r/videogames • u/NagitoKomaeda_987 • 5d ago
Discussion / Question Which video game has a fandom like this?
983
u/SuddenValley1899 5d ago edited 4d ago
40k for sure
E: Games Workshop addressed this a few years back with the post "The Imperium is Driven by Hate, Warhammer is Not"
206
u/ltpanda7 4d ago
68
232
u/TinPin94 5d ago
Not all Black Templars, but always a Black Templar
→ More replies (2)103
u/demator 4d ago
Or a guard player with "historicly" accurate models
62
u/Entendurchfall 4d ago
It is always that one Krieg player with swastikas on the leman russ for historic accuracy. Insert my angry German noises
6
u/Bon-clodger 4d ago
It’s funny because krieg aesthetic and uniforms is mostly ww1 french. I remember years ago at a games day chatting to one of the sculptors about this very subject lmao.
→ More replies (1)5
u/SquatProspector 4d ago
Which is stupid as apart from the name the Krieg are based on WW1 France.
→ More replies (1)10
u/Dakotasan 4d ago
Is it weird I always compared them more to WWII Russia?
14
u/Choice_Pitch6822 4d ago
Guard in general especially with literal commissars. Krieg is also weird because their planet is German but most of the city names are eastern European (russian) while their fit is mostly French.
→ More replies (2)6
→ More replies (1)38
u/stapy123 4d ago
Ah yes, historical accuracy in the setting that takes place 38,000 years in the future
→ More replies (1)5
105
u/KingDarkTurtle 5d ago
198
u/kcal44 5d ago
46
u/KingDarkTurtle 5d ago
THE HERETICS BROTHER!
IT MUST BE ANOTHER HORUS SCHEME!
MAY THE GOD EMPEROR LEAD US TO THEM!
19
u/No_Prize9794 4d ago
Brother, Horus has been dead for 10k years, it was the Xenos who stole the pixels!
5
28
→ More replies (4)6
u/witecat1 4d ago
The Mechanicus are borrowing them.
16
u/kcal44 4d ago
11
u/Maximum-Sky-8438 4d ago
13
u/kcal44 4d ago
6
u/Kooky_Assistance2755 4d ago
Now I need a mod for TWW that gives the tomb kings 1930s mob movie voices
21
u/SentenceLocal1453 5d ago
Omigod was this made on fridge 😅🤣
18
u/KingDarkTurtle 5d ago
Holy shit the quality was better when I first posted the gif lmao idk wtf happen
10
7
9
→ More replies (1)4
43
30
u/joetunn_ 4d ago
Helldivers too
38
u/RE_Towers 4d ago
Starship Troopers, which Helldivers is based on, is like one of the biggest examples of this. It has recruitment ads for literal child soldiers and some people still don't get it.
17
u/joetunn_ 4d ago
Yeah kinda sad how many Helldivers players don’t see the satire in every bit of the game design and gameplay. I still hope they release a Rebel faction at some point haha
→ More replies (2)16
→ More replies (8)7
u/Lower_Pension_2469 4d ago
Tbf the actual book is not satire. Fun fact as well, the "would you like to know more?" Parts of the movie? They were added in afterwards because the director didn't like how positive they accidentally made the fascist government they were making the satire off of.
22
u/Yitzben 4d ago
Which is why I like necrons. They're just old men who hate everyone for being on their lawn
→ More replies (2)7
→ More replies (9)9
u/bionic-warrior 4d ago
For real. The guy who got me into 40k was a legit communist. A couple years later when I started playing with new people, I was very surprised when some of them were legit neonazis.
262
u/Ok-Mousse-4595 5d ago
Hearts of Iron
→ More replies (2)77
u/METRlOS 5d ago
Not enough My Little Pony
34
33
455
u/ScurvyDanny 5d ago
Disco Elysium for some fucking reason.
99
u/Majestic_Balance1887 5d ago
It's not that surprising.
83
5d ago
[deleted]
20
44
u/fearthycoutch 5d ago
If you like the play style but want a different setting you might like Esoteric Ebb.
24
u/SpagettiKonfetti 4d ago
A million times this. Esoteric Ebb is like the combination of Disco Elysium, D&D and Monthy Python
4
u/Am_Guardian 4d ago
theres absolutely a joke i can make with the words "monthly python", but can't. any tips?
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (1)5
u/cl0th0s 4d ago
I can second that. Similar play style but in a fantasy/comedy setting. Art is great, lore is interesting, all around fun. I didn't get very far because of repeatedly failing to sneak past that damn griffin. Next time...
→ More replies (1)26
u/SeptimusShadowking 4d ago
I think the problem is viewing Harry as avatar of you in the game.
I'm bad at explaining this but it's more like you are allowed to be one of the voices inside Harry's head. The actions and dialogue options available are things that are within the realm of possibility for Harry not you. Depending on choices made Harry is either actively an alcholic/drug addict or just starting to recover literally the moment you start. Not to mention all the other problems he has. It makes sense that a person in Harry's position would not make good decisions. A person in that position might not even be able to see the good decisions as options, or if they see the options might not be able to make themselves act on them
→ More replies (1)4
u/FoolishGoulish 4d ago
Yeah, that's how I am playing this. It's definitely no BG3 Tav that let's me do a lot of things how I would like to do them (or Scarlet Hollow, for that matter).
But instead I can be his Jimini Cricket and shove him in different directions, whether these are good or bad or absolutely cringe is up to me. But he is a fully fledged character, not a cypher.
29
→ More replies (19)22
u/turpentinedreamer 5d ago
I stopped playing it. I don’t want to recreationally be an asshole. I try hard enough not to be one in real life.
→ More replies (2)54
u/kolosmenus 5d ago
Ah, so you're the sorry cop
15
→ More replies (2)5
u/drainbamage1011 4d ago
I started getting nudged towards Sorry Cop while trying to be "normal". I had to lean into the weirdness more to see where it went.
57
u/DrHob0 5d ago
What? Why? That game's entire existence mocks nazi's
45
u/Syncopia 5d ago
They aren't exactly known for critical thinking skills or media literacy. A lot of them larp as warhammer crusaders and pretend to be one piece fans when those franchises are constantly mocking their ideology. And they like MMA despite hating all the foreigners and racial diversity that made it possible. They basically look directly at their own cognitive dissonance and say "yeah I'm gonna double down on that".
57
96
u/PM_ME_UR__SECRETS 5d ago
Fascists historically struggle to recognize when they are being mocked. See: some 40k fans
54
u/DaereonLive 5d ago
Also: Helldivers 2
22
u/bv310 4d ago
Starship Troopers
13
u/jormugandr 4d ago
I mean... if you go back to the book, Heinlein wasn't really mocking fascism. It was more of an experiment to see if he could use science fiction to make fascism palatable by making the persecuted out-group literal aliens.
There's a (almost certainly false) rumor that L. Ron Hubbard and Robert A. Heinlein had a contest to see who could gull their readers better. Hubbard would try to use Sci-Fi to make a cult seem reasonable and wrote Dianetics. Heinlein would try to make Fascism reasonable and wrote Starship Troopers. Hubbard won and took the whole thing way too far.
I've also heard that it was Hubbard and Isaac Asimov betting on who could create a sci-fi religion.
→ More replies (2)6
u/Scorpiicore 4d ago
Heinlein was also proposing the idea that a person should not have a say in how a society is run until they meet certain requirements. In StarShip Troopers' case, having been in a position to make a decision that will likely result in someone dying, or having been subject to that decision. We need only look at today's SCOTUS in particular to see how being allowed to make decisions without having any idea of the consequences that choice will have for other people works out.
→ More replies (2)9
u/DataCassette 4d ago
The book was unironically pro fascist. It's the movie that was mocking the book.
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (2)26
u/zgillet 4d ago
The Boys fans.
5
u/Hour_Paint_1903 4d ago
"No, see we always knew. The show was just so much better in the beginning, it's slop now. So woke, so political."
Watching sections of the internet 180 their opinion on a show because somehow the literal fucking Nazi character in the earlier seasons wasn't blatant enough.
→ More replies (1)19
u/13THEFUCKINGCOPS12 5d ago
You’d be surprised how many people think that the game is anti communist just because it doesn’t hesitate to criticize it
16
u/Urbane_One 4d ago edited 4d ago
The only thing that all communists have in common is our unwavering dedication to criticising other communists!
5
40
u/Powderkegger1 5d ago
Nazis are bad at recognizing when they’re being mocked.
30
→ More replies (2)10
u/zer0saber 5d ago
Likely due to the fact that the higher echelons of these organizations are educated, and seek primarily un/undereducated individuals, with little emotional intelligence, to do their dirty work
14
u/AbledShawl 5d ago
Fascism, perhaps all extreme ideologies, seem to require a heavy dosage of social disconnection and illusions of granduer. They see themselves as the Rebel Alliance, the Indiana Jones, the ones Raging Against the Machines. They are the protagonist of their story against impossible odds and a powerful organization seeking to keep them down.
So then, why is it that - in spite of everything - they are unable to connect the dots of history and side with working class people? Well, if we're accepting peoples' behavior as a declaration of who they are internally and in private, the simple answer that they straight up lack empathy.
→ More replies (3)→ More replies (10)7
3
u/Objective_Animator52 4d ago
I've never actually met any sort of right-wing Disco Elysium fan? Huh?
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (47)3
191
u/Proud-Enthusiasm-608 5d ago
I love new Vegas haha.
GTA btw
58
u/Nova225 5d ago
GTA is such a perfect example, especially when it was announced there would be pride parades in GTA 6. Everybody smiling about it, for different reasons.
→ More replies (7)27
→ More replies (3)12
42
u/VisualSneeze 5d ago
I haven't played in years, but this was my experience with Chivalry: Medieval Warfare online chat.
14
u/RelocateToHellFor20K 5d ago
Loved Chiv 2, as it dropped during COVID i played it an unhealthy amount. There are some weirdos in that community
→ More replies (6)6
u/Weary-Barracuda-1228 4d ago
Got called a “monkey fucker with dick for brains” by a dude named dildoth 😭
3
35
95
u/Millennialnerds 5d ago
Call of Duty Black Ops Zombies.
52
u/Youpunyhumans 5d ago
I remember the characters from the original black ops zombies were almost like parodies of this, especially the constantly drunk Nikolai and insane Doctor Richtofen.
"Ive run out of vodka! ... I mean ammo!"
"Ive run out of bullets, that means Ill have to resort to... SCHTABBING!"
I miss the old days of COD.
→ More replies (1)9
u/Competitive_Ad_8215 4d ago
OG Richtofen was one of the funniest video game characters of all time. Especially the SCHTABBING line.
84
u/That-Cranberry6575 5d ago
EVERYTHING
→ More replies (1)31
u/No-One2123 5d ago
A better question is what videogames don't have this dynamic?
→ More replies (1)20
u/sparkling-rainbow 5d ago
porn games usually only cater to one of those
11
u/Aethrin1 4d ago
Considering the republican convention/grindr server outage correlation, I don't think the catering is much of a deterrent.
→ More replies (3)→ More replies (1)4
119
u/_Katin 5d ago
Literally the entire gaming community. Some fanbases lean harder into some ideologies
→ More replies (4)38
u/ZenkaiZ 5d ago edited 5d ago
The amount of dudebros who say "overwatch got taken from us when they made everyone gay" even though like 90% of the roster is cis and straight and a chunk of the ones that aren't are day 1 characters.
They also say Tracer's ass got shrank cause of wokeness which never happened but that's becoming a Mandela effect.
So many games have versions of this "it got taken from us" culture war to explain why they hate something they used to love
→ More replies (7)21
u/PowerOfUnoriginality 5d ago
14
u/PostAntiClimacus 5d ago
Yeah but now its 6v6 again. As of like, this week I guess
→ More replies (2)
100
u/piedude67a 5d ago
The badly drawn fucking swastika lol
51
14
u/Dank_Kahoot 5d ago
Im sure this comic would get taken down immedietly just about anywhere if it was drawn correctly
18
u/AmbitiousEdi 5d ago
Nazi symbols are not worth the time to properly depict them
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (2)9
18
u/Skalywag_76 5d ago
I feel like there's gotta be a WW2 game out there that draws them all in... Fortunately, I try not to get super involved in the fandoms of a lot of shooters XD
→ More replies (4)6
36
u/shabba182 5d ago
Helldivers 2
→ More replies (2)14
u/ASidesTheLegend 4d ago
Eh, I think most of the Helldivers community realizes it’s satire and do not actually have fascist beliefs in real life.
14
→ More replies (2)3
u/ThatOneGuyHOTS 4d ago
Ehhh there’s the one guy who is always posting fanart of his blonde white Helldiver executing white women with colored hair and POC.
15
12
23
u/Beonidas 5d ago
For Honor. I've seen teams with emblems exactly as... "ideologically diverse" as that.
3
u/Derpykins666 5d ago
Yeah, people's shield emblems were ludicrous in that game. I'm surprised people were not perma banned a lot more.
11
u/00Raeby00 4d ago
Warhammer 40k
This is the epitome of Warhamer 40k fandom.
3
u/kingkellogg 4d ago
If it were Warhammer they wouldn't even stop to say this was awkward before saying their faction is superior
21
u/nkhowell93 5d ago
Call of Duty, Halo, Battlefield, GoW…basically any war game has the most racist unhinged fan base
7
u/Competitive_Ad_8215 4d ago
Hold up, I bet one group up there isn’t a fan of Wolfenstein.
7
u/iron_penguin 4d ago
I loved the conservative backlash against having the kkk as the bad guys lol.
5
u/BlueCloud2k2 4d ago
Didn't Xitter blow up when they posted the Wolfenstein ad about killing nazis?
→ More replies (1)
19
u/Motor-Travel-7560 5d ago
Average Sabaton concert
15
u/Doomray 4d ago
History nerds, general metal heads and a few actual nazis. All gathered to see a band named after a shoe. Sabaton rules.
→ More replies (1)
8
u/William_The_Fat_Krab 5d ago
GTA5:
Psychopaths
Rockstar Cocksuckers(they will defend every awful decision rockstar does on the game)
Hackers(usually weed addicts who join sessions to blow up everything and everyone)
And the normal casual dudes
Also you forgot the gambler for Fallout NV. There’s always a gambler
Edit: I also remembered a different game
HOTLINE MIAMI:
Fucked up men
Music enjoyers
Gay femboys who ship everyone in the game
Fucked up women
The one normal guy who played it because one of the others recommended it to him
3
3
15
u/Salamango360 5d ago
Most famous MMORPGs... WoW, Guildwars, TESO and many more.
→ More replies (1)4
11
u/Azure_The_Great 5d ago
14
u/zgillet 4d ago
Sometimes I need a reminder that I'm not as weird as a whole lot of other people.
→ More replies (6)12
6
5
6
5
5
4
6
5
5
u/Popcorn57252 4d ago
Somehow Undertale. It's like Christianity, bro, "From the creator of "love each other because you're all wonderful and life is short" comes the fanbase "fuck you if you're not me you worthless dipshits""
5
u/Kajor3003 5d ago
Hearts of Iron 4, probably most paradox games
5
u/SlowpokeIsAGamer 4d ago
HOI4 gets the rap but yeah CK3 also has a lot of the same kinds of community overlap.
→ More replies (1)
4
u/vile-style 5d ago
I think the takeaway is that gamers are generally ignorant from every angle they can manage.
3
3
3
u/smelly42 4d ago
Halo, COD, Minecraft (seriously some wild neo-nazi servers that exist), and helldivers all come to mind.
4
u/witecat1 4d ago
The Persona fan base is all over the place. There are the Shin Megami Tensei fans that also play this, general JRPG fans, then there are the Meme lovers, the people that only know it from Tik Tocks, the people that keep arguing the sexuality of two characters from 4 that have never played the games, the shippers, and people that randomly discovered it via the anime adaptations. It can be a weird fanbase, for sure..
3
4
u/TheMaskedHamster 4d ago
Amazingly, sometimes things have diverse bases because the thing itself is good, and things being good transcends politics and identity.
Until someone finds a reason to get angry, anyway.
→ More replies (1)
4
u/Few-Marzipan-5647 4d ago
Bruh how lame do you have to be to bring real world politics into a video game.
3
u/Weary-Barracuda-1228 4d ago
Black Templar player here, Warhammer 40k is filled with people Larping that they know stuff, people that take memes to heart, and some players (my chapter Specifically) racists.
Like I’ve encountered people on here that are genuinely racist and use the Black Templars as a method to express it by claiming it’s “just fantasy racism bro calm down”
Homie you just compared the Tyrranids to Israel. Please shut the fuck up
5
3
3
u/delaydude 5d ago
Metro.... Beautiful games.... Hideous fan base... Also, people really like to take the genuine messages of some games (true across all media) and WILDLY deform it to somehow confirm their own worldview, Warhammer is probably the most egregious example, I feel bad for normal Warhammer fans.
3
u/Perscitus0 5d ago
Minecraft. Seeing lots of kids and such getting edgy with swastikas built into some of the Minecraft clips on YT and FB. Fair bit of Nazi "humor" in the comments of some of those clips, too. It's just weird.
If the objects are not built explicitly like a swastika, sometimes they'll be just kinda swastika shaped, or it'll look like the builder is about to make one, and change it at the last second, and the commenters will literally just take a snapshot of that moment with a hastily edited crude swastika superimposed over the shape, with other commenters going "ooh, ooh" like apes under it.
3
3
3
3
3















584
u/thespacepyrofrmtf2 5d ago