I’m pretty new to magic and one of my friends just built a deck using Ygra. From what I understand it turns every creature including my own creatures into food artifacts. Does this mean that when my creatures die and go to the graveyard that his Ygra gets buffed with 2 +1/+1?

with Hasbro's CEO saying that next year's UB sets will be more fantasy adjacent, it got me thinking about what properties would be cool to see, and Elden Ring was one of the first I thought of. Went down a rabbit hole of figuring out the color identities of all the Elden Ring Bosses

Godrick the Grafted (Black, maybe Dimir?)

the whole grafting thing is very zombie-coded

Morgott, the Omen King (White)

despite being a villain, he's probably the one who stuck to "order" the most

Fire Giant (Gruul)

Gruul being the "anti-civilization" color and the fire giant being a remnant of an older age

Godskin Apostle + Godskin Noble (Black)

not much to say here

Starscourge Radahn (Boros)

he kind of exemplifies the whole "Martial honor" thing. not to mention his gravity magic, which in practice looks similar to Nahiri's lithomancy.

Malenia, Blade of Miquella (Golgari)

could be an argument here for white or red as well, but the rot is very golgari-coded.

Miquella (Esper)

he's a schemer.

Mohg, Lord of Blood (Mardu)

blood magic is very rakdos, but he's also got a white element to his character with how loyal he is to miquella

Radagon (WUBR)

kind of feels like they could be every color except green, being unnatural

Elden Beast (WUBRG)

more natural than radagon.

Maliketh, the Black Blade (Orzhov)

wields death magic, but is loyal to his sworn duty

Godfrey (White)

not too sure on this one. could be black or red too.

Rykard, Lord of Blasphemy (Rakdos)

pretty easy here. rakdos is the blasphemy color

Rennala, Queen of the Full Moon (Blue)

moon + magic: blue

Astel, Naturalborn of the Void (colorless)

kind of eldrazi-coded

Bayle the Dread (Jund)

he's got the same vibe as the jund dragons we already have in magic

Divine Beast Dancing Lion (Temur)

being an ancestral practice (and the elemental magic) makes the lion fit into temur pretty well.

Dragonlord Placidusax (WUBRG)

similar to the Elden Beast.

Lichdragon Fortissax (Mardu)

this one is tough. lightning magic is very red, and he's also dead, so rakdos for sure. but he's loyal as well, so mardu?

Messmer the Impaler (????)

honestly not sure on this one

Matyr, Mother of Fingers (Blue)

could be an argument for colorless here

Putrescent Knight (Black)

zombie knight

Radahn, Consort of Miquella (Boros)

radhan is very boros-coded.

Regal Ancestor Spirit (Green)

probably the most green of all the bosses, but could also be temur or simic.

Rellana, Twin Moon Knight (Azorius)

Gives a very Azorius warrior vibe. martial skill + magic

Romina, Saint of the Bud (Sultai)

scarlet rot = golgari, but not sure what the tertiary color would be

Scadutree Avatar (Abzan)

this one feels easy. erdtree avatars are very selesnya, and this one is guarding the scadutree, hence the black mana

what do you guys think? to me, Elden Ring feels like a pretty seamless IP to incorporate into magic

so I always liked the idea of the "Battle of five armies" in the Hobbit even though Bilbo is unconscious for most of it.

I'm looking online and the make up of the 5 armies is kind of up to debate which will be fine for a game of commander since it'd be for rough for anyone not playing elves or goblins.

Option A "Free for all", just maybe try to agree on bracket/power so one faction doesn't pubstomp the table.

Option B. "Archenemy" the Orc/goblin force is clearly the antagonist so why not lean into that.

Option C "Horde magic", make a goblin/wolf deck to pit against the table.

I feel like I’m forgetting the classic moments that made me love magic, share some of your favorites with me please.

Looking for something symbolic. He was a big big fan of Bolas, but all of the Bolas cards he liked are very expensive(out of my range right now.) We've been playing magic together for the better part of 10 years. I miss him dearly. Magic was his life. I was hoping to find something reminiscent of eternal friendship. I appreciate any help.

Before I invent this for my family, just checking to see if there are already any awesome community resources.

Has anyone developed a game using Magic and magic mechanics where it turns into a kind of deck building dungeon crawl?

The basic premise is to start with a hero and access to your "homelands" as mana sources, along with a few spells. Through playing an rpg style campaign you'd gather lands/mana sources, treasure (artifacts), allies/summons, boons (enchantments) and spells...building up a deck in the process and facing off against "encounters" with packs of enemies, villains with their own mini decks...stuff like that.

I know games like this already exist, but I'd love to use it as a less competitive way to teach kids Magic basics along with the idea of TTRPGs. Maybe I'm crazy.

Anyone know of anything like this out there already, beyond Horde magic style situations?

I posted an Intuition for sale for $480 CAD/$340 USD. I thought the quality was quite good. A prospective buyer pointed out something I've never noticed before: On the back, top left side in the picture, there are two lines. They actually extend all the way across to the right side of the card, but you can't see the lines unless the light catches it right. They look like an indent, but you can't feel them directly on the card, so it's either a print error or a very slight <1mm indent that you can't really detect by touch.

When this was pointed out, I had no idea how to actually assess the value of the card. I looked at some online sources, but it's pretty ambiguous for this sort of thing. I opted to take it off my listing, but the buyer offered to buy it as damaged, for $300 CAD/$213 USD. This feels like a tremendous markdown for an error that doesn't affect the playability of the card (and considering that some near mint versions are selling for $630 CAD. And I'm not just going to automatically take the word of the person who's trying to haggle the best possible deal for themselves.

So I'm hoping there are some helpful thoughts and opinions here.

What’s the most fun Rule Zeroes your commander pods use? Small or big changes. I wanna see how different people play.

Mark Rosewater claims that the original Skullclamp design that he submitted to development gave the equipped creature +1/+1 instead of the iconic +1/-1 that we know today. I got to thinking about the implications of a pre-development Skullclamp world. I think it clearly would not be as busted but how prevalent would it have been during its time and would it have the staying power that it has now?

Just an open ended question meant to spark discussion. I am interested in hearing y'all's thoughts. Thanks

I recently got into magic a few years ago, but I feel like there is a lot of lore that I am missing. Are there any great YouTube or podcasts that sum up the lore in an enjoyable way?

i dont think i understand how or what im building around in a commander deck with Phelia, Exuberant Shepherd as the commander any tips or explanations would help (im also pretty new to magic as a whole so the more simple an explanation the better)

Hi all. If I have a Crystalline Sliver out granting all slivers shroud and choose sliver for Arcane Adaptation, can I use the first ability of Sliver Overlord to search my library for a sliver?

I was confused by the wording on Arcane Adaptation - are all creature cards in my library counted as slivers with shroud, meaning I can’t use overlord to tutor for them?

One of my closest friends is leaving the country pernanently (moving) in about a month and I want to make them a Boros EDH deck.

Sounds good, right?

Wrong.

Outside of Gruul, this is my least played colour combination (yes, I'm not the biggest fan of combat) and I'm very firmly in the "a deck nust include Black for me to have fun" camp. So, I turn to Reddit! Would anyone happen to have an [[Arabella Abandoned Doll]] deck which is also Goblin typal?

Goblins and their favourite fantasy creature, the little buggers.

Any bracket is fine - I'll probably tweak it regardless to add my touch to the gift - but we mostly play at a 3 in our pod, so around there is probably the best range to land at.

Hi there! It's been more than a decade since I last played MTG (almost two decades actually). I'm coming back and bringing my GF with me :)

I saw there was a "magic school-themed" set a few years ago, Strixhaven. I feel like that would be a great place to introduce the game to her, considering the vibe and themes.

Can someone please share some deck lists from that era? Goals:

1. Spend less than $600 USD. If there's something particularly cool, we can go over that a little
2. Build one beginner-friendly deck and one with more interesting mechanics
3. Simple 60-card decks, no sideboards. I understand Commander is super popular nowadays, but it'll just be the two of us for now
4. Decks can have banned/restricted cards, since we'll only be playing against each other

Also, what do people use to share deck lists nowadays? Moxfield?

Last but not least, do you have any suggestions for places to buy cards? They must ship to Brazil.

Thanks in advance!

(edit: wow I simply can't format this bullet list)

When cards such as mind's dilation allow you to cast a spell, without paying the mana cost, can you still choose to cast the cards for free via their alternate costs like overload/haste etc. to get the extra effects? Or can you only cast using the default mana cost when you are being allowed to cast a card for free.

And can you activate additional costs like kicker when you cast without paying? Or again are you limited to just the default cost?

Thanks in advance

Maybe something utilizing the storied mechanics or adventures or something like that? There is currently only gandalf but its more wizard tribal i feel.

Deck List: https://moxfield.com/decks/xM9NwaDh8km1E-KJnznGdA

Hello, I apologize for the long hiatus, but I have some really cool Historic decks to share! The combo of Squirrel Girl, Shang-Chi and Enduring Vitality got a lot of buzz in preview season, but it has not seen any success in Historic. This is mostly because it is a tough to assemble three card combo. Mono green is also just not a great color in Historic, if you are not playing devotion. Playing this combo means you do not get to play the card advantage engine of [[Kiora, Behemoth Beckoner]] and [[Outcast, Trailblaser]] that allows mono green devotion to grind out the midrange/control matchup. While the combo being instant speed (if you get all three in play) and enduring innocence's recursion, does make the combo suprisingly resilient, it still struggles into decks like Jund or Dimir Midrange.

With that said, I think I cracked it with another Marvel card that I have not seen many people talk about. That card is [[Earth's Mightiest Heroes]]. This card has a lot of text, but you can effectively think of it as Teamwork 5 you win the game. Being able to put all creatures from the top 8 cards of your library, in combination with Green Suns Zenith, makes assembling the combo very easy and very consistent.

Some other notes on the deck.

Enduring innocence, Badgermole cub and leyline of abundance provides you more mana than you will ever know what to do with. It is not very hard to dump your entire deck on turn 3.

Chittering Illuminator is secretly the best card in the deck. It provides you so much card advantage on your combo turns. Prismatic Vista and Nurtering Peatland and Disciple of Freyalise in your mana base allows you to reset the top of your deck if you brick.

Beast Whisperer is weird as [[glimpse of nature]] is legal in the format. I would probobly trim it down to 1 but I found it to better then glimpse. You want to play glimpse before deploying all of your mana dorks and this deck wants to play beast whisperer during your combo turn.

I would play 4 birds of paradise over 4 delighted halfling. Giving squirrel girl encounterable is relevant but not having an extra green pip for chittering illuminator came up more.

This sideboard sucks and I have really struggled with it. I would completely rework it if you wanted to try this deck.

Hi everyone,

I'm pretty new to Magic and have been getting really excited about the upcoming Marvel set. A local store currently has these on sale, all below MSRP:

• Play Booster Box – €113.96
• Bundle – €37.96
• Commander Deck: Avengers Assemble – €61.71

From what I've read:

• The Play Booster Box seems like the best value if I just want to open packs and collect.
• The Bundle has the promo, lands, storage box, and accessories.
• I also like Commander, so the Avengers Assemble deck is tempting.

My goals are:

• Collect cool Marvel cards (especially borderless variants and hopefully some of the Infinity Stones).
• Build a few fun casual decks.
• Get the best value for my money.
• I'm not trying to make money by opening packs.

Would you:

1. Buy all three while they're below MSRP?
2. Skip the Bundle and just get a Booster Box + Commander deck?
3. Buy two Booster Boxes instead?
4. Spend the money on something completely different (singles, Collector Boosters, another Commander deck, etc.)?

If you've been following the Marvel previews or have experience with previous Universes Beyond sets, I'd love to hear what you'd do in my situation.

From what I found looking into it, it seems fine since I'd know the full rules text for each card with 100% certainty, but what is the actual etiquette with it and what is the likely outcome of having them in a deck in an RCQ+ type setting?

I'm referring specifically to the JP alt art mystical archives; how common is it to have an opponent ask for oracle text, even if they know the card? Would there be any circumstances where I could get penalized even if I know the rules text? And this is with multiple cards being jp alt art, so more than 1 distinct card that would be foreign language.

I started playing Magic in 1998 and it was a big part of my life for well the majority of it at this point. I remember I signed up for the guru program when I was like 10 just because I wanted the free starter kit so I could have more cards than the two precons I'd managed to afford. They never showed up, but I got 5 basic lands randomly a year afterwards, hooray stupid lands.

Anyway I want to get rid of the last of my collection, its a bunch of stuff I forgot I had stored after I sold off my main collection back in 2018-19, it was bulk, but since I got out these scanner apps have popped up, so I scanned through four or five boxes, enough to give me a head ache and a sore neck. I wasnt expecting much value but .. https://drive.google.com/file/d/1kK0dKjirJUIq4ChalqXbShYl2TU7BgEW/view?usp=drivesdk

I'm out of touch with the community the LGS I used to haunt closed shop, my younger family and friends kids arent the type, I can't just throw them away because they're Magic cards and their importance is still some kind of core part of me apparently regardless of how I feel about the game these days. Plus I'm - not rich, a human and not zealously charitable. I also want them to go somewhere they'll be exciting or cool or whatever to someone again. I could just sell off the stuff I put in binder based on the info from the app, but that's only like 600 some cards out of maybe 2500 that I looked through and there's well over 10k total.

Are there any groups that go for big collections or should I try to find like a convention to take them to? What would you do in my shoes?

Oh and the Guru lands aren't in this, my mother burned my first collection..

basically what is the best deck you can build using only secret lair cards. id say use the legacy banned list to remove the really broken stuff like sol ring and mana vault. im not sure what the best thing is but its interesting to consider

As the title says. What MTG art do people really like or art stands out to them?

Some of mine favorite pieces are

[[overlord of the balemurk]]

Extended art version of [[strix serenade]]

[[golden glow moth]]

[[progenitus]]

[[gift of orzhova]]

The OG [[Dark ritual]]

Year of the rat SL [[pack rat]]

I’m wanting to hang a bunch of MTG art work through out my home and would love to see others favorites. Who knows, I might find some new art that becomes one of my favorites