I'm planning to buy a Tesla around December 2026 (unless there's a compelling reason to wait until 2027). I've done way too much research at this point, and the more I read, the less certain I am.
The finances aren't the primary deciding factor since it's my first EV, but I also don't want to spend a lot more if I'm not actually getting much value. I'm looking for the best overall ownership experience, not necessarily the cheapest option.
About me
- 30 years old
- First-time Tesla owner
- Mostly driving alone or with one passenger
- Currently live in New York, but there's a decent chance I'll move to Texas in about 4 to 5 years
- I enjoy technology and driving, but I'm not taking the car to a track
- I appreciate quick acceleration, but comfort matters too
- In 5 to 10 years I expect to have kids, so future practicality is something I'm considering
- I plan on subscribing to FSD regardless of which model I buy
The three I'm considering
1. Model Y Premium AWD (Long Range)
Pros
- Best range
- Better ride
- Lower tire replacement costs
- Lower purchase price
- Feels like the logical choice
Cons
- Worried I'll always wonder if I should have bought the Performance
2. Model Y Performance
If I get this, I'd probably configure it with Quicksilver and the white interior (about a $3k value),so the price difference is a little smaller.
Pros
- Amazing acceleration
- Looks great
- Adaptive suspension
- Feels a bit more special
Cons
- Lower range
- More expensive tires
- Unsure whether I'd actually appreciate the extra performance every day or if the novelty wears off
3. Model YL
I know it's only available to order in the US right now, so nobody has real ownership experience yet.
Pros
- Better interior
- Active suspension
- More room if life changes over the next several years
- Seems like it'd be a great road trip vehicle
Cons
- More expensive
- Bigger than I currently need
- Hard to know whether it's worth waiting for without real owner feedback
What I'm really trying to figure out
If you were in my shoes, which would you choose and why?
A few specific questions:
- Does the Performance still make you smile after months or years, or do you eventually stop noticing the extra speed?
- Do Premium AWD owners ever regret not getting the Performance?
- If you were buying today, would you wait for the YL or stick with one of the regular Model Ys?
- If you could only buy one and do it all over again, which trim would you choose?
Also, assuming I'm targeting December 2026, would you still buy then, or would you wait for potential 2027 incentives, pricing changes, or hardware updates?
I'd especially love to hear from people who cross-shopped multiple trims or have owned more than one Model Y. Thanks!