Has nothing to do with the suicide attacks Hamas committed during the second intifada
Hey maybe you should criticize Hamas for intentionally putting their own people in danger by operation out of civilian infrastructure, which is a war crime by the way.
If you don’t like seeing dead children, maybe Hamas shouldn’t have reignited a war during a ceasefire by committing the October 7th attack on Israel. War sucks don’t start wars you can’t win.
So you’re cool with strapping suicide vests to children? Anyone glorifying the second intifada should look into the shit Hamas did during it because it’s pretty fucked up
You know he also refused the condemn “from the river to the sea” which if you’re not brained knows that it ends with when translated properly “Palestine will be Arab”
Do you even hear yourself? People being born into an identity isn’t a justification for violence. You can become Jewish, and it isn’t just an ethnicity. But the moment you’re framing the issue as Jewish and not Zionism is telling. This is just the same dehumanizing framework associated with Nazism that you're trying so hard to say you're condemning. At that point it’s not anti-ethno-nationalism anymore, you’re calling for ethnoreligious extermination.
Unfortunately there are endless people exactly like him with no nuance. They claim to be anti-Zionist, but their logic ends up being plainly antisemitic. And they do it while sitting on a high horse, just like with the abortion issue -talking like only they care about “the kids,” while ignoring the underlying dehumanization
The issue isn't Islamophobia, its whether or not you condemn violence against civilians. So you're arguing for 'globalising the intifada' which reads as endorsing terrorism, you didn't dispute it. Such irony calling for a 'better world view' while advocating that moral line.
But when an Islamic country, the UAE, funds an Arab supremacist led genocide in Sudan that’s brutally killing thousands and black African children that’s like totally cool right?
wtf does “westernism” have to do with any of this? Are you not of a fan of women and LGBT people having basic human rights? You pissed that we don’t marry off our 9 year old girls or have massive inbreeding problems because we predominantly don’t fuck out cousins?
The intifada also famously included Hamas strapping suicide vests on children, what a righteous “resistance” oh but I forgot it’s not big deal because your fantasy god will grant them virgins in the afterlife so it’s cool. Yeah nothing rapey and fundamentally demeaning to women about that.
Edit: the guy deleted all his comments, classic, but just so everyone knows he said it’s a morally just thing to globalize the intifada to fight Zionists, Nazis, and westernism. His responses to me said westernism was worse than Nazism and that I was Nazi. He deleted those too it seems.
Double edit: I guess you just blocked me because I can’t see your comments and I’m getting notifications that people are responding to your comments this thread. Another classic Reddit move, respond then block my ability to respond back
Just take that one line he said in the video, about "crimes so grave they offend all of humanity". That's a hell of a line. I agree with that. There are crimes that transcend cultures, religions, politics, history, etc.
And if Mamdani judged every possible person by that same moral standard, even his own guys, I would respect him a lot more.
Because the proof of 'moral clarity' is consistency. You judge everyone by the same standard, even if that means internal critique of your own beliefs and guys.
Ironically enough, I agree with Mamdani's conclusion about Benny. But to claim he's speaking with 'moral clarity' would demand he applies it to all, not only those he's opposed to.
That's like saying I agree with Trump that the Iranian leadership are bad. I can say he's right about that one thing, but would never claim that Trump is speaking with 'moral clarity'.
Because he does and says and believes far too many other "immoral" things, both in and outside of politics, to ever say that. Same with Mamdani.
Celebrated the deaths of civilians on October 8th, before a single Palestinian had died in retaliation
Called Biden a rapist
Said every single service member was a war criminal
Thinks interracial marriage should be illegal
... And more.
But she hates Israel too so she's cool in his books.
That's an exact example of the "blind spots" he has when it comes to people he likes, which is the exact premise of this thread.
And his statement on Oct 8th itself was also more concerned about inexistent lost Palestinian lives than the actual murder of over 1000 civilians and barely mentioned them or even condemned them, just a passing "regret the loss of life" like it was some accident.
Here is some of it, focused more on the deleted tweets, though it sums them up a bit too much, but wanted to find a source that you couldn't dismiss offhand (even if they were true).
There's a whole CNN article on her and Marxism, but that is more of a right wing bogeyman (however it reinforces her pro-Russia / Anti US rhetoric)
One simple question that will tell me everything I need to know about you, before we get into specific examples in my next post.
1-Surely you agree that ALL ped0philes are inherently bad(no exceptions), and ANYONE willfully praising, defending, quoting, etc, any verified ped0phile is a morally bad person(no exceptions), right?
The most obvious current example of this in the US would be Trump the ped0 and MAGA who praises/defends him, right?
So you agree that all ped0s and anyone praising a ped0, are all inherently bad persons, correct?
"oh I'll give you examples. Anyways time to profile you instead" okay?
No, not all pedophiles are inherently bad lol. It's a mental health issue, often most pedophiles get PTSD from their own thoughts, they need psychiatric help and support ❤️
hope that's clears things up instead of being a weird puritan absolutist. got any examples now?
Sure, keep that same non-absolutist energy with Trump and the Epstein files, champ.
Sahih al-Bukhari 5134
the Prophet married her when she was six years old and he consummated his marriage when she was nine years old.
The fact that Mamdani quotes this prophet, even in his formal role as mayor, going so far as to call him a moral compass, show a clear moral blindspot.
I judge MAGA and Mamdani the same. It's called moral consistency.
163
u/hawkandhandsaw 17h ago
How refreshing to hear a politician speak with moral clarity