r/BattlePaintings • u/GameCraze3 • 7h ago
Dramatic depiction of the final stand of Alexander McRae during the Battle of Valverde, 1862, New Mexico Campaign of the American Civil War
This battle was a part of Confederate Brigadier General Henry Hopkins Sibley's ambitious plan to seize New Mexico Territory, capture the rich mineral resources of the American Southwest, and eventually threaten California's ports. Rather than assault the heavily fortified Fort Craig, which was defended by Colonel Edward R. S. Canby, Sibley attempted to bypass the fort by crossing the Rio Grande at Valverde Ford. Canby recognized the danger and dispatched Union forces to contest the crossing, bringing nearly 6,000 men into battle along the dry riverbanks and open desert surrounding the ford.
The fighting lasted throughout the day and repeatedly shifted in favor of one side and then the other. Early Union attacks successfully pinned Confederate troops in an old river channel, while Captain Alexander McRae's experienced regular army artillery battery inflicted devastating losses with accurate shell, canister, and grapeshot fire. McRae, a graduate of West Point and a native of North Carolina who had chosen loyalty to the Union despite most of his family joining the Confederacy, quickly became the anchor of Canby's line. His six guns dominated the battlefield, breaking up repeated Confederate advances and threatening to force Sibley's army into retreat.
By the afternoon, however, the battle reached its decisive moment. General Sibley had become too ill to command effectively, leaving Colonel Thomas Green to direct Confederate operations. Green recognized that as long as McRae's battery remained intact, Confederate victory was impossible. Concealing his men behind low sand ridges and using the terrain to mask their advance, Green organized a bold, direct assault aimed squarely at the Union artillery rather than the infantry supporting it. As the Texans emerged from cover, McRae's guns unleashed devastating volleys of grapeshot at point-blank range, tearing gaps through the charging ranks. Yet the Confederates continued forward despite terrible casualties, closing the distance before the artillerymen could reload.
What followed was fierce hand-to-hand combat. Confederate soldiers surged directly into McRae's battery, fighting among the cannon with pistols, rifles, bayonets, and clubbed muskets. As opposed to retreating, McRae and his artillerymen remained beside their guns, continuing to resist even after Confederate troops had reached the battery. According to contemporary accounts, the fight lasted only a matter of minutes, but it was extraordinarily violent. Roughly half of McRae's command was killed at their posts, and nearly eighty percent of all Union casualties during the battle occurred in or around his battery. Within approximately eight minutes, the Confederate assault had overrun all six Union guns.
Captain McRae himself refused every opportunity to withdraw. Already wounded during the desperate defense, he continued directing his men until he suffered additional wounds and was finally killed beside one of his cannon. Having remained loyal to the United States despite intense pressure from his father and brothers to join the Confederacy, McRae's final moments reflected the same unwavering sense of duty that had guided his decision at the outbreak of the war. One of the Texans who made the assault on the Union center at Valverde was Private William L. Davidson, Company A, 5th Texas Mounted Volunteers, he wrote this about McRae: “[H]e died by his guns and no braver man lived or died on that field. He was a Southern Man, a North Carolinian, but he died fighting the South, but he died where he thought his duty lead him.”
The loss of McRae's battery shattered the Union battle line. Although many Union officers believed the captured artillery could still be recovered, Colonel Canby judged the position irretrievable and ordered a withdrawal toward Fort Craig. The Confederates held the battlefield, capturing the six guns and claimed victory. Nevertheless, their success came at a heavy cost. Their army had suffered severe casualties, remained short of supplies, and lacked the heavy artillery necessary to reduce Fort Craig. Instead of destroying Canby's army, the Confederates were forced to continue northward, where they would eventually suffer a disastrous strategic defeat after the Battle of Glorieta Pass, ending hopes of permanently securing the Southwest for the Confederacy.
Colonel Canby paid tribute to his fallen officer by writing that McRae was "pure in character, upright in conduct, devoted to his profession, and of a loyalty that was deaf to the seductions of family and friends," concluding that he "died, as he had lived, an example of the best and highest qualities that man can possess."