r/Banking • u/Rayp93 • 14h ago
Advice Debit card stolen out of mail and used to withdraw $3500- how to handle this?
Hi everyone, I recently, seemingly, had a replacement debit card stolen from my mail, activated, and somehow used to make two withdrawals from 2 accounts at two seperate branches totaling $3500 ( one business and one personal, $1700 and $1800)
I noticed my two debits were expired and my mailing address was never updated since we bought a new house in 2024. I proceeded to change my mailing address in my banks app and requested new cards. One card arrived promptly but a second card did not. I looked at my balances today and noticed that yesterday there were the 2 withdrawals on my accounts USING THE SAME DEBIT CARD. I don’t know how that is even possible.
I called the bank right away, they froze and closed everything and advised to go in branch tomorrow in person to open new accounts + file an affidavit and start the fraud process. The customer service rep said that the card used was mailed a little over a week ago (meaning it was mailed to the correct address), activated 2 days ago, and then used yesterday to make the two withdrawals. I do not have more info than that right now as I am waiting till banks open to go in person (unsure if it was teller or ATM, PIN code used or not, how they activated it etc- will be getting more details in branch hopefully). How could that even happen? How likely am I to see that money returned to me?