This is not about whether or not I hate anomaly just pointing out what is it about anomaly and it’s mod packs that make it controversial even with it's popularity and it seems to mainly boil down to 3 things
1 How distant it is from Stalker
I think it’s pretty well known how much Anomaly and especially its mod packs like GAMMA and EFP stray from OG stalker economy, looting, crafting, difficulty etc. But is this really a bad thing? Is it wrong try something new and add a unique twist to Stalker? I think most people would agree that it’s not and in the case of GAMMA it’s supposedly pretty customizable. Perhaps this may not be such a huge issue if it wasn’t for the second thing
- How it’s popularity SEEMINGLY affected modding and the image of the Stalker series
Something that Anomaly and its modpacks seemed to get blamed for is what the modding scene has supposedly changed into because of Anomaly. Because Anomaly and it’s modpacks are more hardcore, more scavenging focused and more difficult a lot of new mods have supposedly centered around that trying be some diet Tarkov and day Z hybrid rather than adding on to stalker and if you look at the YouTube a lot of it seems to focus on how harcore tacticool or difficult the mods are and how the modding landscape seems to be some contest on how difficult and punishing they can make stalker mods and overall the modding landscape does seem to heavily skewer towards anomaly. Now I say supposedly because I’m not here to say whether or not this is actually true as Stalker modding itself is it's own rabbit hole but it does seem that way with what people see. Are the creators of Anomaly and it’s modpacks to blame for this? Or are they are being scapegoated? This popularity has also seemed to have shaped the perception of stalker making people think it is a more sci fi Tarkov lite hardcore Milsim rather than stalker and that leads into the third point.
- Anomaly fans themselves
Many people claim that anomaly fans and it’s offshoots like GAMMA and EFP are nothing but a bunch tourists from games like escape from Tarkov, Ready or not, Day Z etc who not only not played the Stalker games but discard them entirely. I’ve personally seen more people complaining about these people rather than these people themselves. But this mindset is not only a disservice to stalker but also a disservice to the mods they’re trying to brush off Stalker with because those mods were never there to replace the Stalker games but rather to add unique twist to Stalker.
That seems to largely be it from what I’ve seen do you think these are warranted? No hatred towards anomaly or it’s creator or the creators of the modpacks just wanted to see what people thought of three main things of what make anomaly so controversial.