Hi everyone,
I'm looking for advice on a meaningful upgrade to my current home cinema setup.
I currently have a JBL Bar 1000 MK1 and, overall, I really like it. The biggest thing I love is the convenience: the detachable wireless rear speakers are genuinely easy to use and give me proper surround sound without running speaker cables around the room.
However, I have one major issue: I don't really feel the 3D/Atmos effect. The system sounds good and the bass is strong, but the height and spatial effects don't really give me that "sound is happening around and above me" feeling. I also use the system quite a lot for gaming, so convincing positional audio and immersion are important to me.
I'm looking to spend up to approximately €2,000, and my priorities are:
- A meaningful upgrade in surround/3D/Atmos immersion
- Excellent gaming performance
- A genuinely good subwoofer with strong bass impact
- Wireless/easy setup
- Separate rear speakers
- Preferably no complicated speaker wiring
- Ideally something that is a clear upgrade rather than just a different sound signature
The systems I am currently considering are:
- Sony BRAVIA Theatre Bar 8 + 2× BRAVIA Theatre Rear 8 + BRAVIA Theatre Sub 8
This is currently the most interesting option to me. I'm particularly interested in the Sony's spatial processing/360 Spatial Sound Mapping and the dedicated Rear 8 speakers. It also seems attractive for gaming because of HDMI 2.1 features such as 4K/120, VRR and ALLM.
My main concern is whether the Sub 8 would actually be an upgrade in bass impact compared with the JBL's 10-inch subwoofer. I don't want to spend €2,000 and end up with better surround but weaker bass.
- LG Sound Suite H7 + 2× M5 + W7
This seems very interesting because of Dolby Atmos FlexConnect and the more modular approach. The W7 also looks like a serious subwoofer, although I am not sure how it compares in real-world output to the JBL 1000 sub.
My concern is that it is a relatively new ecosystem and I have seen some comments about connectivity limitations for gaming, particularly the lack of HDMI passthrough.
- Sonos Arc Ultra + 2× Era 100 + Sub 4
I know Sonos is probably the most polished ecosystem and the Sub 4 is highly regarded. However, I'm wondering whether the Era 100 surrounds would provide a sufficiently large upgrade in immersion compared with my JBL.
I have also considered Era 300 surrounds, but that setup seems to go significantly over my budget.
- JBL Bar 1300 MK2
This is the obvious option if I want to keep the detachable battery-powered rear speaker concept, but I'm not sure whether it would be a sufficiently meaningful upgrade from the Bar 1000 MK1.
So, if you were in my position, what would you choose?
The main question is:
Which of these would give me the most noticeable improvement in actual 3D/surround immersion and gaming, while still giving me strong bass and keeping the setup relatively wireless and easy?
I'm especially interested in opinions from people who have actually compared these systems, rather than just looking at the number of channels or advertised Atmos features.
Also, if there is another system I have completely overlooked in the €2,000 range, I'm very open to suggestions.
Thanks!