r/ExteriorDesign • u/Broasterski • 2h ago
Did I goof?
gallery1- front
2-side
3-front door and porch
4-back porch ignore the mess
5- example of how intense the lower color can look in the sun (imo)- I warmed the image up and increased saturation to approximate it
6- Gemini rendition of alternate front
7-same as 6 for the side
8-one more real porch photo, couldn’t change the order sorry
Update: I think I’ll keep it! Seems like the response is overwhelmingly positive.
I went outside and chatted with a neighbor, she and her kids like it lol. She said also that it looks more bold bc the other houses haven’t been done in years.
One question: the reviews on the door are a little mixed, and that’s the cheapest to change. It’s marigold, more orange than yellow. Not a fan of lemon yellow. I want something cheery and already use this color inside a lot anyway. Does it work or should I go with the same navy from the accent?
TLDR- should I switch to 6/7??
I have been getting random compliments on it so clearly the whole world doesn’t hate it. Am I just panicking? I’ve been working nights (nurse) and maybe I’m just looking at this through sleep deprived eyes.
I just feel like the porch reads almost Halloween. I know luxe blue is a violet shade… I love that about it. But it just looks different than I expected, more intense at scale. My neighbors have their horizontal trim at various levels- some 2/3 up like me, some 1/3 up. Neighbor to the left has it 1/3 up the side so I do not currently match his. Mine was previously lower, just like in the mockup Gemini did- the homes were designed so we could switch it up.
I spent well over a month painting samples, trying things. I like the lower blue but didn’t realize how much more saturated the lower blue (luxe blue SW) would be at scale. We get lots of sun and heat so it sometimes will look almost as saturated as #5
Part of my concern is the gloss. HOA told me to use a low luster variety. I have been back and forth with them 3 times doing approvals so I was sick of it and just chose to follow that to the letter… so I did Duration low luster. It’s much glossier than I realized. (Curses).
Thoughts on repainting the front and sides to be more navy? To be clear the lower blue would stay on the bottom 1/3. It just wouldn’t cover 2/3.
Maybe I would use a flat sheen for the middle third, (horizontal slats), hoa be damned? I think since it’s a different “plane” the fact it’s a different sheen won’t be noticeable aside from just being less glaring in the sun. It’s the only part of the wall that is so darn shiny. Or should I recoat the top navy portion in flat as well?
Think I could get away with just doing that in front to save budget. I would repaint the middle third on the sides in flat navy so it’s less shiny, and the white trim would go below that as in the Gemini mockup pics.
Sorry if this is confusing, happy to clarify. Appreciate your help!