r/okbuddycinephile 7h ago

A historically accurate adaptation of 'The Odyssey'

Post image
4.4k Upvotes

2.0k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

46

u/Auggie_Otter 5h ago

The Odyssey wasn't originally written down. It's an epic poem that was part of an oral tradition passed down through memorization and would sort of be sung or recited to the audience in a rhythm (dactylic hexameter) that made it easier to remember. 

A typical full traditional performance of the epic took about 20 hours, usually broken up over several days. 

28

u/AwysomeAnish 5h ago

 usually broken up over several days. 

I love the implication of one really dedicated guy going at it for 20 hours while a bunch of equally dedicated people listen to it for 20 hours

3

u/Fluffy-Pop-3407 2h ago

We binge 20 hours of The Wire without breaking a sweat; things haven't changed so much.

1

u/whatsbobgonnado Neil breens #1 fan 1h ago

I wish homer could've lived long enough to watch the wire

9

u/LogicalInfo1859 5h ago
  1. Open Reddit

  2. Read phrase "dactylic hexameter"

  3. ?????

  4. Profit

5

u/Wild-Lychee-3312 3h ago

It is imperative that the dactylic hexameter remain unharmed.

2

u/Ashrewishjewish 4h ago
  1. New porn name?

2

u/Delta-Ka 1h ago

Would honestly love a version of the Odyssey that is just people listening to the story told. Like a worse audiobook

2

u/DepartmentFamous9932 5h ago

Don’t bother bud - correcting the masses’ ignorance on this poem will be an exercise in futility.

3

u/Houdinii1984 5h ago

I mean, this individual learned something that'll stick. I just usually upvote and move on. Sometimes it's not about reaching everyone, but just reaching a few that want the info.

1

u/AwysomeAnish 5h ago

Wasn't ORIGINALLY written down. Then someone wrote it down.

1

u/jewrassic_park-1940 5h ago

How do you know that?

-1

u/TheYear1414 4h ago

Aw look everybody, its a pick me chud.

He thinks he's not part of the unwashed masses, how cute.

1

u/DepartmentFamous9932 4h ago

In this regard, considering I’ve read and memorized large parts of the Iliad and Odyssey in Ancient Greek, I’m not. It’s nice that people are getting excited about it but I check my desire for others’ historical understanding at the door because otherwise these convos are aggravating.

0

u/TheYear1414 4h ago

You could have memorized large parts of the hammurabi code in ancient babylonian doesnt change anything.

If you say stupid shit like correcting the masses ignorance you are the very definition of the Dunning Kruger effect.

You're uncomfortably sitting on the peak of mount stupid.

Dont worry though, soon enough you'll fall down the slide of awareness and hit the bottom of the valley of despair.

Maybe you'll develop some self-awareness along the way.

1

u/WittyCombination6 4h ago edited 4h ago

Wait so what you're saying we could have had Christopher Nolan do a bunch of Greek mythology movies the length of the Harry Potter franchise.

Edit: I've read another comment saying the Odyssey is poem 7 out of 8. So they could have had Christopher Nolan Greek mythos MCU

Man Hollywood just doesn't like money.

2

u/EscapeSeventySeven 3h ago

Yeah. But it’s just a single shot of a person standing around a campfire doing each section of the poem in one take. 

1

u/lift_1337 3h ago

It's poem 7 of 8, but we only have surviving copies of the Iliad and the Odyssey. We know about the other 6 because we have surviving references to them (including in the surviving copies of the 2 we do have). 

1

u/Warm-Professional494 2h ago

It’s pretty much understood that the story we know of today was not what Homer had created because it was added to and adjusted for the times it was told.