I’m a White Christian female (26F) dating an Indian Hindu Male (29M). We both are pursuing PhD’s in the US and both want to settle here. We have been dating for over a year, and he has been in the US for over 7 years pursuing his advanced degrees.
I grew up in a culture where independence and individual autonomy are the norm, while he comes from a culture and family where family involvement and obligations seem to play a major role. I genuinely have aspired to respect his family na culture, and I have always tried to approach my questions regarding the same with an open mind. However, as we have started recently having more serious conversations about marriage, engagement, children, and our future, some of the expectations that have come up have been eye-opening and a tad concerning to me.
I need an outside perspective. I genuinely cannot tell whether I am overthinking these conversations and differences, whether I am not compromising enough, whether these expectations are culturally normal, or whether some of these things should be considered red flags. If the latter is true, what advice would you give me?
We have been dating for a year, and while his father knows about me, his mother does not. Even with his father, I am not entirely sure how much he knows about our relationship or whether I have been clearly presented as his romantic partner rather than a friend. I have never spoken to either of his parents. On the occasions when they video call him while I am around, I am asked to stay quiet so they do not know I am there.
He explained to me that he wants both a traditional Hindu wedding in India and a wedding in the U.S. I told him I am happy to oblige fully in the traditions he wants for our wedding in India. However, I explained to him that our wedding in the U.S. would be completely different from what he is expecting since traditional Christian ceremonies are relatively short compared with the multiple days of festivities involved in many Indian weddings. What concerns me most is that he has told me the first time I would meet his family would likely be on the video call after our engagement. He plans to tell his mother about me shortly before that, meaning I may meet and potentially even speak to his family for the first time in-person at our wedding… even though they are coming to where we are for his doctorate graduation in December.
The issue that concerns me the most out of everything, is how he is (1) not transparent upon request and (2) how he would prioritize his family in the most delicate life events. I will speak upon the latter first.
He knows that pregnancy, childbirth, and postpartum recovery is going to be medically complex and physically difficult for me because of a medical condition I have, although it is not genetic. During many conversations, I have breached the topic of family involvement. During one very recent conversation, I mentioned how I would sincerely appreciate it if it was just the two of us at the hospital when the time comes and during the first month of postpartum because I have an extremely weak immune system and will be extremely physically vulnerable during that time.
He responded immediately: (1) “I am literally giving up including my folks during the birth of their grandchild, and I was happily doing that for you”, (2) “Well, it’s very traditional and a very important day in my life. And I always thought my folks would be there to be part of my happiness,” and (3) “They need to be at our home when you are released from the hospital because what if I’m too tired to cook?” I explained to him the stark difference in our two perspectives. For me, I am excited to marry him and live my life with him, including strength with him during our most vital life moments. I feel like he will never be able to put me completely first (mentally, physically, and spiritually) when I need it the most. I told him I don’t feel like he is regarding me and prioritizing me the same way he is his parents.
I’m at a loss. I’ve taken both of your advice and have had numerous conversations with him about how that would make me feel in life, but he says that “I’m overreacting because he shows effort through actions, not words.” We cannot demonstrate many of these future situations through “actions” in the present which leaves me wondering if I would always feel this way when I do not know if I will be able to be put first. I’m devastated.
What do I do? Am I being overly sensitive? Any advice is welcomed. Any advice is welcomed and much appreciated!!