r/IndianDefense • u/Brave-Blacksmith-557 • 6h ago
Discussion/Opinions Looking for less credible Indian defense sources
Hey, I'm not Indian and just starting to get into Indian defense watching.
Indian defense modernization is still at a relatively early stage. A lot of absurd claims from Indian nationalists, plus poor media coverage, make defense information pretty unreliable.
But at the same time, people either ignore or moderately downplay the considerable achievements India has made in recent years, which do deserve some credit. The combination of mindless hype from nationalists on one side and dismissive bias from a few others on the other side makes it really hard to observe Indian defense objectively.
I'd like to know: which Indian defense sources would qualify as LessCredibleDefence level? I'm hoping for sources at that bar, but I'd also like some that can meet sdf or spf standards. Please don't recommend any brainrot YouTube channels. I can accept sources at the TWZ level: outdated, derivative, not fully accurate, but not deliberately dishonest.
What about sites like these, for example?
https://defenceforumbharat.com/
https://defencehub.live/forums/india-defence-forum.55/
https://defence.in/forums/
Are any of them worth my time?
Here's one extra litmus test. Does the source agree with, or stay silent on, the following view? In Operation Sindoor (May 7), the IAF fully absorbed lessons from 2021, planned the mission soundly, and the pilots actually performed well and executed the plan effectively. India lost badly that day purely because of a significant capability gap.
If a source explicitly denies that view, I won't waste my time on it.