r/TrueAtheism 21h ago

The Strange Logic of Petitionary Prayer

22 Upvotes

To an all knowing, all powerful God, prayer is completely redundant, and honestly, a bit bizarre. If God already knows every thought in my head, every outcome before it happens, and possesses a divine plan that is by definition perfect, then what is a human monologue supposed to accomplish? Begging an omniscient being to change its mind implies that either God’s original plan wasn't ideal, or that He requires constant flattery and reminders from mortals to act mercifully. It ultimately feels like a strange psychological feedback loop where people talk to the ceiling, attribute random coincidences to "answered prayers," and conveniently ignore the unanswered ones, all to convince themselves they have a dial in line to the universe's master clockmaker. 🙄


r/TrueAtheism 3h ago

What's y'all take on metaphysics?

2 Upvotes

This one term frequently comes up in discussions about God. I am a naturalist and thus don't believe in anything metaphysical.

But stuff like Logic and reasoning don't have purely physical footings. I reconcile with this by saying that we can't function without having a belief in both those things.

But, does that warrant further metaphysical claims about God? Are there any naturalistic explanations for those things?

And as an extension, what do you think about belief in things without any apparent physical evidence supporting it, i.e. faith?


r/TrueAtheism 12h ago

Hola chicos

3 Upvotes

Estuve viendo recientemente las ideas de espinoza como la sustancio y el Deus dice Natura y me hizo preguntar si solo le cambiamos el nombre de dios a universo sus premisas axiomas y metafísica encaja con el ateismo o cual es su opinión de espinoza