r/FirstTimeHomeBuyer • u/TldrDev • 19h ago
Underwriting Contingent loan; seller wants us to pay. What do we do?
Hey all,
Made a classic mistake, apparently.
Seller accepted our offer after about a year of super active house hunting. Seller hasn't updated anything in 20 years. Roof has issues, and there is a failed skylight. My cousin is a roofer and will put a new roof on after close; that was the plan. Radeon failed badly. Plumbing is all polybutylene on city water. We asked for a seller concession of 3% in closing costs for the deferred maintenance. Seller countered at 2%. We accepted.
My wife had received a direct email from the mortgage company asking us to upload ALL SELLER ADDENDUMS, and we had uploaded everything that was signed as requested by the lender. They specifically had asked us for any seller concessions.
Went to underwriting. Loan went contingent. Everyone, including our agent, is now absolutely pissed at us for complicating things.
We had 3 major asks. A roof inspection, a plumbing inspection, and radon mitigation.
Seller knew a guy and paid for the plumbing inspection. They then sent a demand to our realtor for us to pay the bill. Feeling bad, and trying to show some good faith, I paid the seller $525 for the inspection and plumbing fixes. I figure we are both worried about the other backing out, and we will both increase our skin in the game as a show of good will.
Roof was today. We have no specific invoices yet. Im starting to feel a bit anxious now. Im not wanting to pay to fix this fellas roof for a house I dont own.
More importantly, seller is asking us to schedule and pay for, in full, the Radon system. This is going to put me, at minimum, around $2500 in fixing this guy's house.
Close is August 6. We offered a full month of tenancy. Our current lease ends Sept 14th. Were kind of at the wire here.
This is a $400k house, and im pretty tired of looking, this is literally the best house we seen for the money, and so id like to salvage this.
Seller said "im not really in a rush to sell, so you can either pay or you need to get another lender."
What say you, reddit? Torpedo the deal over $2k, put my own living situation into a crisis, or how can I approach this?
This whole thing is feeling sketchy, financially risky, and exploitative, but we're kind of really wanting to be done with this.