r/PCRedDead Apr 23 '25

Online RDRMP

7 Upvotes

for anyone who doesn't know, an alpha of Red Dead Redemption One multiplayer (RDRMP) has just been released! for anyone interested here is the link to the setup: https://redmods.com/rdrmp/


r/PCRedDead Feb 04 '25

Bug / Issue Heads Up to PC RDR2 Players Using Mods: There is a save corruption bug with all the most popular cosmetic mods (WhyEm's, RDO, EEE, GFA, etc.)

72 Upvotes

With the influx of new players thanks to the Steam Sale, I thought I'd make a post addressing a known, yet hardly discussed bug (or it might be more accurate to call it an engine limitation) related to cosmetic mods in RDR2 PC.

TLDR - Buying too many items added by mods will brick your save.

1. The Problem

As you accumulate items of ANY kind in RDR2, this includes from clothing/weapons you can buy/find to all the consumables, collectibles, provisions, valuables, letters, newspapers, saddles, etc. (basically anything that will be saved to your inventory - the stuff saved in your satchel, wardrobe, or horse), there exists an "upper limit" that, once reached, will permanently brick your save and will prevent you from saving your game anymore whenever you play that save in the future, forcing you to start over or reload a previous save. You'll know you've reached this limit when you get this dreaded black screen with the message, "Save failed. Please ensure the system storage has free space and try again."

Basically, it seems that when you get too many items, RDR2's engine can't save all the data to your save anymore, so your save is basically bricked as now, you're forced to reload the last save you had before buying all those items. Autosaves are generally unhelpful in this case, as the game typically autosaves whenever you buy items so even if you reload an autosave, you'll still have most of the items before you were soft-locked, so the next time you loot some fine brandy or chewing tobacco off a corpse, the save will just brick again.

2. Who is affected by this, and what do those cosmetic mods have to do with it?

A big reason why I believe that this issue is hardly talked about is because this problem might only affect completionists like myself who wants to collect EVERYTHING the game has to offer. I tested buying out the entire clothing catalog with RDO and WhyEm's DLC installed on two different saves - one that just started Chapter 2 (so barely any items saved) and my 100% complete save with everything collected from the base game - all Cigarette Cards, Letters, Weapons, Clothing, Trapper items, Horse Stable items, etc. - you get the idea. The new save that just started Chapter 2 was able to buy everything available at the catalog without issues, while the 100% save ended up getting the "Save failed" black screen halfway before I finished buying out the modded items in the catalog.

The most popular cosmetic mods like Red Dead Offline, WhyEm's DLC, Eastern's Epic Extras, Gonpachiro's Fancy Atelier, More Pretty Gun, and Smoak's Mega Arsenal are all affected by this bug because they add a boat-load of new content to the game, which will push you towards that upper limit if you were to buy a majority of the items offered in those mods.

Now, I myself don't know if non-modded saves would be affected by this if you were to somehow get 99 stacks of every single consumable/valuable in the game on top of every single letter, weapons, clothing, etc., but I would assume that non-modded players are safe as my own 100% save (which did not have 99 stacks of everything but still a decent amount of consumables on top of all the collectibles/clothes/weapons) was fine until I started buying a large stock of modded clothes.

I don't know where the actual upper limit of items you can keep on your save is since this issue is barely documented online; through Googling I could only find one other Reddit thread where someone had this issue and even then there weren't many solutions brought up there besides just uninstalling the mods or not buying too much stuff.

The only other mention I can find of this issue is on the mod page for the Smoak's Mega Arsenal mod itself, where it states that "Buying absolutely everything has a risk of preventing you from saving due to engine limitations, this includes the clothing the mod also adds."

Searching the "Save failed. Please ensure the system storage has free space and try again." message online typically points to other problems that can bring up this error, but of course I'm making this thread to specifically point out the issue for players who are modding their games and getting too many items.

3. Possible Solution

I reached out to the OP of the other thread talking about this issue I mentioned above, /u/littlebelialskey, and even they pointed out that uninstalling the mods and reloading your save will not fix the issue. If I had to guess, loading up a bricked save in the save editor would likely show that there's a bunch of blank dummy items (since the save editor doesn't take mods into account). Even if you uninstalled the cosmetic item mods, their data is still stored in your save, so the issue will not be fixed. You would need to reload a backup save where you never purchased a modded item at all in order to keep your save's slate clean.

(EDIT: I ended up testing this myself after the fact, and it does seem like uninstalling a cosmetic mod and reloading your save safely removes modded items. That said, I would still keep a backup save just before you uninstall the mod to be safe. In my case, I uninstalled WhyEm's and this ended up messing with all of my weapon customizations as WhyEm's DLC changes the values for many gun customization settings like metals, carvings, and stocks (even some of the base game ones), so I had to go through every weapon I owned and reapply them. You might also mess up your character model if you have a modded clothing item equipped when you uninstall, so remember to take all of them off before you do so.)

The only possible solution I can think of would be if a community-made mod fix were released which allowed those modded cosmetic items to be stored in a .dat file in the root folder of RDR2 instead of being saved in the save file itself. A few other mods such as AMJM Transport and Custom Gang Mod utilize this method, where they store memory from their mods into a .dat file that is loaded with the .asi files whenever you boot up the game. AMJM Transport for example, will store your saved Wagons/Boats and accepted jobs in its .dat file, while the Custom Gang Mod stores all info related to the gang you create such as the NPCs you chose, the level and location of your camp, and your Gang Funds. The only downside to a solution like this would be that .dat files in your root folder will not be able to differentiate saves, so if this hypothetical fix was created, everything you purchased from cosmetic mods would be shared between all of your saves. This could also be an upside, though, as if you were to CTD while buying modded items, everything you bought will still be stored in the .dat file even if you didn't get to save before crashing.

I'm not an RDR2 Mod coder, so I have no idea how feasible or possible this solution would be when it comes to storing purchasable items in a .dat file, but unfortunately it seems like all the creators of the mods I listed above are no longer really active in the community, so I wouldn't expect any of them to upload a new version of their mods that stores items in a .dat file (would be happy to be proven wrong though), meaning that any effort towards making this theoretical solution a reality would have to come from a third-party.

Hopefully this post brings awareness to this (admittedly niche) issue, and helps anyone who Googles this issue in the future and barely comes up with any results. Thanks for listening to my TED talk.


r/PCRedDead 4h ago

Bug / Issue screen bug

Post image
1 Upvotes

I downloaded reality redemption 4.0 to get some higher texture quality etc. but whenever i boot up the game it has this weird lines effect overlaying my screen, does anyone know how to fix it?


r/PCRedDead 9h ago

Bug / Issue RDR2 WhyEms DLC spawning in naked

1 Upvotes

i keep spawning in fully naked. all my horse gear and arthurs clothes are modded and from whyems. ive tried so so so many things to change it. yesterday i had the stuck in guarma issue i fixed by removing every mod and readding them after, but before i did the guarma mission modless, i was naked once so i disabled/enabled interface and overlay in scripthooks config and it appeared when i loaded up an older save to redo guarma before i figured out how to fix it by removing mods.

i havent changed a single thing after adding them back and im 100000000% everything is in place.

my mod load order is correct. i changed the whyems install texture lines in the file from streamfolder to filereplacement. i tried disabling/enabling scripthooks config overlay and interface a billion times. i checked overwrite for whyems in the modloader. i reloaded mods in game using ctrl+r. i tried looking for a custom install.xml that someone made who had the same problem but it got deleted. WHAT ELSE AM I MEANT TO DO?? im at my wits end

EDIT: i deleted and reinstalled every single one of my mods and it fixed itself šŸ‘ i no longer posses murderous thoughts


r/PCRedDead 20h ago

Bug / Issue Game stuttering/freezing constantly.

2 Upvotes

A couple of days ago I bought RDR2 on my pc (Intel i5 12400f, RX 6600, 16gb DDR4). I’ve kept having one persistent issue.

My game will randomly start stuttering, almost 0 frames, basically completely frozen for about a second at a time, and it happens every few seconds. The only pattern I’ve noticed when it happens is in the beginning of missions and when I’ve ridden into towns (like valentine). I’ve only done the first couple of missions of chapter 2 but this has been a recurring problem.

Almost every time, I’ve had to restart the game and it sometimes still starts happening again. I turned off Radeon chill features, my graphics settings don’t use too much of my VRAM, I play on fullscreen mode and I really just don’t know why it could be. I thought maybe rendering in Valentine, but even after I left the town and went back to camp it just didn’t stop. Does anyone know why this happens or how I can fix it? I can barely play the game when it starts happening, and it runs incredibly smoothly when it isn’t freezing constantly.

Edit: forgot to mention, the entire game lags, not just my frames dropping. Like if I press a button whilst it freezes the input just doesn’t go through.


r/PCRedDead 1d ago

Bug / Issue Trying to use ReShade but Messes Up Visuals?

Post image
6 Upvotes

Hi all,

trying to test out RDR2 Enhanced 2025 and Photorealistic shaders (at different times) and they both make my game look like this....

Did an uninstall and reinstall of ReShade, and the ini files, but no avail. Any ideas what in the fresh hell is causing this?


r/PCRedDead 1d ago

Bug / Issue RTX 5070 — Persistent random crashes in RDR2 (ERR_GFX_STATE / silent crash / cutscene graphical corruption) — EVERYTHING tried, still failing

3 Upvotes

Hello everyone, I'm at my wit's end with this and hoping someone here has cracked it.

The problem: RDR2 crashes randomly — sometimes silent (no message), sometimes ERR_GFX_STATE, sometimes a generic "Game Error, please restart." Happens during cutscenes, missions, or just walking around. No consistent trigger. I've also seen colored block graphical corruption during cutscenes even when the game doesn't crash.

Important context: I played this exact same PC/hardware totally fine about a year ago, using keyboard and mouse. Nothing has changed hardware-wise since then. This time around I'm playing with a wired Xbox controller, and the problem appeared at some point since I switched.

Everything I've tried (seriously, everything):

  • Clean driver reinstall via DDU + latest Game Ready driver (610.74)
  • Rolled back to an older driver (581.80, clean install) — still crashes
  • Full game reinstall + Rockstar Launcher reinstall
  • Verified game files multiple times
  • Full Clean Boot (only Microsoft + Rockstar services) — still crashes
  • Brand new Windows user profile (completely fresh) — still crashes
  • Disabled Steam Input, tested with/without controller, controller via USB cable
  • Switched DX12/Vulkan multiple times
  • Disabled Steam Overlay, added -ignorepipelinecache launch option
  • Deleted SGA/cache files in Settings folder
  • Lowered graphics preset, disabled V-Sync, POM set to Low
  • GPU underclocked -50MHz (Core/Memory) via Afterburner — didn't help
  • Uninstalled Windows "Graphics Tools" optional feature
  • Confirmed hardware isn't bottlenecked (CPU ~30%, GPU ~50-100% but stable, VRAM ~50%, temps ~45-50°C)
  • Checked Event Viewer — nothing logged around crash times

System:

  • RTX 5070 (multiple drivers tested)
  • AMD Ryzen CPU (integrated AMD graphics also present)
  • Windows 11, SSD

I've got an open ticket with Rockstar Support that's been bounced between like 5 different agents giving me generic/copy-paste advice (some even confusing my ticket with GTA V). Still no real resolution.

Has anyone with an RTX 50-series card actually found a permanent fix for this? At this point I'm wondering if it's a fundamental RAGE engine incompatibility with Blackwell architecture that just doesn't have a fix yet.

Thanks for reading this wall of text.


r/PCRedDead 1d ago

Bug / Issue Vestigia 2.0 Rain Particles Are Broken

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

5 Upvotes

Vestigia causing very odd rain particle glitches. Tried using the variants that come with the Vestigia install but they dont help. Tried using it with and without rain particles fix and WhyEms rain and they dont help either. Anyone have any ideas? If not I might just switch back to Renewal


r/PCRedDead 1d ago

Pic/Video This Game is STILL Breathtaking... | RDR2 Next-Gen Photorealism ReShade Showcase

Thumbnail
youtube.com
1 Upvotes

Hey everyone,

Just wanted to share a graphical showcase of a Reshade preset I've been working on. It utilizes a custom shaders while keeping the lighting grounded and realistic. I removed the oversharpening resulting in a more natural look. Hope you like it.

Check out the youtube video I made!

Let me know what you think of the changes!


r/PCRedDead 2d ago

Discussion/Question Should I sell my ps5 to buy a pc?

4 Upvotes

So I’ve had my ps5 for about 2 years now and I like it a lot but I feel like there’s not much to do on PS5 games like rdr2 after I finished the story and 100% the game it just got boring and there’s no mods either so I can’t really do much should I switch to PC my birthday is also coming up soon and I really want to ask for a PC


r/PCRedDead 2d ago

Bug / Issue Hello, how do i fix this?

Post image
3 Upvotes

I'm using Catalogue Improvements and for some reason when trying to modify an outfit the game softlocks me.


r/PCRedDead 2d ago

Discussion/Question Modded Gunslinger Jacket

Post image
1 Upvotes

Hey yall, so I don’t know what mod is causing this but for some reason Arthur’s Gunslinger Jacket has been changed to this. And I’m not sure what to do to get rid of it. If anyone could help me figure this out I’d appreciate it so much


r/PCRedDead 2d ago

Pic/Video Arthur had to wait in line for the Valentine outhouse

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

3 Upvotes

An NPC got there first, so Arthur had to wait for his turn. They even had a small argument before the man left. Small situations like this can happen naturally with the bladder system in RDR2 Care Overhaul mod


r/PCRedDead 2d ago

Discussion/Question What's the problem man šŸ˜”

Thumbnail
gallery
8 Upvotes

I bought acer alg i5 12th gen rtx 3050 6gb laptop 2 months ago and played games Like gow ragnarok spiderman remastered etc at medium settings with 60fps cap at which gpu temp was staying at 70 degrees I did the same with rdr 2 because I saw a benchmark on youtube showing it can even run the game on favour quality staying around 70 degrees but guess what happened? My gpu temp is not going under 80 degrees even on lowest settings.sometimes reaching 86. U can see the benchmark in youtube video and mine with low settings.


r/PCRedDead 2d ago

Bug / Issue LML (vfs.asi) causing huge stutters

Thumbnail
0 Upvotes

r/PCRedDead 3d ago

Bug / Issue Latest AMD drivers crashes the game

1 Upvotes

I used a legacy driver from 2022 after wiping drivers with amd clean up utility. This allowed me to launch the game. But legacy drivers mean I can't launch recent games like forza horizon 6.

What do? I have a laptop too so I can't turn off iGPU which let me launch the game but with 5 fps in menus


r/PCRedDead 3d ago

Bug / Issue RDR2 Fullscreen and PC graphics issues

2 Upvotes

I just downloaded RDR2 for the first time and am running into a whole bunch of issues trying to configure the graphics settings.

For context I’m running a 7800x3d and 9070xt on a 1440p 280hz oled.

When I load the game it starts in a tiny window which gets fixed by Alt + Enter. When I do that my adrenalin and steam banners that pop up on loadup are for some reason humongous.

Next when I try to configure my settings, choosing display 0 says I have 0 mb of storage and I can’t save any settings. When I switch to display 1 it jumps to around 5000 mb, but then there’s no option for 1440p resolution and my hz is greyed out to 60.

This is super frustrating and haven’t found any solutions that actually work (like switching to DX12). Has anyone actually found a fix for this?


r/PCRedDead 5d ago

Discussion/Question The Long-Awaited mod is finally COMING SOON!

44 Upvotes

r/PCRedDead 5d ago

Bug / Issue Was there just a mod breaking update?

0 Upvotes

Just logged onto red dead like any other day with the same mods I have been using for the last two weeks, to be hit with a screen that said there was a disconnect between my hard drive saved file and my cloud save file. I choose the hard drive, get into story mode, and most of my mods are now very broken. They still work, but it is not the same and they glitch out like WhyEms DLC outfit changing doesnt work well accessories get stuck on every outfit.


r/PCRedDead 5d ago

Discussion/Question Are there any mods that add Micah's chapter 1 coat to the game?

2 Upvotes

I really want to get this coat in story mode, but I couldn't find any mods that add it to the game. Are there any mods that add something at least similar to it? Thanks. Also, sorry if my english isn't good, i started learning not too long ago. (Wanted to post in red dead fashion, but I couldn't because my acc isn't old enough.)


r/PCRedDead 5d ago

Discussion/Question Question about Modding RDR2 (story mode)

1 Upvotes

So I'm new to PC gaming and PCs in general, I've only had my laptop for about 2 weeks now. I use Nexus/vortex for modding my games and my question is I cannot find an up-to-date version of script hook to enable mods on rdr2. Everywhere that I have read says that the one that they have available Nexus is out of date and will crash the game. I just downloaded rdr2 and have not even started to play the game yet and I'm wondering, does anybody know where I can find the most up-to-date version in order to be able to properly mod my game. Any and all help on this would be highly appreciated, thank you.


r/PCRedDead 6d ago

Discussion/Question What mod is this poncho from?

Post image
3 Upvotes

Does anyone know?


r/PCRedDead 6d ago

Bug / Issue scripthook not working

2 Upvotes

Script hook has randomly stopped working everytime i use it the game crashes


r/PCRedDead 6d ago

Bug / Issue Cutscenes in missions sometimes won't play making me unable to complete them

1 Upvotes

I have some mods installed, and when i was played the mission "Just a social call", the cutscene where you free the stagecoach horses won't play. I moved scripthook out of my rdr2 directory and it was fixed, I still didn't know which exact mod was causing the issue though. Now the same issue is present again in the mission "Honor amongst theives", where the next cutscene wouldn't play after riding up to the mountain with captain monroe, i've seen someone else had this same issue on this sub 3 years ago but the post was deleted. anybody has experienced this issue and has any idea what mods are causing this?

MOD LIST :

ASI mods :

HeapAdjusterRDR2

Rampage Trainer

Immersive Guarma

Better Character Names v2.0

Bounty Hunting - Expanded and Enhanced

Duels

Masked (Bounty and Honor)

TieYourLasso - Hangman Edition

RDR - Contracts

Dog Companion

Stagecoach Robberies

Companion System

Restored Cut Content - Quiver 1.6.6

Custom Gang Mod

NoBlackBars

Take NPC's Hostage

Open All Interiors

Gambler 11 - Liar's Dice

Gun Tricks

SgtJoe Bank Robberies

Rename Outfits In-game

Smoking Complete

Camp Anywhere

LML Mods :

Beta Guarma Restoration Project

Online Content Unlocker

Whyem's Visuals

RDR1 Soundtrack

Beta Guarma Restoration Project

A.R.E.P Reworked Extreme Stumbling

Whyem's BloodBath

Just Bleed Already

Dismemberment for Corpses

Dismember Everyone

Ped Damage Overhaul

Ambient Gangs

Red Dead Offline

WhyEm's DLC


r/PCRedDead 7d ago

Bug / Issue Pixel lines appearing on water when "water refraction" setting is on high

Post image
6 Upvotes

As you can see by the image I've worked hard to make the game look as good as possible at 1080p, however within the red circle if you zoom in you can see pixel lines being rendered on the water surface. This is due to the water refraction setting being at high, I can remove the pixel lines by lowering the setting to medium but this makes the water look far less clear. Does anyone know of any fixes beyond lowering the setting? I'd be willing to try anything at this point, I genuinely have no idea why my game is doing this