I was very critical of the Fold 8 since it was rumored months ago. My argument was that the regular square shape is better than the wide version, mostly due to app compatibility, and I finally had the chance to play with the phone today.
The phone is, as I expected, a mini phone. Yes, it is factually smaller than its big brother. It is exactly the way I expected, small apps on the cover screen. I visited CNN.com, FoxNews.com, and other sports pages, and the difference in screen real estate on these phones clearly shows. The mini displays less content, so you need to scroll more. Yes, scroll more. Whereas I normally open a website once on my Fold 7 and that one glance is enough to see pretty much what's new in the Middle East or whether Shakira will perform at another World Cup, basically, you can see a few titles on the Fold 7/Ultra) the mini phone needs to be scrolled, which is very inconvenient for my usage.
Another thing I noticed is that, yes, my Fold 7 is tall. The screen is quite tall, and it is hard to reach the top, but I have never needed to reach the top because I use Good Lock's gestures. On the Fold 8 mini phone, I noticed that my fingers hardly reach the right side of the screen. So when I am texting, I noticed that I am using two hands instead of one hand like on the Fold 7. I am not lying, it is pretty nice to have a large space to type, but the phone is also quite wide to a point that I didn't like it. I wish the Ultra was just 2mm wider than the Fold 7.
As I expected, social media apps like YouTube Shorts, TikTok, and others seem small and weirdly shaped on the front screen. That continues when you unfold the the phone because it is still short, the issue only gets fixed when you rotate it. I opened MKBHD Shorts on the cover screens of both phones, and the difference is quite big. The only way you could fix this issue on the mini phone is to basically unfold AND rotate it.
Now, before you lose your patience and say other people are happy with this type of design, I get it. I fully understand, and I like that people have choices. But for neutral people who genuinely want to know the difference between the two devices, here are my two points that determine which Fold is for you:
If you primarily watch YouTube and TV shows a lot and don't mind small apps on the cover screen, the Fold 8 is your device.
If you mainly consume social media apps, then the Fold 8 Ultra is the clear choice.
The Fold 7/Ultra can do every single thing that the wide Fold 8 can do, except two things: typing on the bigger but weird front screen, and hiding the camera hole when you are watching full screen videos.
In my case, I don't watch YouTube most of the time, and if I somehow do, I rotate my device. I get exactly the same size as the Fold 8, and the camera hole doesn't bother me at all, I don't even notice it. But the most important reason the Fold 8 is a no-go for me is the fact that it has less screen real estate than the Fold 8 Ultra. It is math, ladies and gentlemen, you can spin it the way you want, but 8 is bigger than 5. A larger screen can do more things that a smaller one can't do. YouTube reviews are irrelevant to me because most of them are paid by Samsung, and they are trying to market the new device before Apple's foldable device comes out.