Hey everyone,
I’m still pretty new to the trade and wanted some honest opinions from people who’ve been doing this a lot longer than I have. For some background I have about three years of machining experience from a vocational high school program. During that time I learned blueprint reading, precision measuring tools, basic machining and CNC fundamentals. So I’m not coming into this completely blind I understand a lot of the concepts but I definitely needed a refresher because it had been a while since I had worked in a machine shop. I’ve been at my current shop for about four weeks. It’s a production environment and I’m running a 2015 DMG Mori Seiki lathe. My day mainly consists of loading parts, making offset adjustments, performing quality inspections, checking dimensions and keeping production going. I inspect parts with micrometers, calipers, bore gauges, depth gauges, and a microscope when required. I can read blueprints, make work offset corrections and keep the machine producing parts within tolerance.
My first question is: Would you consider me a machinist, or am I more of a machine operator at this point? I’m genuinely curious where I fall.
As for the second part;
My first trainer (I’ll call him Bob) made my first few weeks miserable. Every day I was trying to learn he’d call me a dumbass, make me feel stupid for asking questions, dismiss things I didn’t understand and generally made me feel like I wasn’t welcome. Instead of teaching me it often felt like he was tearing me down.
One incident really pushed me over the edge. Before break Bob told me NOT to run the machine until he got back. So after break I sat at the machine and waited exactly like he told me.
Then another lead (Lets call him Jay) walked over and started yelling at me asking what the hell I was doing telling me to get my ass up and go do scrap work in the back. I was honestly confused because I was following the instructions I had just been given.
After several weeks of dealing with this kind of treatment and I finally filed an HR complaint. I gave them a detailed timeline of everything that had happened and HR met with me to discuss it. I explained that the constant insults, yelling and lack of actual teaching direction were causing me a lot of anxiety and emotional stress.
I also have ADHD which is even harder on me however I learn best by asking questions and writing things down. Because we work in a controlled facility phones aren’t allowed on the floor so I can’t keep digital notes with me. I’m doing my best to learn but being insulted every day instead of taught made it much harder.
HR ended up moving me to a different trainer.
My new trainer is definitely more respectful but he’s almost too hands on. Even when I’m doing something correctly he’ll stop me grab the part out of my hands or inspect everything himself before I can finish. I know he’s trying to make sure I don’t make mistakes but sometimes it feels like he doesn’t trust me enough to complete the process on my own.
So I have a few questions for the experienced machinists here:
Was I wrong for going to HR?
Is this kind of treatment just considered “normal shop culture” or was it actually out of line?
Based on what I’m doing now would you consider me a machinist or still just an operator? (My guess is an operator from what I’ve been doing)
Is it normal for a trainer to constantly step in even after you’ve shown you can perform the task?
Any advice for surviving the first few months in a production shop?
I’m not looking for validation I genuinely want honest opinions. If I handled something poorly tell me. If I need thicker skin tell me that too. But I also want to know if what I experienced would be considered unacceptable at most shops.
https://api.p1.mks.com/mam/
celum/celum_assets/resources/MKS-Labor-
Policy pdf
Any feedback is appreciated!