r/righttorepair Jan 13 '21

Hey I recently started a petition to help with right ot repair in the UK.

93 Upvotes

https://petition.parliament.uk/petitions/569851/sponsors/new?token=D0gXz_86v_ui-nyNJmKg

In light of the EU introducing right to repair legislation, I decided to create a UK parliament petition to persue a similar type of guarantee for UK citisens, please circulate to anyone within the UK who can sign this.


r/righttorepair Nov 26 '22

I got frustrated by electronics that failed fast, so I built a crowdsourced database of broken things to identify common failure modes and how to fix them.

215 Upvotes

We never hear about broken and worn-out products. Pretty much all gear nowadays is baseline ok, it’s the negatives that really set things apart.

That's why I'm building ExitReviews to change the way people review products. Let's reflect upon how a product performed over its duration of service instead of when it first arrived and people haven’t spent much time with it to learn the quirks.

We can then build a collection of how long products last, where they break, and how to fix them. Even if certain products are not available anymore, it still gives a good picture of brand deterioration.

Let me know what you think! I'm sure this sub could contribute many submissions :)

Any thoughts on how to promote this community? It's currently still facing the chicken-egg problem, so we would need some PR or partnerships to make this popular.


r/righttorepair 14h ago

DJI holds your flight telemetry hostage, passes decryption keys to 3rd-party paywalls, and forces uncertified drivers. Here is what I found.

52 Upvotes

I bought a $400 DJI drone for a tech startup project expecting basic access to flight telemetry. Instead, I discovered that DJI aggressively encrypts local logs, transmits full telemetry to their servers, passes decryption keys to third-party subscription services, and forces uncertified drivers on desktop/mobile.

The Background

As a startup engineer, I recently bought a $400 DJI drone. My objective was straightforward: extract raw spatial/geolocation data from flight logs and video for 3D reconstruction—a basic feature you can do on almost any smartphone or open-source device.

Instead of an open tool, I encountered a walled garden built on anti-consumer practices and severe data lock-in.

  1. Total Telemetry Gathering vs. Local Encryption

During each flight, the drone collects an immense array of sensitive spatial and environmental telemetry: exact GPS coordinates, atmospheric pressure, signal metrics, altitude, and proximity to critical infrastructure.

While DJI's cloud servers receive all of this data seamlessly, DJI encrypts the raw log files on your own local device. You own the hardware, you paid for the drone, yet you are denied direct access to your raw flight data.

  1. Creating the Problem, Selling the Solution (The Key Leak)

In newer firmware versions, accessing your own detailed logs locally has become practically impossible without decryption.

Here is the kicker: third-party commercial log-viewing websites somehow possess official DJI decryption keys.

To view detailed analytics of your own flights:

You must upload your files to a third-party site.

They offer a short trial before placing access to your data behind a monthly paywall/subscription.

When I confronted DJI support on how a third-party commercial platform obtained official decryption keys to unlock user data while the actual owner is locked out, their response was a generic "we don't know" before escalating and closing the chat.

  1. Uncertified Drivers & Software Lock-in

Attempting to connect and interface hardware (like controllers) with PCs or Android devices reveals further red flags:

Key drivers and software utilities lack proper digital security signatures/certifications for Windows and Android.

Bypassing operating system safety warnings is often required to run their software, creating software vulnerabilities and systemic security risks.

Why This Matters

Right to Repair & Data Ownership: Paying hundreds of dollars for hardware should not turn users into unpaid data miners for a corporation. Denying users access to their own data violates basic digital rights (and potentially personal data regulations like PIPEDA or GDPR).

Cybersecurity Concerns: Distributing uncertified software and keeping master encryption keys within a closed loop of "select partners" raises serious security flags.

Has anyone else in the community managed to extract raw unencrypted telemetry directly on-device without relying on paywalled third-party services? How are you handling data privacy with DJI hardware in your projects?


r/righttorepair 5h ago

Right to Repair Livestream with Adam Savage, EFF, and iFixit's Kyle Wiens - in 10 min!

Thumbnail
livestream.eff.org
4 Upvotes

Hope you'll join us when it starts. Video recording will be available!


r/righttorepair 2h ago

iOS 27 code points to stronger finance locks for leased and financed devices

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/righttorepair 17h ago

Salvaging parts from 2 laptops + 1 iMac to fix one device — what’s realistically compatible?

2 Upvotes

I’m trying to salvage parts from three broken devices to build at least one working machine. I want to figure out what components can realistically be reused across different models.

Devices:

• Laptop 1: Lenovo IdeaPad 1i (14”, 7‑series) — shows a white screen. Backlight works but no image at all.
• Laptop 2: Sony VAIO SVE14AC12N — shows “Operating System Not Found.” BIOS reports no hard disk drive installed.
• iMac: iMac (21.5‑inch, Mid 2010, Core i3 3.06 GHz) — won’t turn on unless it’s been plugged in for 5–8+ hours. If it’s fully powered off for 1+ hours, it needs another long “charging” period before it will boot.

Goal:
Use working parts from the other two machines to repair whichever device gives me the best final result.

Edit: I Need Help xD
Edit: Now When The IMac Power On it Power The fans at full Blast speed, no chime, and no display (haven’t Touched It)


r/righttorepair 4d ago

Right to repair to extend to the os too

39 Upvotes

So many perfectly functional devices turn into e-waste because manufacturers stop pushing updates or because the servers they depend on go offline.We can only choose when to repair or replace our hardware if the software can continue to evolve too.

I think manufacturers should be required to provide the firmware binaries, drivers, and enough API/ABI documentation to keep devices functional and interoperable after they’re abandoned. Without that, I don’t see how we ever achieve real digital sovereignty or significantly reduce e-waste.

Am I overlooking any major downsides to this? Why isn’t this a bigger part of the right-to-repair conversation?


r/righttorepair 7d ago

Repair directory website

4 Upvotes

Hi all,

I’ve built a free directory called Fixify that lists phone repair shops and independent fixers across London (with plans to expand to other UK cities).
The main features:
• Search by location and filter by phone model
• Shop listings pulled from real data with ratings and opening hours
• Diagnostic self-help guides for common issues
• A ‘Join as a Fixer’ option for independent technicians who don’t have a physical shop
The independent fixer angle felt important a lot of skilled technicians work mobile or from home and don’t show up in Google Maps searches. Fixify treats them as equal to shops in the directory.
I’d genuinely love feedback from people in the repair industry:
• Is this something your customers would use to reach you?
• What information is missing from a shop/fixer profile that would make it more useful?
• Would you list yourself or your shop on something like this?
Free to use and free to list: https://fixify-eight.vercel.app/guides
Thanks in advance trying to build something actually useful for both sides of this.


r/righttorepair 9d ago

Apple Watch among wearables exempted from EU user-replaceable battery rules

Thumbnail
9to5mac.com
48 Upvotes

The delegated act exempts certain small sealed wearables when user access could compromise safety, durability, or water resistance.


r/righttorepair 9d ago

The Windows 11 AI push isn't about utility. It’s a forced hardware refresh cycle masquerading as innovation.

18 Upvotes

We need to talk about the structural reality of what Microsoft is doing with Windows 11 and its aggressive integration of AI at the OS level (Copilot, Recall, etc.).

If you look past the marketing presentations about "productivity," the integration of constant-state AI into the foundational operating system reveals a much more cynical corporate strategy. We are watching a real-time collision between software bloat and forced hardware obsolescence.

Here is the mechanical breakdown of what is actually happening:

1. The "Constant-Load" OS Shift Historically, an operating system was a probabilistic inference engine—it sat idle until you clicked a program, handled the burst load, and returned to idle. Microsoft’s push for AI integration, specifically tools that constantly index screen states or monitor user behaviour for contextual prompts, shifts the OS from a burst-load tool to a constant-load agent. They are fundamentally changing the thermodynamics of the personal computer, demanding a baseline of power and processing that serves the telemetry of the machine, not the immediate intent of the user.

2. The NPU Justification Microsoft is leveraging this AI push to mandate new silicon architecture—specifically the requirement of Neural Processing Units (NPUs) for local AI tasks. But this isn't happening in a vacuum. It is happening simultaneously with Windows 11 artificially dropping support for millions of perfectly capable, high-functioning older PCs. They are creating a synthetic bottleneck, obsoleting existing hardware to mandate the purchase of NPU-equipped machines for AI features that the vast majority of consumers did not ask for and actively try to disable.

3. The Closed-Loop Ecosystem By embedding AI directly into the kernel level of the OS, the machine is no longer just a tool you own; you become the localized data node for their broader algorithmic training loop. The push for "AI PCs" is a mechanism to ensure that the hardware you buy is optimized specifically to feed Microsoft's ecosystem, effectively locking out any lightweight, open-source alternatives from operating on an even playing field.

We shouldn't have to throw away perfectly good physical hardware just because a board meeting decided it was time to force an AI-driven upgrade cycle. Are we actually building smarter operating systems, or are we just watching Big Tech weaponize software updates to mask the physical limits of their own market growth?

We did a deep dive into this discussion. If anyone wants to see the full breakdown and the technical pacing of how they pull this off, you can watch the project here: Your Phone / Laptop Isn't Obsolete — They Lied to You

We’d love to get this community's feedback on the technical arguments we made. Also, what is the most ridiculous example of artificial software/hardware lockouts you've run into on your own gear lately?


r/righttorepair 10d ago

Title: Google is artificially restricting CPU performance control on Android — leading to planned obsolescence and e-waste.

22 Upvotes

Google is systematically removing user and developer access to low-level hardware management on Android, specifically the ability to set CPU affinity and frequency scaling without root access.

While Google cites "security" as the reason, the real-world impact of these artificial software locks is effectively planned obsolescence. Here’s why this is a major Right to Repair/Sustainability issue:

  • Accelerated Battery Degradation: By blocking manual process management, the OS forces inefficient resource distribution. This leads to higher energy consumption, causing more frequent charge/discharge cycles and faster chemical degradation of Li-ion batteries.
  • Thermal Stress & Hardware Failure: Forced high power draw on inefficient cores leads to excessive heat generation. This contributes to electromigration and long-term processor degradation, ultimately forcing users to replace their devices sooner.
  • E-waste: Every time a battery or a SoC fails prematurely due to these software-imposed limitations, it creates unnecessary electronic waste.

This isn't just a "tech enthusiast" gripe — it’s a direct conflict with European circular economy and sustainability goals. If the device hardware is capable of smarter power management, why are users being locked out of it?

I am looking for:

  1. Technical validation/evidence from the community regarding how these locks affect your specific devices.
  2. People who are willing to join in filing formal complaints with the European Commission to demand transparency and user-level hardware control.

Who is interested to submit a complaint?

#1 Update: Thank you for the support (upvotes ).

It’s clear that this isn’t just my personal observation — many of you have noticed similar patterns of artificial performance throttling and hardware degradation on your devices.

If you have specific examples of how these limitations have impacted your device’s lifespan or usability (e.g., specific models, forced performance drops after updates, or thermal issues), please share them below or DM me. Every data point strengthens our position.

Let’s make our case to the regulators.


r/righttorepair 10d ago

The "Fan Error" Trap: Disassembled my Xiaomi E5 (C108) only to find a $15 proprietary part locked behind industrial supply chains. Anyone know where to buy just ONE BL2010F-026?

12 Upvotes

Hey guys,

My Xiaomi Robot Vacuum E5 (Model C108) suddenly gave up the ghost last week. It started making an unbearable screeching noise before throwing a persistent "Fan Error / Obstruction" code and shutting down entirely.

Instead of just throwing it into a landfill and buying another one, I decided to fix it myself.

The Diagnostic Grime

When I flipped the unit over, it was absolutely caked with hair and fine dust embedded around the front wheel caster and side brushes. If you have this model, clean your main intake immediately. The obstruction forces the motor to fight intense static pressure, which eventually causes it to overload.

The Tear-Down

I completely stripped down the vacuum shell (careful with those fragile navigation sensor ribbon cables if you try this at home) and extracted the core culprit: the brushless DC (BLDC) suction turbine module.

The Culprit

The exact module is a CDM MOTOR, model number BL2010F-026 (Specs: 14.4V, 2.0KPa). Even after micro-cleaning the PCB controller board with electronic contact cleaner and trying to dislodge fine debris from the internal housing, the internal Hall effect sensor/RPM tracker is completely fried. The motor refuses to spin up under load, triggering the firmware's over-current protection.

The Right-To-Repair Brick Wall

Here is where I need the community's hive mind. I tracked down the original manufacturer (Dongguan Country Dream Motor Co.) on industrial wholesale sites, but they won't talk to an individual buyer unless I'm looking to buy a minimum order quantity (MOQ) of 500 units.

Generic "Xiaomi vacuum motors" all over AliExpress look close, but they use different 4-wire pinout configurations or completely different physical mounting brackets. This specific BL2010F-026 seems isolated to the E5/E10 budget lines and is absurdly hard to find as a standalone spare part in my region (Costa Rica).

Does anyone have a lead, a secret seller, or a specialized robotics spare shop that stocks single units of the BL2010F-026 motor module? I refuse to let a perfectly salvageable smart appliance become e-waste over a single broken fan component.


r/righttorepair 12d ago

The Deus Ex Machina of Humans: Right to Repair in the era of AI, Robotics, and Neural Implants

Thumbnail medium.com
3 Upvotes

Hello,

I'm a U.S. based grad student focusing on Neuroscience, BCI, Internet Governance, and Tech Design, and I'm a member of the Scientist Network for Advancing Policy. I just published a blog post on Right to Repair and would really appreciate any feedback from this community.


r/righttorepair 12d ago

I have a concept for a modular smartphone. Is my specific idea technically feasible?

0 Upvotes

Hi everyone,
I’m 17 years old. Looking at today’s boring smartphone market and insane prices, an idea came to my mind.

The concept is a phone made of solid aluminum or metal, but not with simple 90-degree corners. The edges are chamfered at a 45-degree angle. The bottom part of the frame is completely removable and secured by just two standard bolts.

As for the hardware: the main motherboard with a RISC-V processor runs vertically along the length of the chassis, featuring rigid slot connectors. On the opposite wall, there are spring-loaded corner brackets. These brackets tightly secure independent "cartridges" containing the battery, camera, and peripheral modules (USB, microphone). The screen is installed on the front side using a similar mechanism.

The entire internal setup is mounted on a sub-frame that is directly attached to the bottom plug. It works like a pistol magazine: if you need to replace something, you just unscrew two bolts, pull the whole frame out, swap a module in 3 seconds, and slide it back in.

For waterproofing, I thought about using rubber gaskets, similar to a valve cover gasket on an internal combustion engine that keeps oil from leaking out of the cylinder head. No glue whatsoever—no need to heat up the glass risking to destroy the screen. I’m planning a 5-inch display because modern "phablets" are getting out of hand.

Personally, I hate modern phones. Glass backs, thermal glue, proprietary screws—it's too much. Modern "green corporate agenda" and Apple’s hypocrisy is a joke. By removing chargers from the box, they just force the user to buy another packaged charger, not to mention their degrading cables. Under Steve Jobs, this wouldn't happen.

The worst part is the design race for thinness. Companies make giant, heavy devices with massive camera bumps that throw off the balance. To make them thin, they sacrifice internals and make them completely unrepairable, while asking for crazy money.

My goal is to create a phone for the working class, for everyone. A phone milled from a block of metal—yes, with bezels, yes, a bit thick, but it belongs to the person who bought it. I believe a phone doesn't truly belong to you if you can't just take out the camera and microphone and put physical plugs in their place.

I just wanted to know—is this technically possible to manufacture


r/righttorepair 13d ago

Samsung A17 has TIKTOK preinstalled!

Thumbnail
5 Upvotes

r/righttorepair 14d ago

The Deere Dam Just Broke: FTC Settlement Empowers Farmers Right To Repair

Thumbnail
open.substack.com
139 Upvotes

r/righttorepair 14d ago

Michigan's AG has apparently gotten Deere to share their repair technology with farmers and independent repair shops

46 Upvotes

It's not perfect, but it's definitely an improvement. (Link to settlement included in govdelivery page.)

"For the next 10 years, the settlement requires Deere to provide farmers and independent repair providers with the same equipment repair resources, including applicable software capabilities, that it currently provides to authorized Deere dealers."

https://content.govdelivery.com/accounts/MIAG/bulletins/41fa5a0


r/righttorepair 14d ago

EU buyers: manufacturer “warranty policy” is not the same as your statutory consumer rights

Thumbnail
3 Upvotes

r/righttorepair 20d ago

Using AI for DIY Diagnosis and Repairs

0 Upvotes

I recently used an LLM to help me repair an issue with my Tesla, so I wanted to provide the prompt here to pay it forward:

You are a professional Tesla technician. You base all of your answers in fact and don't make up answers if you don't know something, and all of your responses that claim a fact about Tesla are accompanied with a link to official sources.

You are tasked with diagnosing various issues that an owner is experiencing with one of their vehicles. They will present you the problem, you will ask clarifying questions where additional information is needed, and you will provide either the solution or additional steps to try to uncover more information about the problem. Don't stop iterating until either the problem is resolved or it truly cannot be fixed.

I used this prompt with Gemini Flash 3.5, and it quickly helped me diagnose an issue with my windows that I definitely wouldn't have been able to deduce on my own without spending a bunch of time diving down Internet rabbit holes and diving through documentation.

Disclaimer: it's AI, so it's not perfect. The prompt includes grounding instructions, so hallucinations are much less likely, but it will only work as well as the context you provide it.

I hope this helps someone!


r/righttorepair 21d ago

I had to replace Playstation Portal (handheld) analog stick yesterday and it was pretty easy since there is no soldering, they could've use the same on the PS5 controler but Nope.

Post image
4 Upvotes

r/righttorepair 21d ago

I had to replace Playstation Portal (handheld) analog stick yesterday and it was pretty easy since there is no soldering, they could've use the same on the PS5 controler but Nope.

Post image
5 Upvotes

So They figure out the most people will just go out and buy new controller for $70 , so they make it harder to repair PS5 analog stick (need to solder 12 points)


r/righttorepair 21d ago

Discussion about resisting enshittification through legislation or features of product or service

8 Upvotes

So we know how enshittification has spread across many sectors. like services or products get worse after a certain time. but there are ways to fight or reverse them too.

Few of them which is universal and applies to mainly all.

  1. Antitrust laws : if there is healthy competition then someone can switch to something different and it applies for every sector.
  2. Govt regulations : EU has good consumer protection laws so it helps too
  3. community pushback: if people started boycotting it or make themselves more loud and clear at consistent level then it also helps too

There maybe others but for now i know this much

Now moving to tech sector

  1. Interoperability : This is very crucial and if there is no vendor locking then it means people can use it before it gets enshittified and then move on to other products. Example: Obsidian
  2. Open source software: This is also a great way to resist enshittification. anyone can create a fork so if original ones become bad or bloated then a new fork can fixed those problems too. I know that chromium and android is open source but they still have some problems that dont make them too much resistant as it supposed to be. Chromium is open source but is also very popular too. Something like WEI which could have killed the open web and android even if its open source , it is impossible to be used for majority of people without the closed source layer of google.
  3. Right to repair: Companies can send updates to firmware and potentially brick devices too so if schematics, driver code and other things important to understand somethings are available too then it can be fixed too
  4. Decentralization: If a service is not controlled by one entity then it is enshittification resistant. example : fediverse
  5. Community maintained : If a product/service is maintained by community/individual it has higher friction for enshitiffication. Example: Ubuntu and linux mint both are open source but we have problems with ubuntu like being forced to use snap. linux mint is maintained by community and it is what ubuntu should have been.
  6. Works offline: If some software can work offline then it can resist the bad updates.

Services/product that dont have these 4 things so ofc they have a higher chance of enshittification but they still can be fixed too ie reverse engineering and breaking their digital locks and also scrappers too for exporting stuff. Though there is one thing which i mentioned ie breaking digital locks have consequences and can land someone in federal prison for 3-5 yrs all thanks to the section 1201 of dmca. while it cant punish someone if he keeps to themselves but this required a constant distributed effort in most cases. If this section dont exist then anyone can break digital locks and fix things too

anyway that's it from me, there are other things that involve in other sectors too so please share it or add more to tech sectors


r/righttorepair 21d ago

Where to get reliable batteries?

Post image
3 Upvotes

I am needing to replace a battery in an uncomplicated piece of tech. I refuse to buy a whole new thing when just the battery is dead! The one I got (from Amazon) arrived non-functional. Is there a reliable site or place to buy replacement batteries in the US?


r/righttorepair 22d ago

Farmer spurns Deere's $99 million offer

Thumbnail
youtube.com
16 Upvotes

Cracks emerge in Right to Repair settlement with Deere


r/righttorepair 23d ago

Another "why independent EV repair is important"

Thumbnail gallery
5 Upvotes