Spoilers ahead
I’ll start by saying that I still enjoyed the show for what it was and I didn’t regret watching it. It’s a good show. But the hype is overblown.
The show is essentially about Tenma travelling and his positivity rubbing off on everyone he meets. And about Nina trying to regain her memories. That’s it, that’s the show. The rest is all just there. Johan only exists to tie Tenma and Nina together, to give Tenma a reason to be an outlaw on the run and a reason for Nina’s storyline to start.
The length of the show and endless filler
About less than halfway through I realized that all the slow moments weren’t going to amount to this insanely good payoff. Around the episode where Tenma gets the orphaned girl to laugh and the stoic veteran guy (that teaches Tenma how to use a gun) gets hit in the feels over it made me realize that these were the true highlights of the show. So when I started seeing the show in that way and stopped watching purely for the next crazy moment, it became more enjoyable for me.
Nevertheless, I do still feel like the show did disappoint in the long run. Eventually I got bored of Nina’s trauma with her flashbacks. Eventually I stopped caring about Johan’s past. And worst of all I eventually got bored with seeing Jesus Tenma. His morals never change and seeing him “struggle” with another moral quandary felt pointless because he never caves and never changes.
The show just beats the same drum over and over and naturally its impact is going to get weaker everytime. It’s just way longer than it needed to be. The entire thing could be 30 episodes instead of 74 and they’d be able to fit it in and show you everything that matters. The last 10 episodes I was pretty much done and just powered through it because I wanted to be done with it. The revelations in the end do not feel that rewarding especially when the show teases you with it the entire time. It’s not building up to some Breaking Bad Ozymandias moment where the whole world gets flipped upside down.
Also another thing is the soundtrack. It’s terrific but the length of the show makes it so you hear those same emotional tracks over and over. Eventually I’d just say to myself oh here comes that cool music again which has zero impact anymore lol.
The Villain
This was a huge disappointment to me after hearing all the hype about Johan being one of the greatest villains perhaps in all of fiction. He’s barely in it and you rarely see him actually do anything evil. Now I can understand and get behind the concept of a villain who is operating behind the scenes and is casting a shadow over the whole story. I’m all on board with that. But this just wasn’t it. Johan is a villain because the show says so and you better just take its word for it. It’s a bad case of telling instead of showing.
The scene where he kills the guy in the parking garage in front of Tenma is the height of his villainy and it happens within the first few episodes. It really felt like Tenma was seeing something that he shouldn’t have and the consequences were going to be dire. From then on it’s all mostly downhill for Johan. The show just tells you that he’s a mastermind but you never really see it yourself. He’s got aura, no doubt. But that’s pretty much all he has.
Characters never change
There are some that do like Eva and honestly I do like lots of the characters. But Tenma, Nina and Johan are the exact same characters at the beginning and at the end.
Tenma has a huge moment where he finally pulls the trigger on a bad guy and kills him. At this point we’re about halfway through the show. So naturally I’m thinking “ok this is it, a huge development in Tenma’s character”. But then later on it’s revealed that the guy he shot didn’t even die and Tenma never behaves any differently even when he thought he had killed someone. I wasn’t expecting him to become bloodthirsty or anything but just a little change would have been nice.
Nina’s whole story is about regaining her memories and discovering her true self and at the end she’s the same person that she was before her journey started.