r/slp • u/Temporary_Dust_6693 • 19h ago
advocacy The FixSLP-S2C crossover
Jeanette went on a podcast known for promoting Spelling to Communicate. The podcast host, David Kaufer, objects to ASHA for their position statement against S2C, so the two discuss their shared disdain for ASHA. I won't summarize the episode, as you all can listen yourselves, but I'll leave you with two teaser quotes:
On why ASHA opposes S2C, Jeanette says, "I have to suspect it starts from someone who doesn't like it for a specific reason who's on that committee that has something to protect. That's my guess because it all comes down to money with them. Everything is about money. Nothing that I see is for the best of the community or the people who receive our services."
In her defense of S2C, Jeanette makes no mention of the fact that the primary objection to S2C comes down to authorship: who is authoring the messages. She says, "Our job is to help your kid communicate, right? Like, it doesn't matter what my opinion is. It matters what's working to get your kid to communicate. And and that's that's kind of the stance I've taken. It doesn't matter what the research says. If there are this many families saying like, 'Hey, this is working for us.' Then we need to believe them, right?"
For those of you looking for more information on Spelling to Communicate, I suggest:
-www.facilitatedcommunication.org
-https://www.asha.org/slp/asha-warns-against-rapid-prompting-method-or-spelling-to-communicate/
-Interrogating neurotypical bias in Facilitated Communication: https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s40474-024-00296-w