I am starting the search for what will likely be my forever BAT rotary, and I have narrowed it down to three horns:
- Miraphone Hagen 497
- Miraphone Siegfried 98
- Meinl Weston (Melton) 196 Fasolt
For context, I currently play a Wessex Grand 6/4 BBb. It is actually the first piston tuba I have ever owned, and while it has served me well, I have come to realize that I simply prefer the feel, response, and sound concept of German rotary tubas.
Part of that preference goes all the way back to the early 1990s when playing with the 98th Army Band. I had the privilege of playing one of the old 6/4 Cerveny BBb tubas, and I have never forgotten that sound. It had what I can only describe as a cathedral sound...dark, broad, effortless, and absolutely room-filling. You did not just hear the low register; you felt it. Every BAT I have considered since has been measured against the memory of that Cerveny, although the intonation was something to be desired. :)
If I make the jump, my plan is to gift my Wessex to an 18-year-old tuba player in my community band who absolutely loves it. Buying even a used tuba is simply out of reach for him, so this feels like another opportunity to pay forward the kindness that so many people have shown me throughout my musical journey. Over the past two years, I have also gifted every young tuba player in our band a mouthpiece of their choice from my extensive 45 years of collecting. Interestingly, every one of them chose either a PT-88+ or a PT-50+, and it has been a joy watching them grow as players. I play on a gold PT-88 MAXX or a gold satin Mercer-Barker MB7 Lake Monster.
The difficult part is that I am the full-time care partner for my wife, so traveling to play-test instruments simply is not a realistic option. Because of that, I have to rely much more heavily on the experiences of people who have actually lived with these horns.
Interestingly, every professional player I have talked with has been incredibly enthusiastic about the Hagen 497. They consistently mention its core, center, intonation, and how well it projects without losing warmth. That has definitely pushed it toward the top of my list.
For those of you who have spent significant time on any of these three instruments, I would love to hear your experiences.
- Which one has the biggest, most effortless low register?
- Which one gives you that same "cathedral" or "wall of sound" feeling without becoming unfocused?
- How do the Hagen and Siegfried really differ in playing characteristics, not just on paper?
- How does the Fasolt compare in terms of projection, color, and intonation?
- If you had to choose one as a lifetime BBb BAT, which would you buy and why?
I know there is no substitute for playing them myself, but in my situation I have to make the most informed decision I can. I appreciate any firsthand experience you are willing to share.