r/obamacare • u/swampwiz • 14h ago
This is the optimal strategy for those that can control their income
I suppose this is only for the early-retired or self-employed, and have the ability to adjust ACA income (i.e., MAGI) at will.
First, you project an income that is below 150% of poverty income (PI), and get a Silver plan - but at least 138% of PI, if in a Medicaid-expansion state, or 100% of PI if in a non-expansion state (oh, the irony that these states get a better deal!). The Silver plan will end up being a special CSM-enhanced plan that has an actuarial payout of 94% (i.e, the Silver-94% plan), rather than the 70% for the normal plan. You will also get an Advance Premium Tax Credit (APTC) that makes the cost of the 2nd Lowest Cost Silver Plan (2LCSP) be 3% of income.
Then, make sure your actual income is below 200% of poverty. This will keep the APTC reconciliation at tax time to the lowest tier (currently, only $395 for an Individual), so your net premium cost (presuming you get the 2LCSP) will be only 3% of poverty + $395, or about $875 (for an Individual). If you exceed this, the reconciliation gets much more painful.
Something else that needs to be considered is that you can only get the APTC at your projected income if the "data matching" shows your income as within a certain amount, the greater of $12K or 50% of data-matched income. For folks without a steady paycheck (or a steady pension/SS), the data-match will be the latest tax filing, which is for the tax year 2 years before the coverage year. If income for every year is shown as always being less than 200% of PI, then projecting an income of 138%, or even 100%, of PI will be within this guideline, and the system will award the APTC for that income, and using the Silver-94% plan.
However, if the projected income is out of this envelope, than there will be no APTC, and the Silver plan will be the Silver-70%. And if you don't have a steady income, you will not be able to prove a lower income, and you will be in a world of sheet; yes, you could reconcile to get an APTC refund (of course, you would actually need to have that lower income to get that refund), but you will not be able to undo having that 70% plan instead of the 94% plan.
This is the way the game is played: play well, and you win - play poorly, and you lose.