r/AITAH • u/Still_Equipment_968 • 17m ago
AITAH for leaving my stuff in his house even with his bad communication?
I met Simon in July 2024 during an African jam in Montreal. Something clicked, it's like if we knew each other since always. We exchange phone numbers and called each others a few times afterwards.
Bare in mind that he was 60 (looked much younger) and I am 40, and i am still modeling. I didn't know what our potential connection could be like, but I felt that he could be a good friend, at the same time by now in my life I try to keep in mind that even if men are kind they probably also want to see what's under my skirt, so I generally keep a polite distance.
At that time, i was living in the south of Montreal and he was living way up north, about 15 hours driving, working as a school teacher for native American kids on a reserve. He was gone all year round except for summer breaks (so that's when we met.). My daughter just turned 18 and I started to think about a nomadic life but didn't act on it yet. My appartment at the time had so many problems and my landlords were awful people.
One day in September, Simon called to tell me that he just bought a house, only 5 hours north of Montreal, in a town he loved. That was the second or third time we've ever talked, so I found it surprising that he would share that with me. Later, I learned that his parents died when he was 19, he never really had a family, and also even tho he loved his job, he recently had to move to teach to another reserve further away, so he needed to make another circle of friends and it was still pretty lonely.
That's also why he bought a house, it was very cheap and he could move there directly after his retirement, that he planned for summer 2026. He could also go during summer breaks meanwhile.
Still, I was surprised that he shared this with me as we barely knew each other. It seems like he already considered me his friend (or potential girlfriend we don't know)
Because he could go to live in the house only during school breaks, and because I hated my appartment, he proposed me to go and stay there, for free. He said that he would be happy that somebody could be in the house from September to June. Especially in the winter time.
Of course I refused for several reasons including that I barely knew him. But also, I couldn't just break my lease and go, AND, it was way too far and in the middle of nowhere. Yes it was free but what do you want me to do up there? Its still 5 hours driving north and even tho the town is active in the summer it's dead in the winter. In the summer, when it's whale season, there's loads of tourist, it's next to Tadoussac, it's very popular. But in the winter it goes back to his population (164 people lol).
But yes, the house was amazing, with the view directly on the St-Laurent River. I said thank you and wish him luck to find somebody but I refused. I said maybe next year but I really didn't know.
Then we barely kept in touch. I did my last year in my appartment. Which was so shitty because I payed 1400$ per month and I was gone more than half the time... I went in the states for a modeling tour for over a month, later on I backpacked in Thailand, came back and went in California... My daughter turned 19 in March 2025, she was working, we were barely seeing each other.
I've lived in Quebec for her all my life as her dad lives there. We were together for 3 years and then broke up but we stayed in good terms. Even tho I've never really want to stay in Quebec, I did, I needed to respect the person whom I made the kid with and not just fuck off. So I traveled a lot with her when I could, brought her in 17 countries total, like once per year. Before she entered school for good at 9 years old (I homeschool before) we spend 3 to 4 months per year in cheap countries like Mexico, Guatemala, India, Thailand... Everytime I needed to come back I felt depressed but that was it. I was looking forward to be free. But when you are finally free, then you're a bit older and a bit more scared. I was almost 40 when she started to be independent and my professional life was doing so well, so I really didn't know if I felt like starting everything again.
I became a mom so young, I had so many responsibilities from a young age and I was more and more thinking about leaving everything and going nomadic. Or just, travel with no retuen ticket, just to see where life would bring me.
Finally after my trip in Thailand I made the big decision to leave my appartment. So I ended up my lease in June 2025 and gave or sold everything. I kept the equivalent of maybe 2 full cars.
I found an amazing place where to stay for the 2 months of summer I was staying with one of the organizer of a festival where I participated as a seller. I'm a designer so I have a lot of fabric, 2 sewing machines, dyes, a small mannequin... That's one of my job and I love it. Anyhow, I worked very hard all summer long because I knew it would be my main income, all of this while my roommate had pretty serious mental health issues (she was slowly lowering her meds) and the reason why her psychiatrist didn't keep her at the hospital after an accident was because she had a "safety net" at home. That was basically me. She didn't realize the weight she put on me, and I needed to manage her, keep the house perfectly clean for her to be happy and all this while creating and dyeing clothes, posting on social media... I made it. I smoked a lot of weed and sadly skipped many meals because it wasn't a priority.
In August 2025, last year, I needed to start thinking about what was next. Then of course Simon came back in my mind. I thought I could maybe go to the house for 2 or 3 months. Just before leaving for a big trip somewhere during winter time... What I earned during the festival plus the money I had aside was ok to live for some months but not too many in Quebec as it's more expensive - my goal was to fly somewhere more affordable, maybe in November (again Thailand, or South America) and make and sell clothes up there (and I finally made it in Peru! 😀)
So I reached to Simon, he was very happy if I could go stay at the house from September. For me, his offer and attitude being exactly the same as the previous proved me that he was truly looking for somebody to keep the house more than a romantic relation. And anyway, he wouldn't be there cause it was school season.
He told me he was aware I wouldn't find any work up there so if I didn't have money, it was ok for me to not pay rent. I still sent him 400$ per month when I was there. When he said that, I found him definitely strangely too generous but I made his astrologic chart and that reassured me a lot, it said he loves to share his place and have roomates... That he was truly generous.. I still believe this, but yeah.
We talked and I decided to first go to have a look at the house. I drive 5 hours to get there and of course I felt in love. The country side, the view straight on the river, being able to walk on the beach... He told me that his good friend Peter and his wife from the village could help me with anything I needed. That there was a community and that they already knew about me, that I was welcome.
So I brought all my stuff. The decoration was pretty ordinary or absent so I took charge of it. I asked Simon by phone first and he said that it was ok as long as I wasn't bringing furniture. He knew that he would finally bring everything he owned in the house in the summer 2026, but he didn't really have any decorations yet. Just the basic were there like a fridge, over, one table, one comfortably seat, one mirror. Not much for a 5 rooms house. So I made his place very pretty and I was sending him pictures from time to time.
I finally kinda started a life there. I made Peter and his wife who was the owner of the only b&b in town. I also learned that my good friend Catherine knew them for like 40 years, I didn't know. They were all from Chicoutimi (the closest city). They were all more or less 60 years old but there was also younger people of my age in the village.
I started to see them regularly and have some drinks. We planned for me to work at the b&b next summer. I met everyone else of the community. Partied with them a lot, came back at the house pretty trashed at midnight regularly, after drinking smoking and playing music. They were very good people (but good drinkers). Everyone in Quebec knows that people in Tadoussac are the greatest party people in the province.
The rest of the time, I was smoking weed alone at the house working on my clothes or making music. It was a bit heaven. Sometimes I was visiting Catherine in Chicoutimi. Remember I have never been a young adult, I went straight to teenager to mom and I couldn't sleep or wake up when I wanted. I needed to care for my baby everyday at 21.
The fact that my rent wasn't too high also allowed me to get high as much as I wanted and experience for once what it was to not care about tomorrow. I even started my page on Reddit where I was filming my progress with my flute, guitar and dance.
The more the time flew the less I was thinking about my initial plan to travel in the winter time. November came: I made a small market with Catherine where I was seller my clothes. Then December came, it was family time for Christmas. Harsh and cold winter started and I discovered that I could in fact deal with it. I was shoveling the yard and it was taking me more than an hour. I was bringing wood and making a fire downstairs. I was making a big grocery that would last at least a week cause sometimes it was impossible to go to the grocery because of the road conditions. I got used to the life up there. I was talking to Simon sometimes but not often. It was weird to be in his house, after all I saw him once in my life for like 2 hours. But I trusted Peter, all his friends and the community.
Then started my awful tooth pain in January.
That same tooth that made me suffer when I was in Thailand the year before. When I was in Chiang mai, I went to the dentist, they checked my tooth, said it was done and I needed to get a root canal. Otherwise it should be taken off. I was a bit flipping out. I decided to think about it first, and then decide... But then, I don't know why or how, but the pain went completely away! So I did nothing except taking care of my teeth the best I could. Btw I was really scared because I already had a filling on this tooth 2 year before and they NEVER could get it to freeze totally. So I could feel everything. They weren't sure if the filling would last because they couldn't do it properly. They tried to freeze it 3 times on 2 different occasions and 2 different dentists never found the nerve 😭 so I really didn't want to get anything done again on this tooth (unless I was under anesthesia)
Months passed, and the same pain came back January 2026. But then it didn't go away.
One week, two weeks... Then, I met an old friend who was back from Mexico - she just returned from the dentist!
So I thought, what a good idea. For the same price I could pay for a flight, and get the dentist plus a little trip! Canada is 3 or 4 times more expensive for dentists procedures. And, I read that it's much more common in Mexico to get it done under anesthesia. I really wanted to go and get done with it. I planned to travel for like a month.
At this time, I loved my life in the house in the north even if it included a lot of drugs. I was really free. I was a bit stressed to think about working at the b&b in the summer for different reasons. Even if Peter was fun to party with he could be pretty authoritarian out of nowhere especially when drunk and I couldn't really picture him having authority above me. Everyone else in the town also had some type of issues and none of them traveled the world as a freelancer all their lives like me. But I liked them because they were all very alive.
Another thing that was stressing me is being a pretty single girl of my age in a isolated town basically like a prey in a town of haunters. All the men would soon come to know about it. The day I was flying to Mexico, a guy I have never met from my town invited me for a ski-doo ride. Of course I didn't go because I was flying out but 2 other ones also contacted me and I really don't know how all of this would have ended. All the women of my age were either already taken, ugly or/and fat, or had mental health issues.
Not mentioning Simon - sometimes during parties with Peter a d his wife they were mentioning him, saying I might end up with him when he comes back. I was always telling them to stop because I barely know him. But they were like "well we don't know!"
They were like their parents to him, that's what I understood. Because sometimes I would try to reach him and it could take 2 weeks before he's get back to me but he was speaking with them on the phone regularly, at least once a week. Like it's not because you are in the north that you don't have Wi-Fi or a cell phone tower. Its 2026 for everyone even Cri native American Nations on Maingan.
He never told me anything meaning he expected more - except once. We were supposed to see each other at Christmas but we didn't. He was very sorry he couldn't come and he texted these words "I was burning desire to see you"
I didn't know what to reply from this so I didn't reply anything specifically to this. And then nothing along that line ever again. So ok, maybe he was drunk, no idea....
So when I decided to go to Mexico, I was basically going to the dentist in my head. I didn't have that much money aside at that time and I didn't really feel like traveling. I liked the little house in the north. All my skills were improving, dancing, playing piano, guitar and flute.
I just wanted to have an anesthesia. Peter was insisting on me going to the dentist in our town. I called and there was 2 months wait. It was the same everywhere. I was like fuck it it's not a big deal, it's one straight flight to Cancun, 5 hours, and I can go to the dentist next day and relax under the palm trees straight after. I reassured everyone I would be back fast.
But yeah.
You understood. I didn't get back fast. In fact, after Mexico I went in Peru and now, July 2026, I'm in Australia. I felt in love as it was meant to be. My daughter is fine and happy for me. And I'm, in fact, realizing my initial dream to travel the world with no return date.
And, believe it or not, I went to a dentist, got an X-ray. My tooth had nothing. I will never understand what the Thai dentist lied the year before. But it's like if life forced me to leave Canada.
Back in May, my boyfriend proposed to follow me in Canada, come in the little house for me, work at the b&b : I refused. I thought about Simon and that weird text from Christmas and I wasn't sure if bringing back a man in his house was a good idea. Coming to Australia also meant for me that I was not only leaving behind the house and all my things but I also wasn't going to work at the b&b.
So I decided that if they didn't have anyone to replace me, I wouldn't go to Australia and I would come back 'home'. But there was a woman in town who already asked for my job so they asked her and she was happy to take it. Which meant that I was free.
I took the craziest decision of my life to follow a guy literally to the other side of the world. We have been together for 4 months, I know it's sounds like nothing, but I felt in love at the first glance (him also) and we have plans for months ahead. We both can work as freelancers and since we've met, we are just both more and more successful in everything.
He caught his flight for Australia on May 14 and at that moment we didn't decide yet if we wanted to stay together. Well I wanted, but I have met many guys in my life who weren't serious, who basically wanted my butt for some time but then that was it. Everytime I hope it was different and everytime it wasn't different. And I have been with many older guys, much older than me. And I know I'm 41, but I might want a other kid. I just wanted to be with somebody at the same stage than me, and I found someone!
We finally made it clear that we both wanted to stay together and I bought my ticket for Australia. When we met at the airport, we decided to not be separated ever again 🥲 I arrived June 5.
So the main thing I was stressed about were my things at the house.
And that's what I wanted to talk about. I knew I wouldn't be able to make it short.
At this point of the story it kinda sound ridiculous but it's not. Simon is a very generous person but very disorganized. And, we don't know if he has romantic intentions towards me. But we probably think so.
I felt so bad not coming back home to clean all my things - I thought I was going to the dentist so of course my stuff were still everywhere. I lived there for 5 months. Dried food, bathroom stuff, all my crafts, dyes, paint, brushes, my instruments... What I put on the wall, carpets, curtains. And then not only my clothes, but the clothes I have made that are ready to sell, and the ones I planned to make and finish and more fabric to sew and create.... And... All my modeling stuff, dresses, wigs and makeup. Technically not that much in quantity but nothing was sorted or packed up.
I thought I wouldn't not follow love to come back home to clean a house.
And, luckily, a month before Simon was going to be back at the house, my daughter went with his friend in Tadoussac. So I asked her if she could pack and clean my stuff and she accepted.
I wrote to Simon, I explained the situation, told him I felt in love and decided to go to Australia. I told him I felt very bad but fortunately my daughter could come up and clean.
And that he could take anything he wanted (including my 500$ AC...) and that we could talk about it when he wanted. I said I was that if there was still things upstairs after my daughter came he could put everything in the basement (full of mold, on concrete, some patches of water, there's nothing in the basement cause it will mold but I just didn't want to be in the way and felt bad so worst case he could put it there until I come back or somebody could take it for me)
He took one month to answer to me.
One month during which I was so worried and felt bad everyday and waited for his news everyday. My daughter told me she went already but she could go back if I needed. I was waiting for his confirmation before telling her she could go and to arrange for her to find the keys somewhere.
He finally wrote me back and just dismissed pretty much absolutely everything I said. And by the time he answered my daughter found a job and couldn't go anymore.
He answered quite calm but said it was disrespectful of me, that he will "bill me soon for all the time he spent just packing the food". And that I should be aware that the basement was full of mold. But then he went on telling me that if I wanted my stuff to be there he would charge me 100$ per month 😂😂😂
I couldn't believe it because I found lockers in the area where I was before (a city) for 30 or 40$ a month. Heated, in good conditions. There's no way a dirty cave could be that expensive lol.
But before I answered be sent one other message, he added "But if you want to come back and have a room I would ask you 250$ per month)
So not much difference for either my stuff in the basement or in a room where I could stay.
But what would I do in that area? None of the work I have as a freelancer work in a town where nothing happens. So that was just a weird proposition. He's retired and has friends in the area: yes I liked the people there but I'm not retired lol.
I talked with Cathrine early July and she said she could take my stuff, which I think is incredibly kind and I would never expect anyone to do for me. It happens that Catherine loves to clean! Like she was really happy about doing it.
She was supposed to go at the house in mid-July but eventually told me that she will go only in August. Meanwhile she talked to Simon, I said is it ok? He'll bring his stuff from Montreal and have my stuff also between his stuff? She said yes... She said he didn't feel bitter on the phone...
Meanwhile, I knew that Simon wanted to bill me for packing my food. Which shouldn't realistically take more than 30 minutes but I know he's disorganized and it looked like a big deal to him. I couldn't imagine the rest of the house....so I sent him 300$. Even if he wasn't at the house yet,...he was officially moving in only July 20th. That's why I was hoping Catherine would go before him.
Then he wrote me back a few hours after telling me his bank wouldn't accept the deposit because it was on his phone it should be on his email, that I should cancel it and make another one with his bank. It was the first he answered to me within hours: because the paiement didn't pass.
I sent it again the way he wanted and, as usual, didn't get any news, any answer, any thanks. It was the same also for the money I was sending during winter tho. He said thanks one or twice. I think he's truly disorganized but it's just weird that he would be able at last for once to answer fast when he didn't get the paiement but fucking slow for everything else, including one month after my message saying I won't be back.
So Catherine called me this morning. She said Peter and his wife just came to her place to bring her bags with my stuff. And she was very disappointed. And told me she prefer to tell me rather to keep it against me. She said I should have asked her at the start (which I did but she changed her date and told me she spoke to Simon and it was ok)
Bare in mind that absolutely nothing in my situation changed since the last 2 months. I planned it, told them, found somebody to replace me at the b&b and my daughter to pack the house.
She received bag with all my stuff and half of it was destroyed. Simon just put everything together: food, crafts, paint, clothes. She said she threw half of it in the bin.
😞
So when he mentioned billing me for packing my food meant in fact packing everything in the same bag with no notion of being careful with anything.
And i think people in the village had been talking about me and changed some facts. None of them knows or remembers that my daughter could have done it. Even Catherine. I told her already a month ago. Now she said that I should have asked her at the start like in June, but I told Simon my daughter could go and he just never replied. And never considered it. Catherine said he couldn't reply because he was in the north in June, I told her that he was still talking to Peter and he wife regularly, it's not a reason.
Also my daughter and her friends would have HAPPILY taken all my food. They're 20 years old and all the food would have been used. This is sad 😢
And not only that, many of my crafts and my guitar and my flute. Like so many things she would have liked to take. I don't even know where is my flute, it's a wooden alto and it worth 1000$. 😔 Also Catherine didn't hear about my AC, so he just kept it and put all my stuff in bags. I really hope my flute is fine.
I understand it's my fault I left everything behind. But nobody communicates with me.
When I was in Peru, Peter started to miss me and started to call up to once a day. He complained about me not answering and I needed to tell him that I wasn't even calling my mom or daughter that often. That I like to talk in person.... He understood and calmed down. So he's able to talk and communicate... Why did nobody told me about the bags, about them picking up the bags at Simon's place, about bringing them at Catherine's house?
I'm supper fast at answering. I talked with Catherine maybe 7 times since the beginning of the month. What I understand is that she feels she's between all of us so I don't want to put more on her shoulders.
But she clearly had a discussion with them this morning in which I wasn't portrait in a positive light. I said I'm sorry a thousand times, I wrote to Peter, he never replied so I made a series of 3 videos in french on my Instagram for him and others to understand what happened, how I'm following my dreams, how in love I am and how sorry I am for leaving my stuff at the house.
Then even if I find 2 persons that care about my stuff and send 300$ it's still not fine.
I understand it's not nice AT ALL. I regret to have left like that for the job I'm giving them but I don't regret to have followed love. I would understand any of their reaction ESPECIALLY if I could have the luck to communicate with one of them.
I don't even know why Peter got my bags, I don't know when Simon packed it. The time Simon took to write to me that he couldn't deposit my money would have been as long as writing to me that he was about to put all my stuff in one bag and somebody needed to come soon otherwise everything would be destroyed lol.
No communication. And it was ok until now, now it's like if I have been a monster and did nothing. I have been trying to do absolutely everything I could since 2 months with all the communications I could. Apart from Catherine I either have no answer or very slow answers.
My mom said that it's obvious he was in love with me and was expecting something. That maybe he had been dreaming about it for months. That's why he was charging me so much to put my stuff downstairs and so little to live there. Anyhow - before writing all of this I felt very bad and now I think it's ridiculous and I feel a little better. Its just material possessions. And I know what I've done is not good but its not the worst thing in the world.