A friendly acquaintance rejected me a while back. We're still on the same uni campus and I run into her and the guy she's close with occasionally. I've been stuck ever since trying to work out whether if he was the reason I got rejected, and I'm deciding whether to send her a short, neutral message or leave it alone permanently. It's a long story but please answer my question: Background below
There’s a story that’s been affecting me for some time so bear with me. I moved to a new city for uni and don’t know anyone. I met this girl from class, “A” and became interested in her. I got her discord and I found she was a friendly person, in week 1 when I missed out on lecture she gave a detailed notes and mostly chatted other stuffs too. She’s a bit older than me and i actually liked her the first moment I saw her too.
In week 3, I asked to grab a coffee together after the lecture. I noticed she was already seated with him, “B” (youngest) and initially I didn’t see him much of a threat. She flatly told me he was just someone from “tutorial from before” which I believed until I found they spent more time outside of class but still at uni too. I also noticed she had a ring on her left hand fourth finger in week 3. B didn’t leave when we were about to part for coffee, and I invited him into the hangout. For example, she had not known that he attended church (when I asked them what they do on the weekends). However, they discovered several things in common, including religion and good at music. Though when she found B went to church, she just said ‘what a small world’ then pivoted to ask me if i went to church as well. She laughed a lot at his jokes and seemed physically oriented toward him. B also mentioned that they had spent part of a lunch break together before the wk 3 lecture. I began feeling like a third wheel, especially since she was laughing hard even before they discovered commonalities. although I believed they had only met a week or two earlier. I remember leaving the coffee thinking ‘really? what is it about him did she see?’ cos I didn’t see B as a threat when I first saw him but after seeing her behaviour had to readjust.
A few weeks after, I asked out A again but this time on an explicit date. She thanked me for the invite but said she was “currently in relationship”. I did accept it gracefully (I thanked her for being honest and wished her luck) and did not continue pursuing her after. That was like a few weeks after the week 3 coffee, not sure if it’s too quick for A to refer to B for the relationship. Tbh I asked her in the middle of the term not really because I thought I had a chance but because I thought asking out at the end of term would be worse/too late till B asks first or something.
Over the rest of the term though, I noticed A and B becoming closer, whilst they did have a group project (from mid term) they paired up at the start of term. Anyway, in the final week, I actually was hoping to say a final goodbye, as a closure. I tried 2 times, arriving the lecture 5 mins early hoping to catch them and just say bye and after the lecture. But I didn’t have the chance to do so because they both arrived to the lecture late together by 20 minutes. I tried to encounter them after the lecture but honestly I saw how two of them were walking close (not touching) but side by side, looking ahead. They weren’t even talking to each other too. And back when I was rejected, I just saw the ring + her statement and thought oh she must be taken (I didn’t intentionally try to steal or ask a taken woman. Whilst I did see the ring, the closeness I saw between her and him made me think it was contradiction). But seeing how close they walked and how they both came to the lecture late together made me confused and we didn’t say bye to each other (it was sort of mutual yea, although someone did murmur as I passed but I couldn’t tell who or what was said but I've wondered since if it was her telling him). She did spend 2 days delay when rejecting me (i saw her typing/untyping for 40 minutes on the day i asked her out but she sent two days after). And if B was the relationship she was referring to , say if A whispered then wouldn’t B have known since week 6? The murmur doesn’t matter to me emotionally much so maybe not productive to dwell on this.
There were few times where I didn’t even leave my room because I felt bad.
Fast forward, us three (more like them + me on the outside, if they even think about me at all) are still in the same program, same campus and uni. There was a break with new term, fresh faces and all that. And yeah, what do u know, we happened to be enrolled in the same course next term too. And there was a mandatory pair project component. I found that A and B were initially not pairs the first lecture, they were in fact in different class too (u had to be in same class for the pair). I don’t think they knew they were taking the course at the very first lecture. But it’s only at the end of the week they paired up and switched to be in the same class. I dropped that course due to other reasons and just thought I moved on.
And a term after (current term), A and B don’t share any classes anymore. I actually ran into B on campus which is what prompted me to start this. And we only had like an hour of coffee last year (me her and him) so I thought he forgot about me (back then he was asking me if i went to like private schools and runs uni society). But in fact when B saw me, he changed direction suddenly, move toward me as if to intercept, there were some pauses as though he wanted to say hello. I later on found out that B doesn’t have any class on that day but A did. She had a class starting at 2pm and I saw him about to leave campus at 2:17 pm (until he saw me and pivoted). I’m not sure if B was with A and spent the break together, before the lecture started. They have no shared course between them. If so it seems to be unusually close into this new term. I wonder if A lied to me when she said she was in a relationship and was developing it with B too.
To be honest when I got rejected romantically, I thought I moved on a week or two afterwards. But I was under the assumption that she was taken BEFORE the term. Ngl constantly seeing her and him together hurt, and some I cannot explain away as ordinary classmate friendliness (like coming to late lecture together or walking close side by side but not touching. actually I never saw touching). And at the week 3 coffee it was when she discovered commonalities with B like they are both Christians and musicians too and I didn’t fit into those two criterias. It was just unlucky so I don’t blame them, when she discoverd church commonalities, she pivoted after and ask if I go to church as well. I don’t blame myself for asking her out because what I felt was real but I also feel like I’m stuck still thinking and all that.
At least academic wise, I got a great internship at the end of this year and will publish a research paper too. I do feel a bit vindicated that I was the bigger person. B is only significant in this story because of her reaction to him. Without A I wouldn’t give a second thought about B, to be very candid with you. (I’ve been carrying all these on the side whilst securing the internship and research publication skull)
How do I stop trying to solve whether A and B were or are together? What should I do? don’t think I can fully accept that I had some brief but for me, intense, connection with her, and that I will never be part of her life. Sometimes I have this urge not to pursue her romantically but to show/insert myself that I did exist. And I don’t want to seem rude or anything that I ‘faded’ because I didn’t get what I wanted. I liked her as a person yea and it’s been a while kinda curious too. Has anyone experienced becoming fixated less on the rejection itself and more on feeling replaced or forgotten? Like what good does it get out of and I do worry I spent so much time.
TBH the whole thing, unlike before, it did make me a lot more cautious not to approach any group especially when it’s just a girl and a guy. Even if they said they’re just ‘classmate’ or ‘friends’. I find it’s easier to hang out with other guys and befriend and less stress too.
I don’t know what to feel good about and whether if I imagined the connection or closeness at all. I remember telling the convo I had with A and the text to few ppl in real life and they said she did like me and ended in wk 6 cooly. I just feel like I need to know to move on