r/CraftyCommerce Jun 24 '24

Megathread Pricing Megathread

23 Upvotes

Since a lot of people have questions about pricing lately, I thought I would throw a Megathread up here for folks to have it all in one place. We might also discuss trying to come up with some sort of formula that could be applied to most situations.

Please put all general pricing questions here. For example, if your question is something like "How much can I charge for this?", then you can ask it here.


r/CraftyCommerce May 07 '26

Megathread Good Enough?

99 Upvotes

We've been seeing a flood lately of posts asking, "Is this good enough to sell?" and variations on that theme. We're not really here to evaluate someone's skill level or the popularity of a particular item for sale. It's too subjective. However, if you really need to get it out, post in the comments below. All other individual posts of that nature, from this point onward, will be removed. I have added a new rule to the sidebar. Please read it and follow it. Thank you.


r/CraftyCommerce 3h ago

General Discussion I crochet tiny nick keychain

Thumbnail
gallery
5 Upvotes

He’s completely handmade with lots of tiny details, including his green shirt, brown pants, fluffy tail, and the little keychain loop. He’s small, lightweight, and perfect for decorating a bag, backpack, purse, or keys. ✨


r/CraftyCommerce 1d ago

Online Selling Handmade crochet card 💌❤️

Thumbnail
gallery
7 Upvotes

r/CraftyCommerce 20h ago

General Discussion what crocheted items are in high demand for the most money?

Post image
0 Upvotes

hey, i was wondering what things are selling the most (and for the most money) and where to sell them. i keep seeing these pants selling out for hundreds of dollars so im assuming these are a big one lol. but i usually look on etsy but its hard figuring out what kind of things people would want. im very open to learning to make new things and would love any advice!
(if you already saw this same post in [r/askcrochet](r/askcrochet) just know it wouldn’t let me cross post and i just figured this was a better question here😭)


r/CraftyCommerce 2d ago

Pattern Creation & Sales Does it look fake/ai?

Post image
22 Upvotes

I promise this isn't self promotion since I dont have my etsy attached to my reddit! I just have this listing with a photo of my crochet bag sitting on polyfil and im worried some may see it as Ai or an edited image. Would this photo turn people away with all the worries of fake patterns nowadays? How would I fix it if yes?


r/CraftyCommerce 1d ago

Strategy How do I price a crochet tapestry made out of embroidery floss?

0 Upvotes

I designed a colorwork project I want to sell but there are so many colors that I'm going to see if I can make it with embroidery floss. It's 6400 stitches.

Would charging by yard make sense here? Any advice welcome.


r/CraftyCommerce 1d ago

Instagram Selling Crochet Advice

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

(Some of the items Ive made in the past six months)

Im a self taught crocheter who’s been crocheting for about three or four years now. Im currently a full time student and don’t have the time in my schedule to apply for a job. I needed to find a way to start making some cash for myself, no matter how little it is, anything is something for me to start saving up some money (for my own personal use), so I resorted to the next best thing for myself and made an instagram account for my crochet. I posted some of my crochet items to sell and said that I would take any custom items that people wanted. It has now been around six months since Ive had my account. I have about six posts (i know it’s a small amount but i just haven’t had time to post a lot these past months) and about 30 followers, with most of these followers being my friends or people I know.

I honestly feel like im getting no where with my items. Ive tried to use hashtags, trending audios, more cuter items that people would buy while also trying not to fit into selling the same old items that people sell. I also don’t feel that my items are so bad that people refuse to buy it. For the most part i’m pretty proud about what I put online, even if it’s not anything huge or intricate.

I mostly sell stuffed animal crochet items and other objects like flowers. I don‘t really know if it’s setting me back that I don’t sell more items like shirts, dresses, skirts, huge crochet plushies, or sweaters. But honestly, making stuffed animals is all I have time for which is a big inconvenience for me. I know me not having more time on my hands sets me back, but despite being busy I also try to make time on my schedule to create something so I could then post.

I would love any advice on how people started selling their crochet or what crochet items they sell that people love to buy from them. Where they sell their crochet for the best chances of selling. Just any advice on how to maybe reach more of an audience on instagram with my crochet items or if it’s even worth setting my items on instagram at all. Should I look to sell it somewhere else, other than instagram? I know it takes some people months, or even years to get big on instagram with their crochet but I still want some advice when it comes to selling my crochet and why not ask now while i’m still starting up. Any advice is helpful :)


r/CraftyCommerce 2d ago

Self Advertising I created a free app for makers to sell their creations locally

13 Upvotes

I built tiny store (www.tiny.store) because I hated Etsy and there was no other platform where I or my other maker friends can sell our stuff at local markets or safely at home.

If you ever wanted to make a website, sell locally, or you already do and hate taking order via DMs, it’d be awesome if you can try tiny out and let me know what you think.

Perks: you get your own website for free, allow local preorders and pick ups, post your events, and put your products with prices for your customers/followers to buy. No fees.

I’d love feedback too! Really lucky to have a strong community here so it’d mean a lot. ❤️🙏


r/CraftyCommerce 2d ago

In Person Selling where to sell crochet plushies in BC canada

0 Upvotes

i cant seem to find places except for cloverdale (but i havent made much profit since its a flea market) that doesnt require me to need insurance or pay $200 for a table. im a small business so i cant drop that much money, especially in one day.

could anyone give me a place that they know wont bankrupt me immediately


r/CraftyCommerce 2d ago

Self Advertising Wish to have free crochet patterns to make and sell?

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes

I create boho crochet items, such as beanies, headbands, and scrunchies. You are free to create and sell items made from my patterns. New videos will be added each week.


r/CraftyCommerce 2d ago

Online Selling Where can I sell this handmade doll?

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

r/CraftyCommerce 3d ago

Online Selling Help!

0 Upvotes

Trying to find a subreddit to sell my crochet plushies and keychains. I started a small business and need customers. Any help is appreciated!


r/CraftyCommerce 3d ago

Branding NEED NAME SUGGESTIONS FOR MY FIRST EVER CROCHET ONLINE BUSINESS

0 Upvotes

Hey y'all! I'm new to Reddit and could really use some help. 😊 I've been crocheting for a while now, and I'm finally getting to the point where I want to start selling my crochet online! 🤗 The one thing I'm completely stuck on is coming up with a business name. I'm terrible at naming things, so I was hoping y'all could throw some ideas my way! My style is definitely crochet plushies (amigurumi), and I love making cute, cozy, cuddly things. I'm open to anything—cute, cozy, funny, whimsical, or unique. I'd love to hear whatever names you can think of!

Thanks in advance! ❤️


r/CraftyCommerce 4d ago

In Person Selling Question about deductions for vending

0 Upvotes

So, I don't sell my pieces in markets but I really should. I sell through another shop and the owner takes a cut, duh. Is it normal for them to take a 60% cut 😭. It was NOT that high of a percentage last year. If anything it was the opposite last year, and they would take a 40% cut. So I priced my work based off of those consistent numbers. I know the economy is bad rn but man. The increase was not communicated btw, just in case that's important info for any reason. Cause if I had known I would have priced accordingly 🥲. Please be nice, it's a genuine question. I've only sold a handful of my crochet before and I'm still learning how these things work!


r/CraftyCommerce 4d ago

Pattern Creation & Sales Easy, popular crochet ideas

0 Upvotes

I’m trying to make a bunch of items to sell, and right now I have scrunchies and flower coasters, but I want to know what other things sell well.


r/CraftyCommerce 4d ago

General Discussion Is there a market and interest for Crocheted Things in Tbilisi, Georgia?

0 Upvotes

My husband and I are planning on moving to Tbilisi as it’s just better for him when it comes to his work and he said since I love to crochet and have lots of free time that I can make Plushies and sell them as a small income. He suggested this because he said it’s very popular and Georgians have a big interest when it comes to handmade things. I’m just curious if this is true before I make any drastic decisions and purchases. I’m wondering if there’s actually a market for those Things? Not just Plushies but crochet things in general(hats, bags, bag accessories, wallets etc) also if there’s any good place or website to advertise myself.

Thanks in advance for any help or advice


r/CraftyCommerce 5d ago

Selling Via Commission I got my first commission! How do I deal with the payment?

1 Upvotes

As the title says, I've been commissioned! It's very exciting for me, and it's for a lovely long-distance friend whose buying it for a gift!

We've discussed all the details, and the pricing that she's happy to pay, but I just wondering what is the "done thing" when it comes to actual payment?

I would have to buy all the yarn in as what she wants I don't have currently - would you ask for all or some payment upfront to cover the material costs, or pay for the yarn yourself and have her pay in full when it's finished?

I'm aware that I can ask for the money however I like, but I'm hopefully wanting to do commissions as an actual side gig, so would like advice on the general practice that I should expect to follow if I do :)

Thank you in advance!


r/CraftyCommerce 5d ago

Strategy Can a solo knitter reach 15 sales/month with a custom configurator?

0 Upvotes

Hey,
I’m currently turning my knitting hobby into a small side business and could use some honest feedback.
I’m planning to launch a small line of premium merino wool beanies. Instead of selling pre-made items, I’m building a web configurator where customers can customize their beanie (choose colors (6 colors) , pom-poms, leather tag details, etc.). The goal is a minimalist, high quality, and a focus on premium materials.
My marketing plan is to document the entire process through short clips knitting, debossing the leather tags, and packing orders and post these on Instagram and TikTok.
I’m aiming for a price point around $60. My initial goal is to reach 15 sales per month to keep this as a manageable side project.

questions
1. The Configurator:Does the idea of a custom-built beanie sound appealing to you, or is the "extra effort" of choosing options a turn-off compared to buying a finished item?
2. The Price: As a buyer, does $60 feel justified for a custom-made, high-quality merino wool beanie, or is that pushing it for a small brand?
3. The Strategy: Is documenting the process on social media enough to build trust for a new brand, or is it too saturated now?
4. Scaling: My goal is 15 sales/month to keep it fun rather than overwhelming. Is there a "trap" I'm not seeing here with this custom-order model?
Any advice or red flags you see in this approach?


r/CraftyCommerce 6d ago

Quality Control Need help please

Post image
0 Upvotes

Hi all would you buy this even if it's unlined? I'm chronically ill and lining it is a real task so I'm wondering if it's a 100% necessary. If so hypothetically how much? The strap is adjustable.


r/CraftyCommerce 7d ago

Community Looking to collaborate with event planners for crochet decor.

0 Upvotes

r/CraftyCommerce 9d ago

Quality Control Would you buy this? And what changes you would like

Thumbnail
gallery
3 Upvotes

My mom and I recently started making handcrafted wool products under our small brand called SARAS. This is something we’ve been working on together, and it’s been a really meaningful project for us.
I’d love to get some honest feedback from this community.
Would you consider buying something like this? What do you like about it, and what would you change? Is there anything that would make you more likely to purchase a handmade wool product like this?
We’re trying to improve before launching more products, so honest opinions are genuinely appreciated. Thanks so much for taking the time to help us out!


r/CraftyCommerce 9d ago

Online Selling Is Etsy still worth it for someone who just wants a small, casual handmade business?

11 Upvotes

I've been seriously considering opening an Etsy shop to sell physical crochet items, but after seeing so many negative posts and TikToks about Etsy lately, I'm starting to wonder if it's even worth trying anymore.

To give some context, I'm not looking to sell crochet patterns or other digital products. I want to sell actual handmade crochet items that I make, package, and ship to customers.

I'm also not trying to build some huge company or become a six-figure business owner. This would be more of a side hustle and something I genuinely enjoy doing. I want to start small, improve my crochet skills, add more products as I get better, and hopefully make some extra money along the way. I'm perfectly happy having a nice little small business. I don't have dreams of becoming the next massive crochet company lol.

That's one of the reasons Etsy originally appealed to me. I liked the idea of being able to create a shop, list my products, pay the necessary fees, and sell without immediately feeling like I need to build an entire business operation from scratch.

However, I keep seeing people say they're done with Etsy because of the fees, competition, changes to the platform, and the amount of digital or mass-produced products taking over the site. I've also noticed that some handmade sellers have to raise their prices significantly to account for Etsy's fees.

So my main question is: Is Etsy still worth trying in 2026 for a new seller who wants to sell physical handmade crochet items?

Are people still actually going to Etsy specifically to look for unique, handmade items? Or has the platform changed so much that new handmade sellers are better off starting somewhere else?

I've seen Facebook Marketplace suggested as an alternative, but I've always associated Marketplace with meeting buyers in person. I don't want to meet customers face-to-face. I would much rather package my products and ship them.

I also know that creating my own website is an option. I'm not completely against doing that eventually. I've actually helped my mother-in-law with her website, so the idea of managing one doesn't scare me.

My hesitation is that I don't really want to jump immediately into the feeling of running a full-fledged business with my own website, driving all my own traffic, and going through the entire business checklist right from the beginning. I'd rather start somewhere that already has customers looking for handmade products, see whether people are interested in what I make, and grow from there.

If Etsy is still the best option for that, I'm perfectly fine giving Etsy a chance. Sometimes I wonder if the negative opinions I'm seeing online make the platform seem worse than it actually is.

For those of you who currently sell physical handmade products:

Would you still recommend Etsy to a brand-new seller in 2026?

If not, what alternatives would you recommend for someone who specifically wants to sell and ship physical handmade items?

I'd especially love to hear from people selling crochet, jewelry, crafts, or similar handmade products.


r/CraftyCommerce 9d ago

Pattern Creation & Sales Advertise crochet patterns?

0 Upvotes

Hi! So I just started selling my own crochet patterns after selling plushies for about a year. Selling the plushies has been kinda stressful and time demanding on top of not really making more than covering my own costs which I didn’t mind that much since it’s a hobby. But now I’ve gotten into designing my own patterns! I’ve already sold 2 of my very first which I’m very excited about. Buuut how do I advertise in the best way? I have about 500 followers on insta and almost 5k on tiktok… the 5k are almost only people interested in the plushies I’ve been selling and people from my own country. So do I just continue posting there hoping to find more interested people? How do I up my instagram game? Do I just post about my own patterns regularly? Would honestly love some advice!


r/CraftyCommerce 11d ago

General Discussion I need advice for some ideas

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

I have many handicraft skills which I'm pretty good at, the skills are crochet, punch needle, making and designing clothes and i wanna do something with these skills that can generate money...i wanna be financially independent without a traditional job ....soooo any advice how and what to do and also what you guys think of these niches. The market the demand and the platform whatever knowledge and information you guys have please do share and help me in anyway you can.