Last week, we had a rough redwood fence installed. Per the contractor the wood they use is ready for staining and doesn’t need to wait.
This fence is a mix of sapwood and heartwood, so red and pale all over, and while I love it, I am trying to find something to make it more neutral because our house is quite cool toned.
I chose three stains to test today and they all look awful to me. The roughness of the boards really soaks up the stain and makes it so dark in those areas. This hasn’t dried the full 48 hours yet, but I feel like I’m not going to see much of a change.
Is the answer just to sand the fence? I read that it shouldn’t be necessary on a new fence but maybe I need to.
There are three semi- transparent stains here. The first 3 from the top down are applied with a paintbrush -Armstrong Clark chestnut, armstrong Clark rustic brown, Armstrong Clark natural oak. the second set of 3 are the same stashing the same order but applied with a foam brush. They all look awful to me. Is this just normal? Does it look off to me because I’m only seeing small sections up close?
I’ve also attached some pictures of how rough some of these boards are along with some of the nicer boards.
Any advice is appreciated! Any stain recommendations to bring this more neutral as well as recommendations on application.