r/maninthehighcastle • u/AntiqueWash2656 • 15h ago
r/maninthehighcastle • u/fleckes • Nov 15 '19
Season 4: Episode Discussion Threads Hub
This is a hub for links to all Season 4 Episode Discussion Threads, so it's easier for people to find the threads they are looking for.
THIS IS NOT A THREAD FOR DISCUSSION, SO THIS THREAD IS LOCKED
No comments allowed here, as otherwise people that only look for a link to a discussion thread may get spoilers from episodes they haven't seen yet.
r/maninthehighcastle • u/fleckes • Nov 15 '19
Episode Discussion: S04E10 - Fire from the Gods
On the brink of an inevitable Nazi invasion, the BCR brace for impact as Kido races against the clock to find his son. Childan offers everything he has to make his way back to Yukiko. Helen is forced to choose whether or not to betray her husband, as she and Smith travel by high speed train to the Portal - with Juliana and Wyatt lying in wait.
r/maninthehighcastle • u/lNFORMATlVE • 12h ago
Spoilers Jahr Null doesn’t make mathematical sense
It just occurred to me that how in TMITHC the Nazis in the GNR get all excited about “Jahr Null” which is means “Year Zero” i.e. they are rewriting the BC/AD/BCE/CE calendar to restart from that point and erase a bunch of american history and culture.
But there is no such thing as 0 BC or 0 AD: the first year was 1 AD which followed 1 BC. In the same way that there is no “0th century AD”, only a 1st century AD, the first year in a new calendar will always be called the first year, or year 1. Not year 0 because that would be the “0th year of X” which doesn’t make sense.
So there can’t be a Jahr Null. It should be Jahr Eins.
Stoopid Nazis.
r/maninthehighcastle • u/Relative_Race8887 • 1d ago
New here
I’ve never seen or heard of this show but this sub was recommended to me. Convince me to watch it? Or don’t, I’m just always looking for new stuff!
r/maninthehighcastle • u/Specialist-Kick-4403 • 3d ago
Juliana Crane is annoying
It’s like she bounces between men every episode and has no problem with just ending the life of said man. I’m also pissed that they put a T55 as a German tank in 1946 when it would’ve likely been a Panther G according to SS armoured divisions at the time. THE SHIPS DONT HAVE ANTI SHIP MISSILES IN THE 60s but a 1970s KA27 Soviet helicopter. I don’t like the show it’s unrealistic and Juliana is passed around. Her and Joe would’ve been great, franks a weirdo
r/maninthehighcastle • u/Master_Restaurant_44 • 3d ago
Juliana did a terrible job recruiting people
Juliana wanted to use the films to give people hope, which is excellent, but she shouldn't have said that other worlds exist—something very difficult to believe. More propaganda would have been more effective.
r/maninthehighcastle • u/BarbacoaWoah7 • 3d ago
What happened to the Bismarck?
Did they still cut her down?
r/maninthehighcastle • u/Shot_Age3609 • 3d ago
Mangele as head scientist of the die nebenwelt program makes absolutely no sense
He was a physician and to my knowledge he had absolutely no degrees or extensive knowledge of physics it would have made no sense to have him as the head of this program it would've made much more sense if the head of this program was Heisenberg, Johannes Stark or Phillip Lenard
r/maninthehighcastle • u/Secret_Ruin_9808 • 5d ago
I’m pretty new to MITHC; which episode is this shot from?
Forgive my ignorance 😅
r/maninthehighcastle • u/ShoutingTom • 6d ago
Season 4 question re: BCR & Yakuza scene
So the scene where the BCR is sweeping the Japanese buildings after taking over where they follow the music to a large room where the Yakuza boss is waiting to speak with them.
Think of this from Producer Guy's (of the Pitch Meeting series) perspective.
How long was he waiting for them? Did he get up that morning and just head over there and clock in for the day?
I mean sure they could have been tracking BCR movements and were able to time it closely but that's just as silly. I'm imagining the boss peeking around corners with a record player tucked under his arm, waiting for a signal so that he can sprint to the dark back of the building, probably giggling.
r/maninthehighcastle • u/Master_Restaurant_44 • 7d ago
Oswald Mosley is the governor of England, right?
I'm disappointed that we didn't see more countries during the series and how they were governed, specifically the USSR, China, and England. If Rockwell was the Reichsmarshall of the United States, that means that if an occupied territory had a fascist organization like the British Union of Fascists, that would be the one governing the puppet state, right?
r/maninthehighcastle • u/ClintBlondieEastwood • 9d ago
John Smith's sunglasses
So I'm going to make a gift for a friend and i couldn't find a definitive answer what type and brand of sunglasses he wears when he went fishing with Thomas. Ai says it's rayban wayfarer, then clubmaster, also suggests american optical saratoga and Oliver peoples Cary grant. Any ideas? I want to be as close as i can get to the actual ones.
r/maninthehighcastle • u/BetaSoyJaneDoe • 10d ago
First time discoverer/watcher/binger of the Netflix series
I have reached season 4. John has consistently been my favorite character despite his villain status.. what he did to Danny. YOU SON OF A BITCH! I don't know if I can forgive him. I have overlooked a lot of what he has done because I understood his reasoning, but that literally made my heart crush! Send me help please x_ x
**edit to note that I learned this was an Amazon series
r/maninthehighcastle • u/HappyAd4609 • 12d ago
What if during the show, The Third Reich and the Japanese Empire entered into a Nuclear War? Wich characters from the show would survive or die? What happens next? Can they survive?
Wich characters would perish in the hellfire? Wich ones would survive?
What happens next to the people and groups of interest that manage to make it out alive?
r/maninthehighcastle • u/L1ng02 • 15d ago
Spoilers I’m 2 episodes in and I figured out who the ‘Man in the High Castle’ is!
The ‘Man in the high castle’ is a figure that scares the (German) government.
They produce film tapes that are illegal to own and ordered to be destroyed.
No one knows who the ‘Man in the high castle’ is or how the tapes are made.
These tapes have knowledge that should be impossible.
When someone watches them are seemingly compelled to watch the full thing (even multiple times).
When they watch the tapes their goals change. Juliana takes the tape to Canon City and Joe disobeys orders.
And think about that name, ‘Man in the high castle’, who lives in a castle… a King.
‘Man in the high castle’ is the King in Yellow!
r/maninthehighcastle • u/Ferguson97 • 17d ago
I just started season 2… does Juliana get less frustrating?
r/maninthehighcastle • u/Icy_Flan_7185 • 17d ago
Spoilers [SPOILERS] Juliana and Thomas plot line in S2 was hilarious Spoiler
Juliana killing multiple important resistance members to save him, only for him to immediately hand himself in to be euthanised
r/maninthehighcastle • u/Expensive_Team_5854 • 17d ago
Love her when she smokes.
r/maninthehighcastle • u/OwnMarionberry5682 • 18d ago
John Smith Edit - r e i c h s w a v e
Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification
r/maninthehighcastle • u/MichiganFan90 • 18d ago
BCR
So the scene that hit me in Man in the high castle
Was when they all were saying we're there family's
Had fallen and the lead person said my home town of
Saginaw Michigan
I freaked out at that part
r/maninthehighcastle • u/Tomnenhumnomeserve • 18d ago
Redesigned Flag of my Headcanon for the End (Free States of America)
r/maninthehighcastle • u/Stunning_Wear_351 • 18d ago
Real
I had always wanted to make this for years!
Happy 4th of July!
r/maninthehighcastle • u/Master_Restaurant_44 • 19d ago
How were the territories occupied by the Reich administered?
From the beginning, I find it curious that the United States was governed by Rockwell, who was a Reichsmarshall, a military rank. Does that mean that the American Reich was a military government?