Any comment with at least 50 (subject to change) upvotes gets the change added. Tiers are in order.

Context: I haven't been tuned into the NFL much this offseason so these rankings are based off what I know. If its wrong feel free to correct me.

Fourth year in a row he’s rated in the top 100 by his peers (56 being his lowest ranking) and players like Brady, Payton, Kurt Warner, Eric Kendrick’s, Vick, desean Jackson, mcnabb, all praise him and talk about how good of a qb he is. But you get on twitter, Reddit or watch espn and they act like he’s the worst starting qb, he can’t throw (even tho he has great accuracy td int ratio and yards per play)

Is there any single non star NFL player who came up more after their career then this guy? Had to have been Terry Crews before him

The tight end position in 2026 feels more exciting than it has in years, but it still carries meaningful fragility.

It's only through shameless hypocrisy that ppl assert Jalen Hurts isn't an elite QB by ignoring his rushing stats and not including them in his yardage/TD totals. In reality he's 2nd in the league in total TDs since 2022. He's 5th in total yards since 2021. If you want to talk total YPG, he's still in the top 10 and basically neck and neck with far more glorified QB in Stafford.

Which brings me to 2nd point of shameless hypocrisy which is common place for QBs like Jalen where his accomplishments are discredit because of his supporting cast. Same ppl who have no problem ranking Stafford as an elite QB while in the same breath admitting the Rams have most loaded squad in the league do the complete opposite for Hurts. You point out that 2022 squad had no Barkley and they point out elite Oline and still having defense and AJ Brown. You point out 2023 squad didn't have Barkley and the 31st ranked scoring D, and he still took that team to a record 10+ wins with a defense close to that bad and it's crickets or goalposts are moved to he should have won a SB with that squad.

Meannwhile other QBs can have loaded WR corp, great Oline, and absolute genius for a playcaller and HC and it's perfectly fine.