r/betterCallSaul 13h ago

Is Kim Wexler Redeemable By Real World Standards? Spoiler

0 Upvotes

This isn’t about whether you like or dislike her as a character. Kim is probably one of my favorite characters of all time but what she did to Howard was despicable, and I love characters that are way worse than Kim Wexler morally. The reason I’m asking is that even though Kim became an awful person in season 6, she’s also the only one that could be considered redeemable by real life standards of the Walt, Jesse, Mike, Jimmy, Kim group. Kim basically is morally equivalent to someone who drives blackout drunk and kills a person, yet is broken by the guilt of it for the rest of their life. They did something truly unforgivable that can never be taken back, yet changed their behavior and act like a good person going forward. When we see the rehab counselor for Jesse in Breaking Bad, can someone who truly stopped harming others, changed, and behaves like a good person ever be considered a decent person after drunk ricing and killing his own kid, a child?

When you break it down, the way Kim and Jimmy behaved towards Howard was a monstrous thing to do. They enacted an elaborate scheme against a wealthy lawyer to scam him into suffering the biggest professional humiliation of his career, seem like an unstable drug addict to his clients and peers in the legal community. They drug him, stalk him, and stole his car for an hour to do this. This is a truly decent person who has done absolutely nothing to deserve this, they have understandable resentments and a complex history they use to justify this but it’s not remotely justified, and they don’t do it for this reason, it’s just the excuse. They get money they plan to use to start a pro bono practice but that’s just the excuse, and Kim turns down a golden opportunity to help people because she wants the scam to happen that day so bad.

No Kim and Jimmy did this because they get off on conning people, and are afraid their relationship is built on conning and think if they don’t escalate pulling a scam to this degree the relationship will fall apart. They drugged, stalked, temporarily stole the car of an innocent man to make that wealthy lawyer seem like an unstable drug addict to his clients and peers. It woukd heavily damage his reputation in the legal community, possibly ruin it, and cause permanent damage, even if he’d probably be able to successfully repair the damage in time and mostly restore his rep to what it was eventually. But they did this for the thrill, while wrapped up in cartel business. And that (albeit very indirectly), got said innocent man killed, and a drug kingpin used that to frame his death as a drug addicted suicide with no body, with Jimmy and Kim being killed if they spoke out. Kim then gaslit the grieving wife at his funeral who didn’t believe the story into thinking the reason she didn’t notice his nonexistent drug addiction was because she was distant and estranged from him.

It’s clear at that point in time, Kim was a horrible person, and her and Jimmy’s actions lead to something unforgivable that can never, ever be made right. But after that, Kim punished her self in any way she could without getting murdered by Gus, gave up everything, completely changed her life, was utterly broken by the guilt, and once it was confirmed Mike was dead (and Gene calling out her hypocrisy) she confessed to Cheryl and accepted whatever the consequences were, whether it be (unlikely) jail, or likely massive civil suit. Kim would have come forward immediately and accepted jail (although it probably wouldn’t be a very long sentence), if not for Mike making it be clear they’d be killed if they came forward (confirmed by the showrunners). And Kim puts herself in purgatory to punish herself, but she’s not helping people either, and after that she goes to a pro bono to make her new focus and dedication in life be helping people for little reward.

I’m honestly curious on whether Kim would be considered redeemable (as in the overall be considered a decent person despite undeniably being an awful person in the past, not the it’s never too late to change way) by real world standards. Someone like Jimmy I don’t think is redeemable in that way because he caused too much harm as Breaking Bad era Saul and Gene, even though I would still respect his attempt to atone and treat him with humanity. Jesse clearly isn’t a bad guy inherently and was just a good kid who fell in with the wrong crowd at a young age, got addicted, and then got in way too deep due t a combination of manipulation and trauma and suffered somehow probably more than he deserved, but he did so much harm I don’t think he’d be considered redeemable by real world standards either. Obviously Mike and Walt aren’t, although they should still be encouraged to change their behavior and stop harming people, and I’m a believer in that prisons should not be based on making people suffer.

But in real life if someone did what Kim did, and then changed their behavior like Kim did, would you consider then automatically bad person incapable of redemption, or a decent person overall who used to be an awful person, or a bad person because she is simply irredenable for what she’s done. I honestly don’t know how I’d react to this myself, nor in the case of say Jesse’s NA sponser in Breaking Bad. I like to be optimistic and lens towards the positive side for redemption but boy that’s honestly a tough one for me, even if I slightly lean towards the redemption side. I will say I think I’d be sympathetic to Kim by real world standards. a tragic backstory doesn’t automatically make me sympathetic towards people who do unforgivable things, but it would in Kim’s case.

Growing up incredibly poor, absent father, with an alcoholic mentally abusive scammer Mom who only showed her love when she acted out and did something bad. Crawling out of that and becoming a high powered attorney and behaving as a good person who genuinely deeply cares about the underprivileged, but then meets someone who brings out her inner repressed childhood demons,. starts a mutually toxic relationship, and realizes the system is rigged for the wealthy and against the underprivileged and her initial good intentions get corrupte, followed by the fallout of everything and her sheer remorse. I’d want her to serve a couple years in jail but wouldn't blame her for that specifically because she’d be killed if she came forward earlier. I’d also have a deep sense of genuine disgust for what she‘s done however and consider what she did unforgivable. But can someone do something unforgivable that causes irrepersble harm as causing the death of an innocent and complete destruction of his reputation, but be considered a forgivable human being and decent person overall despite being awful in the past? I’m honestly curious what people think about that, I slightly lean yes she can eventually be considered a decent person by real world standards but a big part of me says she’ll always be a bad person.


r/betterCallSaul 10h ago

Howard's fatal flaw is also hubris Spoiler

0 Upvotes

I just finished rewatching S6E7. Everyone can agree that Jimmy and Kimmy did Howard dirty, and he has one hell of a speech to give them--totally deserved!

However.

That moment when Lalo walks into the room, and Jimmy and Kim radiate fear and tell Howard to GTFO, Howard just continues to stand there and pontificate like he's in charge.

He doesn't have the sense to think, "These two must be terrified for a good reason. They know something I don't know, and I should take their advice."

Nah. Howard is the boss of these con artist mailroom proteges. He's stronger than them and he can take whatever's scaring them. He's the champion of the boxing ring, the owner of his law firm, and the scrappy architect of his own fate...

Until Lalo immediately ends him for being a bit player taking up too much space in Salamanca's story.

Howard has his reputation unfairly stolen by Jimmy and Kim's conspiracy.

But he loses his life by being the same tone-deaf egocentric child of privilege he's always been.

EDIT: For the record, since so many people seem to think this comes out of left field, the scriptwriters themselves wrote him as being "full of righteous piss and vinegar" in his first interaction with Lalo.

https://www.reddit.com/r/betterCallSaul/comments/1v3mi4q/comment/oz4drtb/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=mweb3x&utm_name=mweb3xcss&utm_term=2&utm_content=share_button


r/betterCallSaul 16h ago

Me! And my family !,we built this whole business,(...) Salamanca blood! Salamanca money!(...) And you treat us like dogs. Spoiler

22 Upvotes

Hector! He was so angry and he had all the reasons to be.

He was angry that a Chilean, Chicken Man went behind his back, to introduce Don Eladio to his highly profitable Meth

He was angry that Eladio’s Cartel was built by Salamanca blood and Salamanca money(I love this scene) Bravo Vince and Peter .

He was angry that Fring’s drug earnings, far outperformed his family’s earnings

He was angry that his nephew Tuco was a meth-fueled, hothead that regularly gets himself in trouble. (Apple didn’t fall from the Salamanca tree)

He was angry because someone robbed one of his trucks transporting his “ice cream”

He was angry because someone robbed one of his trucks transporting his “ice cream

He was angry because he couldn’t convince anyone that his nephew Lalo was killed by Fring. Eladio should have listened, but chooses to mock him

He was angry because Walt changed the channel on his TV😂….and tried to poison Tuco

I really enjoyed Hector! 👏🏻


r/betterCallSaul 3h ago

How is this true according to you? Spoiler

2 Upvotes

Someone here asked in what ways did BCS change BB?(My view)

Most of Walt’s career was due to Saul. And Mike had warned Saul ahead of time that Walt was bad news. But Saul only saw dollar signs.

He said in the last episode if it wasn’t for his help, Walt would have been dead or in jail within a month, and that rings true to me. That’s not something we really see in Breaking Bad, though we know Saul plays a big part in Walt’s success.

We also learn that Saul was a persona, an alias, a fairly one-dimensional creation of James McGill, who is a much more complicated and tragic character.

It will make all my future watches of Breaking Bad a little more sad, knowing Saul isn’t just a wacky, hilarious, smooth talking criminal lawyer, but the broken shell of a man who suffered extreme trauma not long before.Most of Walt’s career was due to Saul. And Mike had warned Saul ahead of time that Walt was bad news. But Saul only saw dollar signs.

He said in the last episode if it wasn’t for his help, Walt would have been dead or in jail within a month, and that rings true to me. That’s not something we really see in Breaking Bad, though we know Saul plays a big part in Walt’s success.

We also learn that Saul was a persona, an alias, a fairly one-dimensional creation of James McGill, who is a much more complicated and tragic character.

It will make all my future watches of Breaking Bad a little more sad, knowing Saul isn’t just a wacky, hilarious, smooth talking criminal lawyer, but the broken shell of a man who suffered extreme trauma not long before.

Vince is a genius 👏🏾


r/betterCallSaul 10h ago

Finally I know where Kim's earrings are from Spoiler

Thumbnail gallery
75 Upvotes

S6E6


r/betterCallSaul 5h ago

Nacho Varga finale scene Spoiler

31 Upvotes

Just a thought, but wasn't it extremely dangerous for Nacho to brutally insult the cartel and admit the plot on Hector's life? Well, not anymore for Nacho, but for his father, who already openly made himself an enemy by insulting Hector as well and by knowing too much. Surely knowing how bloodthirsty the Salamanca's are, even Gus and Mike's protection wouldn't be enough if push came to shove. Because wasn't the whole point of Nacho taking the fall to ensure Gus's crew would repay by protecting his father from the cartel? This makes no sense to me, because unless Gus were to admit the secret collusion with Nacho, there is no logical reason to try to sway the cartel away from Nacho's Dad. So it seems to me like his actions potentially endangered the purpose of the whole plan, and I don't really get the plan in the first place.


r/betterCallSaul 12h ago

I just finished the series (unpleased) Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Since I started season 6 I knew the ending would be rushed or somewhat bad (given how open points season 5 left and how much of the story remains - the aftermath of BB),but the ending was truly disappointing. So we have Nacho, Lalo and Howard killed, ok, Kim leaves Jimmy, ok and then cut. Jimmy is in a mansion (we saw being torn down earlier) and next episode is full black and white -the following arc of each seasons' pilots (the aftermath of BB), which if you haven't watched BB is insanely unclear as to what just happened. Then we have a few more almost entirely black and white episodes, which becomes very tiring after 10+ minutes (it was ok in the pilots, but whole episodes is a little too much). And that goes on for 4 episodes with Jimmy doing "smaller" crimes and of course the occasional return to color flashbacks in the "present". I don't know if the writers or the production didn't want the show to be longer, but had it been 8 seasons it would have been perfect (given that season 6 and 7 show us more about Saul grieving after Kim left and more during and after the BB events, so the people who haven't seen it know what is going on). Then they would make season 8 just like the ending of season 6 now, but Jimmy actually takes 8 years or something, we get a couple of episodes where he is doing deals in prison or something interesting like that and after he leaves he quits law and starts a peaceful life (kinda like Glen).

Anyways, the ending itself was also disappointing. Jimmy had spent so much energy to reduce potential 200 years into 8, just to suddenly decide "oh wait I have conscience now" which he didn't even show during the Glen arc, so it was even more random, stupid and spontaneous. In the end he got 86 years (basically a life sentence), so even if he wanted to be a better man, redeem himself or whatever, he wouldn't, because he would be behind bars. My only assumption is that he either realized Chuck was somewhat right and that he will never change so he is better locked up, OR he has a sleeve up his card and is planning to escape prison (very unlikely). The other inmates still recognize him as Saul Goodman and not Jimmy McGill, so it's not like "let's kill the Saul Goodman/Slippin Jimmy persona", because that will live with him. So it was insanely shitty ending. Would have been funny if they showed him in jail regretting his decision, because it is batshit stupid.

On a side note, the final 4 episodes wouldn't make any sense to anyone who hasn't watched BB.

Overall, I loved the show until the middle of season 6, but after that it flopped. The ending felt like Whiplash, somehow both rushed and dragged.

If you have any comments, suggestions or arguments that may allow me to see a different perspective and change my view on the ending, write down.


r/betterCallSaul 10h ago

BCS inspired my webseries. Check out the season 3 premiere!

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

15 Upvotes

r/betterCallSaul 12h ago

BCS & BB removed from netflix UK?

7 Upvotes

Hi everyone! I was halfway through my rewatch of Better Call Saul and I woke up this morning to find it, along with Breaking Bad, has disappeared from netflix (i’m in the UK). I was wondering if anybody has had this or if it’s just a glitch with my netflix specifically? El Camino is still available so i’m not quite sure what’s happening here. Any help/advice would be appreciated!


r/betterCallSaul 6h ago

Chuck vs Jesse's brother Jake

8 Upvotes

Much like Chuck, Jesse's brother has all these achievements and prizes and constantly works hard. According to Howard's call to Jimmy in s4 ep1, Chuck graduated high school at the age of 14, and then at university lead the debate team 3x to victory.

Jesse's brother Jake tells Jesse that he doesn't feel like being the favorite son. He says that actually, Jesse is all the parents ever talk about.

In both cases one of the brothers is overachiever, genius, too mature for his age, and the other brother seems to get much more
attention from the parents. (how much love each of the brother gets is debatable).

Why this choice?
Can't two brothers just be ... kinda similar?


r/betterCallSaul 9h ago

Does anyone know the name of the background song?

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

7 Upvotes

Can anyone identify the song playing in the background of this scene by any chance?


r/betterCallSaul 17h ago

He will definitely tell a lot of fake stories about his win Spoiler

Post image
11 Upvotes

He did absoulutely nothing but i bet my guy will tell a lot of "untold" stories about his win .