r/datingoverthirty • u/General_Paramedic_96 • 1d ago
Is my place a turn-off?
During the 3rd date we decided to go to mine (I offered hers first but she said it's a mess). Looking at my apartment, she (semi-)jokingly asked, "do you have OCD?". We had good banter and stayed over midnight, so I thought she left with a good impression. However, the next day she rejected me, leaving me wondering about the reason.
Here are pics of my place that I posted to r/malelivingspace, where the consensus seems to be that the place is clean but not comfortable, in particular lacking color and personal items. I'll add that while the stove has safeguards precisely because I don't use it, she already knew I (38M) don't cook. Also (and I feel silly even mentioning it), all of my shoes on display were grey. How likely is it that the overall impression of my place was a deal-breaker?
P.S. I used to think my apartment is near-universally likeable, so it wasn't even on the list of things I cycled through as potential causes. However, a couple days ago another girl rejected me after coming over during our 1st date, and explained it by the insecurity about me seeing her messy place and hating it there (she laid out her thinking and past experiences going into it in great detail, so it sounded credible). This is where I decided to make this post.
UPD: I did not make a move on her. This is because after the 1st date she proposed to see each other "as friends" with no expectation (due to me giving her promiscuous vibe). That said, it was her idea on the 3rd date to go get intoxicated at mine.