual cares about, then you are not a nihilist.
- No, therapy can't magically give you meaning if you can't see none.
Therapists are not philosophers, and even if they were, that doesn't necessarily mean their outlook on life is correct, nor that their specific therapy approach will make you more willing to go through meaningless suffering or somehow convince you that it's the right thing to do.
- No, pills (and psychiatry in general) can't do that either (in fact they can even make your situation worse in some cases, but I digress).
- Someone may have already tried ALL these things before talking to you, to no avail.
Yes, that's a thing. It happens more often than you'd think.
Try to think of that possibility before judging.