r/nerdfighters • u/Elmaslunch • 3h ago
Hank response in comments Hank has started using AI generated images in his educational videos
EDIT: Hank has removed the image from the video, so it no longer shows up at the stated timestamp.
A diagram Hank used in his new video "You Have Never Seen a Normal Star" looks to be AI generated (shown at 7:01). A few indications being the faint dark pattern/texture around the tops and sides of the spheres, the "SMALL SPHERE INSIDE LARGE SPHERE (CONTEXT)" phrase which reads as very AI-esque, and some of the math just being wrong. Also, just from a meta perspective, I don't think Hank would go through the high effort needed to create this image without AI for a 5 second throw-away diagram.
I find this pretty depressing. There was much debate in this subreddit over the ethics of Hank AI "vibe-coding" his recent websites/games, but to me, AI generating images crosses a pretty definitive ethical line. AI image models were trained on the stolen copyrighted materials of essentially anyone who ever posted an image online, and used without compensation or consent. You don't need me to rehash the whole laundry list of reasons AI is bad here, but Hank's pivot into AI usage as someone who's spoken at length about climate change is darkly ironic in my view. Also, just theorizing here, but I think Hank is going to make enough money off this video to have hired a graphic designer real quick to make this image for him. Or you know, any of the graphics people who work for Complexly. Anything human-made would be better than this
Because folks, using AI for educational purposes is a bad idea! There are a few weird mistakes in this image:
- The r_small line under the green sphere in the top right extends across the DIAMETER of the sphere, not the radius.
- The diagram on the right showing the small sphere inside the large sphere has the smaller one being around 6 times smaller in diameter instead of 18 times.
- As seen in the bottom left, 18.1 to the power of 3 is not approximately 5891, but rather around 5929
Moreover, the 5891 number quoted as the volume ratio is simply wrong. It was calculated using the rounded figures of 4.1E9 units^3 and 6.96E5 units^3. If you do the full calculation of the ratio of the volumes of the 55 unit radius sphere and the 1000 unit radius sphere, you find that their volume ratio is 6011, not 5891. Now this isn't necessarily an indication of sloppy AI math. The inputs could have just been manually rounded by Hank himself. It's just a bit of an annoyance for me, a pedant.
Anyway this sucks! I never thought Hank would force me to go through Brandolini's law to clarify misinformation, but here we are. If you're reading this Hank, I think you should stop AI generating images. You're on a slippery slope. Just my opinion.
I'm feeling like Wesley in the Star Trek: TNG episode where everyone gets addicted to that VR video game, only to find out captain Picard is hooked on it too...
