r/AskVegans • u/Thala_Ramos • 4h ago
Genuine Question (DO NOT DOWNVOTE) Is veganism a moral ideology or rational which is backed by science, or both?
I think veganism is currently backed by research and studies done which may have been done because
a) To evaluate current dominant food choice's impact on environment
b) to develop/research for better choices for humanity.
c) to conduct research because non vegan choices affect people and such research helps overall conduct of society.
Is most of what is pushed on to general public just moralism?
I am unclear here. Lot of discourse whenever it is outside vegan spaces, we only get to see moral arguments repeated over and over. While research and study links disappears in threads.
While it is also true most people won't read full research papers word by word (including me) .
I have linked three conversations I have found which I want people here to talk on about.
https://www.reddit.com/r/librandu/s/qwDNJpdQMV
https://www.reddit.com/r/Ultraleft/s/GS1aoZoBRo
https://www.reddit.com/r/Ultraleft/s/xhCQjt1U6h
In the first conversation which I myself had with someone who claimed it was moralism rather than rational where despite soya chunks being cheaper and thus much better way to combat malnutrition in poorer countries than egg/milk.
Common thing among such conversation mentioned here is that veganism is just a part of moral activism.
In India, vegetarian (without egg) upper caste people have oppressed and have historically looked down upon those who are non vegetarians and continues to do so. Since india is a diverse country with multiple cultures and traditions formed from different life experience through generations, some upper caste do consume non veg food and thus have an conflict , wherein a discourse on normalcy and how food choices doesn't make them inferior.
In such a country, do you think veganism will always be unpopular due to it resembling such cultural discrimination for them or it being just a moral take, despite veganism having nothing to do with such traditional values.
Now shifting the conversation, do you think veganism includes both moralism and rationalism.
Because objectivity has no bias. Pardon my ignorance, will veganism stay as an upcoming cultural shift, if studies show veganism isn't the right choice for overall survival/advancement of human civilization . Do you think veganism can still be the poplular choice due to it's moral values .
Where animal suffering and exploitation is an objective truth, why don't people claiming veganims as moral ideology, not see their own moral values formed from cultural upbringing and traditions and deny empirical data.
Do you think ethics and morals which is formed from rational scientific framework needs to change constantly due to nature of science. If yes, then how to make such changes easier where people have emotional attachment to culture they have grown with.
Thanks