As we all know, the AppleTV specials have a more lighter and optimistic tone compared to the original specials. Charlie Brown has been treated a lot nicer in these specials, probably the nicest he's been treated ever. Of course, some fans don't like this approach to the franchise and feel that the meaner and crueler humor from the OG specials is missing.
Now, I totally see where these fans are coming from. While I do like what Apple is doing with Peanuts for the most part, I do agree that the new specials are a bit lacking in the classic Peanuts tone. Like I mentioned, the characters have treated Charlie Brown a lot nicer now than back then. Sure, they still pick on him, but it doesn't come across as cruel as it used to.
You could argue that this new direction for Peanuts originated from The Peanuts Movie back in 2015, but I disagree. The writers respected the source material as best they could, while also doing something different. That movie still feels like Peanuts to me even if it's not as melancholy as the OG specials, but that's just my opinion.
Having said all this, I want to raise a point about the criticism that the new tone has received:
Going the other extreme isn't always the right answer.
If Apple went the opposite route and made the new specials even MORE meaner and crueler than the OG specials, I guarantee that half the fandom would still be complaining.
Not everyone will agree with me on this, but I think Peanuts works best when it balances the cruel tone with the more lighter moments. All the characters treat Charlie Brown badly, but they don't out-right hate him. (Yes, I know Shermy said he hated him in the first comic, but I'm ignoring that.) They've all been shown to care about him deep down, even if they'd never want to admit it. As mean as the characters could act towards Charlie Brown, they weren't completely heartless and the meanness rarely went overboard.
That's why I can't stand specials like It's Your First Kiss or Happy New Year. The writers make the characters act way too heartless towards Charlie Brown. They amplify the cruelty that Charlie Brown receives from them to an almost unfunny degree. It just feels needlessly mean-spirited.
Imagine if the newer specials were written like that. Imagine if every character is now a one-dimensional jerk that hates Charlie Brown and they all spend every second of their lives to bully, insult, and mock him. Would that really be better for the franchise? Having every character be mean and cruel to an uncomfortable degree?
I'm not saying you can't have characters be mean to Charlie Brown. I'm just saying that there's a wrong way and a right way to do it. You can have characters act thoughtlessly without making them heartless or unlikable.
Anyway, what do you guys think? Share your thoughts. I'd love to hear what you all have to say. Sorry if I went on a rant. I just felt really strongly about this.