r/india 23h ago

Health Wet Bathroom

0 Upvotes

tl;dr why is everything in the bathroom wet

Recently moved into a household in Seattle WA with 3 Indian adult males. I'd say 27-37 years old. Not sure exactly where they're each from (they all have the Flag of India in their Instagram).

Have been busy so haven't truly met them, and still very new here, so don't want to make things weird.

Every time (I think one, but maybe two) of the roommates leaves the bathroom, everything is wet. Not post shower, post toilet use.

The toilet seat particularly, the floor around it, the counter, the walls, the door handle. And not a little bit wet, wet as in there's the maximum amount of water possible on that surface.

We have a powerful spraying detachable bidet (like a kitchen sink spray nozzle). The water on the surface appears to be clear. I also notice a little bucket (half galllon), which occasionally has (seemingly) used tissue in it, but and I'm guessing it's used in the process.

I have to use a TON of toilet paper or paper towels just to step in the bathroom, and more just to sit down. Not to mention the hygiene piece... I can't imagine the water is all "clean" (ie deflected spray), plus pools of water in dark humid areas = mold (lo and behold we have a ton of black mold).

Everyone else in the household has been here for at least 1 year, and nobody seems to raise an issue, so I'm hesitant to bring it up. It's clearly something I don't understand, and something they're OK with, so I'd like to better understand before discussing.


r/india 8h ago

Politics RSS-affiliated outfit ABVP condemns clashes at CJP protest: ‘Address student issues through…’

Thumbnail
hindustantimes.com
0 Upvotes

r/india 13h ago

Politics "Why Go To Protest When I Could Study, Improve My Score": NEET Topper To NDTV

Thumbnail
ndtv.com
0 Upvotes

r/india 20h ago

Politics Does the real situation on the ground reach the Prime Minister without being filtered?

0 Upvotes

I often wonder whether the Prime Minister truly receives an accurate picture of what's happening on the ground. I'm talking about the real problems that ordinary people deal with every day.

My feeling is that after someone reaches the highest levels of government, most information comes through layers of officials and party leaders. At every level, reports can get softened, filtered, or presented in a more positive light. As a result, the leadership may not always see the complete reality.

In earlier times, kings were often said to disguise themselves and mingle with the public to understand what people genuinely thought about them and what problems they were facing. The purpose was to get an unfiltered view of the situation rather than relying only on what advisors reported.

When Narendra Modi first became Prime Minister, he came from a grassroots political background, having worked his way up from being a party worker to Chief Minister and then Prime Minister. It seemed like he had a strong understanding of the everyday challenges faced by ordinary Indians. Initiatives such as building toilets, expanding bank account access through Jan Dhan Yojana, improving roads, and addressing corruption through measures like demonetisation reflected issues that affected millions of people.

However, after more than a decade in office, I sometimes wonder whether the information reaching him is still as accurate as it once was. If the leadership had a completely honest picture of the ground reality, perhaps some long-standing issues would have received greater attention by now.

Today, people continue to raise concerns about delays in projects like the bullet train, the quality of roads, corruption within parts of the police system, the weakening rupee, and many other governance-related issues. These are concerns that many citizens discuss and expect solutions for.

Just as many people have argued that the Congress party could improve its prospects by promoting capable leadership, there is also a growing perception among some people that the BJP has increasingly welcomed leaders from other parties, including those who previously faced allegations of corruption.

This raises a broader question: shouldn't every political party have certain moral standards or minimum criteria before admitting leaders from rival parties? If a politician was considered corrupt while in the opposition, should changing parties automatically change that perception?

If politicians from every party can simply switch sides without any accountability, it becomes difficult for people to understand what principles political parties truly stand for. A healthy democracy requires both a strong government and a credible opposition. Frequent party-switching may be legally permissible, but many people question whether it is morally justified.

For example, leaders such as Jyotiraditya Scindia and Raghav Chadha are often cited in political discussions. Some observers feel that after joining the ruling party, they have become far less vocal than they were previously. Whether one agrees with that view or not, it raises a broader question about whether political leaders maintain the same level of independence and public engagement after changing parties.


r/india 15h ago

Politics Unpopular opinion: Parents of the students who took their life because of NEET should also be held accountable

0 Upvotes

I was going through demands of CJP for the government, and first two makes sense as per the protest.

What I don't find sensible is the third demand, giving 1 crore to every family of the student who suicided.

This year, due to the paper leak 21 students took their life, what many people are forgetting that last year, 35 students took their life after the results of NEET were announced. There was no paper leak last year.

People are ignoring the bigger issue, the extreme pressure applied by Indian parents to their children during exams like JEE and NEET.

Yes, the education system is tough in this country, and if you don't perform well in these exams securing a good future becomes difficult, but as a parent, do you not see the type of stress your kid is taking every day for 2 years? Your child is severely struggling mentally everyday, yet you don't interfere.

I believe that if an underage student (<18 years) takes their life, there should be a police investigation on the parents, and based on what type of pressure they are putting on their child, they should be punished accordingly.


r/india 3h ago

Politics Reminder to not contact the Employers/Unis of the Ministers' children unless there is clear involvement in punishable offenses

9 Upvotes

I've noticed posts and comments encouraging folks to reach out to the Universities/Employers where the children of our ministers are currently studying or working.

While I understand the angst behind the ruling class sending their kids to other countries for better opportunities when the common man is struggling in our country, DO NOT CONTACT THESE UNIVERSITIES/EMPLOYERS ASKING TO SACK THE KIDS FOR THE CRIMES OF THEIR PARENTS.

No institution would consider a parent's crimes to be grounds for termination of the kids' employment or enrolment. Unless there is a clear case of INVOLVEMENT in a punishable or morally deplorable offense, the institutions are not going to get rid of them, and more importantly risk a wrongful termination lawsuit.

All you would achieve is get the people of other countries to be irritated by the cause the younger generation is currently fighting for.

I'm all for naming and shaming those publicly. So by all means, highlight the irony of them using the better systems and infras offered by foreign unis. But do not send emails and letters demanding for the termination of their employment/enrolment.

It won't work. All it does is paint us in poor light. Please be sensible. Unless they are involved in wrongdoing, they won't be affected by your protests to these institutions. It would be the equivalent of "India No. 1" comments we used to have (and still do) on YouTube.


r/india 14h ago

Religion I had a heated debate about religion with my mother just now

10 Upvotes

So this might be long

so you can skip this post...It is not life changing or anything

We just ended up discussing religion

we are hindus everyone in my house

but I don't believe in any religion in any capacity

ever since i was 11 or 12

I had an opinion that god is not real and It was just our creativity (I was not this articulate in my mind but still this was my opinion)

I always participate in pooja, hawan, visiting temple, etc.

(I do visit every religious place bcs i kinda like seeing people in these places or smth)

To be honest I do all these things for the sake of my family

and at times my mother praises me for standing with her while she recites prayer in the morning

and sooraj ke samne lota chadana shivling par lota chadana and thngs like that

she always knew that i am kinda atheist or if not atleast i am in that atheist direction

So I feel guilty doing all of these when i see her smile because I know i am lying to her

it is not like i act super religious

i just do whatever she ask me to and that makes her happy

so today we just happened to discuss all this

and she got a lil upset and

she said "i know how to protect my faith"

and i told her maybe "you dont know much about your religion"

and she said shut up you dont know anything

you have read any scriptures

and i said I haven't seen you complete a scripture even once

she left the room and went on doing whatever she was doing

but after some time

she still is very sweet to me and laughing and everything

I kinda feel proud that

she now atleast knows about what is going on in my mind


r/india 21h ago

People Indians Vs Indians while abroad

0 Upvotes

Hello, I'm a Canadian-Indian, and I was just wondering if anyone who has had more experience than me could explain this to me.

In Canada, nearly every Indian guy I've met at university behaves very friendly toward other Indians, which I guess is because nobody wants to miss any information related to their "immigration application," lol.

However, after leaving university, that contact just disappears. I've met other Indian guys and girls as well. In front of White people, they all behave like extroverts, filled with jokes, but the moment they're alone with another Indian guy, they go silent.

Story time: I picked up an Indian guy to go ice skating, and he only asked me about my immigration status, the job market, my CRS score, and how long I'd been in Canada. That's it!

Mind you, this is the same guy who cracks several jokes and gets drunk with other "popular" ethnicities in group settings. He literally only attends our events if non-Indian women are present.

Another case is my roommate. He loves pandering to our Chinese landlord, who's 44 years old, and his 40-year-old girlfriend, even though my roommate is only 22. He keeps cracking cheap jokes in our WhatsApp group just to become the extroverted "class clown" in response to everything my landlord and his girlfriend say. However, when it comes to my replies, it's just a 👍 emoji.

We started with the usual "Hey, hey," followed by the same "private" questions about my residency status, company name, salary, and "Where are you from in India?" kind of stuff. His Indian girlfriend once said "Hello" to me in a friendly way, like Canadians usually do, but after that, she had a conversation with the guy, and now every time we see each other, she walks the other way, always trying to avoid me. What's wrong with a simple "Hey" or "Hello"?

Let's say I'm in the kitchen or the living room, she'll leave through the other side as if I have a disease. The guy also just gives me a side-eye whenever I'm in the house, as if we acknowledge each other's existence but don't want to actually acknowledge each other.

However, this same guy happily cracks "Wassup, man?" jokes with the landlord and his girlfriend.

What goes on in their minds? The funny part is that, despite all the hate against Indians in many countries, how do some people still pretend that they, not anyone else, have a chance to become White simply by being extra friendly and cracking cheap jokes with other ethnicities? Blacks and Latinos are learning this lesson down south the hard way.

It's been bothering me because this is the third time I've observed this kind of behavior.

P.S. The guy is on a temporary resident (TR) status, while I'm a Canadian citizen.

P.S Fixed some grammatical issues with GPT 🙂


r/india 11h ago

Science/Technology Prof. Ashoke Sen on Big Bang, Multiverse, Black Holes, String Theory & Quantum Mechanics

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes

r/india 16h ago

Politics Stop Selling Dreams. Fix the Exam System First.

2 Upvotes

India dreams of becoming the world's third-largest economy. That's a great ambition. But before celebrating rankings and headlines, can we make sure students can take an exam without wondering whether the paper has already been sold?

Every time a major exam is leaked or cancelled, millions of students lose months—sometimes years - of preparation. They sacrifice sleep, money, and opportunities. Many families spend their life savings on coaching, only to watch the system fail them.

A country doesn't become a global powerhouse through slogans alone. It becomes one by building institutions people can trust.

What message are we sending to young people?

Study hard? Or hope someone doesn't leak the paper.

Merit? Or luck.

Transparency? Or endless investigations after the damage is already done.

This isn't just an education problem. It's a governance problem. Every cancelled exam delays careers, wastes public resources, and chips away at people's faith in public institutions.

If we truly want India to become an economic superpower, then protecting the integrity of examinations should be treated as national infrastructure—not as an issue that gets attention only after protests erupt.

Students don't need speeches. They need a system where their hard work is worth more than someone's corruption.

The real test isn't whether we can announce ambitious economic goals. The real test is whether the government can guarantee that an honest student's future won't depend on whether an exam paper stays secret.

Until then, "trust the system" sounds less like reassurance and more like a request for blind faith.


r/india 3h ago

Law & Courts What is the need to bring religion and politics into a protest, man?

0 Upvotes

People often say that politics and religion should have no place in protests. Fair enough but then that principle should apply equally to everyone.

So the question is: when politicians seek votes by invoking temples, religion, cows, or God from election stages, why doesn't anyone stop them? Why doesn't anyone say, "You are elected representatives. Your job is to govern the country and solve people's problems not to use religion for politics."

If we truly believe that religion and politics should be separate, then that principle shouldn't apply only to protesters. It should apply first and foremost to those in power.

In my view, religion belongs first and foremost to personal faith and prayer—whether someone says "Ram," "Waheguru," "Allah," "O Lord," or calls upon God by any other name. That is every individual's personal right.

But in public life, no religion should be placed above another. No religion has the right to insult another, and no one has the right to impose their faith on someone else.

Every person should have the freedom to follow, change, or reject a religion according to their own conscience.

Ultimately, before religion, caste, or any other identity, our greatest identity should be our shared humanity. Without humanity, compassion, and mutual respect, no religion can make us a better society.


r/india 19h ago

Politics A tactical appeal to CJP: Isolate from violent factions immediately

45 Upvotes

To anyone coordinating the CJP and the core movement right now:

you need to publicly, explicitly, and immediately cut ties with the factions and groups that have joined the protests to showcase militant strength or violent power.

​This isn't about tone policing, it is a matter of life-and-death political strategy. From a purely tactical and statecraft perspective, here is exactly what is about to happen if you don't isolate them:

​1. The "Monopoly on Violence" Trap

The modern state operates on Max Weber’s defining principle: it claims the exclusive, legitimate monopoly on physical force. The only reason the police and paramilitaries are currently restricted to lathi charges, tear gas, and water cannons is because the core youth protest has maintained strict non-violence. The second the state can capture footage of allied groups wielding weapons or using violence, it grants the government the absolute legal and political mandate to escalate to lethal, armed force.

2. Political Jiu-Jitsu & Asymmetric Warfare

You cannot out-violence the Indian state. Gene Sharp’s theory of non-violent resistance explains that peace is your only tactical shield. When a state uses force against peaceful students, it triggers "political jiu-jitsu"—the regime’s violence backfires, stripping its legitimacy and drawing mass public sympathy to the students.

​But the moment allied groups introduce violence, the state's narrative instantly flips. They will no longer be "crushing innocent students asking for NEET accountability." They will be "neutralizing a domestic security threat and restoring law and order."

3. The Provocation Playbook

Historically, regimes facing massive civil unrest want the protests to turn violent. A violent splinter group is a gift to the executive. It gives them the exact excuse they need to invoke draconian acts (like UAPA or NSA), deploy armed battalions, clear the streets with bullets, and indefinitely jail the core leadership under the guise of national security.

The Bottom Line:

Non-violence right now isn't just a moral philosophy - it is the literal physical barrier keeping the police's firearms holstered. By allowing factions to flex violent power alongside you, you are handing the government the exact justification it needs to crush the movement entirely. CJP must draw a hard line and purge these elements today.

NOTE: I USED AI TO POLISH AND IMPROVE THE ABOVE POST

UPDATE#1: BJP Govt has airlifted about 2000 CRPF from 20 companies to Delhi


r/india 10h ago

Politics Is India a lost cause ?

66 Upvotes

The amount of hate I see from a certain section of people against anyone who asks for accountability from this regime is genuinely scary. There was no concept of being "anti-national" in 2011 when I participated in the local chapter of the IAC protests and chanted against the Congress government alongside Anna. Back then, we were called patriots.

Now, every little criticism of the government, the police, or public institutions is enough for someone to brand you anti-national. I even see people claiming to be "apolitical" saying things like, "You can be against CJP and with the protesters at the same time." A huge fuck you to that mindset as well. It's astonishing to see people scrutinize a satirical political movement more than the government itself, while remaining silent about paper leaks, student deaths, police brutality, pollution, unemployment, communalism, corruption, and countless other failures.

I'm watching these protests unfold from far away, and I can't help but feel guilty that I'm not there to support them. My plan was to return to India in the next few years, but lately I've started questioning whether it's worth it. The idea of returning to a system where political, judicial, and administrative institutions seem increasingly authoritarian and unable or unwilling to act accountable is deeply disheartening.

I used to believe we could turn the tide and build a better country. But in all honesty, I'm no longer sure that's possible. I hope I'm wrong, because I'd rather be proven overly pessimistic than watch another generation inherit a country that forgot how to question those in power.


r/india 17h ago

Politics Why aren't we asking for accountability from politicians themselves?

4 Upvotes

Title: Why aren't we asking for accountability from politicians themselves?

I support demanding accountability from the government over issues like exam leaks, education, and public services. But I think we're missing a much bigger point.

Why aren't we demanding that politicians actually have skin in the game?

If a politician claims government schools are good enough for the public, why do their own children often study in elite private schools or abroad? If government hospitals are supposedly improving, why don't they use them themselves?

I'm not saying studying abroad automatically means corruption. Scholarships, family wealth, and legitimate income all exist. But if a politician's lifestyle or their children's education costs don't match their declared income and assets, shouldn't the public have the right to ask where the money came from?

Instead of dragging celebrities or cricketers into every protest, why not focus on demands that actually improve governance?

For example:

- Stronger accountability for education failures and exam leaks.

- Mandatory transparency for politicians' major expenses if they appear inconsistent with declared assets.

- Independent audits of elected officials' finances.

- Better public schools and hospitals so politicians would have confidence using them too.

To me, this seems like a more productive conversation than arguing over which celebrity posted a story or who stayed silent.

What do you think? Would policies that increase politicians' accountability be more effective than focusing on public figures who have no governing role?

CJPs protest is slowly turning into political tensions instead of paper leak issue due to involvement of politicians. People are dragging cricketers, religion , celebrities in it. What's even point of this ?


r/india 20h ago

Politics A request to anyone in the CJP Management. As an active contributor.

7 Upvotes

To everyone in the CJP management,

First, thank you for everything you've been doing. Many of us have been following your work, contributing resources where we can, and supporting the movement because we genuinely believe in what you're trying to build.

I want to raise something that I think is important for the movement's long-term success.

A movement of this scale cannot succeed in isolation. It needs to collaborate with other movements that are already organizing around interconnected issues. The protests against the Trans Bill showed that coordinated action across communities and organizations is possible, and that solidarity makes movements stronger.

It's also important to listen to the people who are most marginalized. Education is a critical issue, but it isn't the only one. Tribal rights, the impact of ethanol policies, police brutality, and other structural issues all affect the same communities that we hope to empower. Addressing these concerns together strengthens the movement rather than diluting it.

For the trans community, this feels especially urgent. Many of us who actively participate in protests and public action have been asking ourselves a difficult question: if something happens to us while we're standing up for these causes, will anyone stand with us?

Please address this. Open a conversation with us. Let us know how you see these concerns fitting into the movement and how we can work together.

At the end of the day, we're fighting for the same values. We want the same future. Building stronger alliances and making space for the most vulnerable voices will only make the movement more resilient.


r/india 12h ago

Politics Supporting the youth protests by hitting the government where it hurts. unpopular opinion.

57 Upvotes

I’ve been thinking a lot about the youth protests and how can I actually make a difference. I’ve decided to support them by being very careful with my spending.

I’m cutting back on anything that helps the government through GST, especially unnecessary stuff like new car, bike, processed foods, fancy gadgets, etc. I'm going for repairing existing one instead of buying new one. A lot of big businesses openly support the current BJP government, with political donations, advertisements and even car/bike companies are apparently downplaying issues with E20 fuel. So I’m saying no to all that for now.

Instead, I’m trying to buy directly from local producers and small businesses whenever possible. That way the money actually reaches the people who need it.

It might sound extreme, but the idea is to reduce the government’s revenue and put pressure where it matters. At the same time, I’m saving whatever I can putting money into gold, fixed deposits, or international index funds. Better to be prepared for any economic uncertainty coming up.

I’ve started living more frugally to hurt the government.


r/india 4h ago

Politics modi is not god , how to tell my dad

39 Upvotes

So my dad the other day was saying he will support modi no matter what because he protects our dharm and our religion(my family is hindu) and my dad is a very religious person and he has his reasons.

The incidents my dad has experienced are so unbelievable that, even when he told me about them, I found them hard to believe. They seem almost miraculous rather than ordinary coincidences. I know that's a subjective interpretation, and I'm not claiming everyone has to agree. But from his perspective and honestly, even from mine they're the kind of events that make it difficult to dismiss them as mere coincidence. That's why I understand why he's become so deeply religious. Those experiences shaped his faith.

So id love to be educated by you guys and I could use some points to debate with my dad and keep in mind I've been a modi supporter too until I came to reddit and saw the other side of the coin so I'm kinda neutral now i genuinely wanna be educated and if I do question you that means I'm trying to learn more and not argue .

And yeah please be respectful , if ur one of those " it cell" " how much did they pay u" typa guys u can leave.


r/india 9h ago

Politics Warring demands resignation of Mann, Bains over repeated paper leaks in Punjab

Thumbnail
tribuneindia.com
4 Upvotes

r/india 1h ago

Politics The fallacy of hunger strike and peaceful protest #ModiHataoDeshBachao

Upvotes

We have been taught since our childhood that India is the only nation on Earth who achieved independence through peaceful non violent Gandhian way only. But in reality, that’s the half truth. Sepoy mutinies, rebellion of Bhagat Singh, formation of armed force by Bose, Axis powers attack on mainland British during WW2 and many instances like that actually did the real heavy lifting that ultimately gave us our independence.

In 2018, GD Agarwal fasted unto death for the Ganga but got no media coverage and couldn’t bring any meaningful change because the underlying things I mentioned above needed for a protest to be successful wasn’t present in his case. And this is why our ruling class intentionally teach this fallacy of hunger strike and peaceful protest narrative so that we don’t revolt to change the status quo and it worked well for them since 1945 till now.

Our peaceful protest and hunger strike has completely failed. Sonam Wangchuk has been kidnapped by men in civil dress to unknown location infront of the armed forces, many CJP leaders are arrested and students are brutally beaten by dictator Modi’s uniformed goons. And opposition leader Rahul Gandhi wasn’t even allowed to speak freely about NEET Scandal in the parliament and dictator Modi’s uniformed goons also arrested him when he joined the protest.

Now some of us might think voting will change things. But Dhruv Rathee, Akash Baneerjee, Rahul Gandhi and multiple independent organizations has shown that how BJP control elections in their favor by deregistering some voters, hacking EVM machines and sending their paid goons to take physical control of some voting booths. So if our votes really mattered then dictator Modi wouldn’t anger millions of youth just to satisfy his ego.

This is our last chance to make change happen in India. This is a once in a lifetime opportunity to fix our broken nation and be a part of history. Dictator Modi and his entire cabinet of corrupt ministers must resign. And God forbid If we compromise or fail this time, then BJP will grow so bold and dangerous that they will treat every working class citizens of India as second class citizens regardless of their religion, language, state, color, culture and surname. We are a nation of both Gandhi and Bose. So dictator Modi and his corrupt ministers must know now that by destroying our Gandhian way of peaceful protest they have made methods of Bose inevitable.


r/india 15h ago

Politics Dharmendra Pradhan’s resignation isn’t enough, in fact it won’t solve anything. It’s much bigger than that and we should start asking for it. Read this!!

273 Upvotes

Before anyone says anything, I’d like to clarify that I’m a student too. I know this protest was supposed to be about paper leaks, but is that the only problem in our country?? It’s not the beginning as some people say, but more like the final nail in the coffin.

People of this country have been suffering with many more problems. Our education system is shit, our society is fucked up, people have been divided into castes and religions, corruption, reservation, food safety, citizen’s safety, no justice, fucked up infrastructure, our population, unemployment, non-existent labor laws, poverty, sexual assault and rapes have been so normalized that we’ve gone numb in that matter. I could go on and on , there are just too many things that are fucked up.

We’ve all got used to that “chalta hai” attitude and have set the bar so low that we have reduced our quality of life. Taxes are being paid regularly by honest people but it’s nowhere to be seen. The rich grow richer each day, with the poor struggling for a meal and the middle class people too occupied in surviving today to think of a better future.

Just ask yourself one thing — do we really deserve this?? It’s a protest about the education system, but nobody’s bold enough to voice out the main problem: reservation. Yes, I do know that casteism still exists, but there are still ways to reduce it and reservation is not the ideal choice. In fact, casteism and reservation go hand in hand. There could be something like: from now on only one person can use the caste system and once benefitted, they won’t get that again because they’ve already benefitted. In case of siblings, we can make an exception where 2 individuals can use reservation when the age gap is less than 5 years. This way it would come to an end someday right??

I’ve been seeing videos from the protest (I don’t live in Delhi or any metro city) and I think we need to fight for more. There are many things that need to be fixed. I’m not asking about hijacking the protest and making it about politics. I’m asking that we, as citizens of this country, go all out and fight for all our problems. Let the government face how incompetent they’ve been.

If the education minister resigns today, what are the chances that the next one’s going to be honest if it’s the same party? The problem isn’t him but the entire system!! Let’s just stop holding back and get everything fixed. We've got nothing to lose now.

The only solution I see is the current government being brought down. I don’t mean in the Nepal kind of way. I don’t support any party, not even CJP — I’m only here for my country. I know we need a party but right now there’s no option available. Any opposition is better than the current majority. Maybe seeing the citizens like this, they’ll strive to work better. I just wanted to share this because I feel since we’ve gone all out, let’s voice out all our problems.

I'll be posting this various subs cause more people need to see this

Jai Hind
Vande Mataram
Bharat Mata ki Jai


r/india 7h ago

Politics India's 'cockroach' protests explained and what happens next | BBC News

Thumbnail
youtu.be
55 Upvotes

r/india 7h ago

People We as men have failed women.

112 Upvotes

I'm a 26-year-old man, and I genuinely feel that we, as men, have failed women.

I've been using Reddit for almost eight years, and my experience has been overwhelmingly positive. My inbox has mostly consisted of genuine discussions, people asking questions, or continuing conversations about things I've posted. I can barely remember receiving any random or creepy messages. A few days ago, I introduced my girlfriend to Reddit because I genuinely believed she'd enjoy the communities here. Reddit has some incredible communities where people help each other, share knowledge, and have meaningful discussions, and I wanted her to experience that side of the platform too.

She wanted to do something simple and kind. She made a post asking where she could donate some old clothes to an NGO. Someone replied saying they could help and that they knew where the clothes could be donated. It sounded completely genuine.

But when she followed up, he sent her such a vulgar and sexually explicit message that I can't even bring myself to repeat it here.

She was simply trying to do something kind. A normal conversation about donating clothes to charity was turned into something vile for absolutely no reason. She blocked him immediately.

When she showed me the message, I was genuinely disgusted. I couldn't believe someone could take such a simple act of kindness and twist it into something so vile.

But what stayed with me even more was what she said afterwards.

She said something along the lines of, "I'm more surprised by how normal this is for us. We've almost accepted that this is just what happens."

That sentence has been stuck in my head ever since.

The most shocking part wasn't the message itself. It was that she wasn't shocked. She was disgusted, frustrated, and disappointed, but not surprised. No one should ever become so used to harassment that it stops being surprising.

I've always known this exists. Every time I open Instagram and see a Reel featuring a woman, I scroll through the comments and see men objectifying her, making disgusting remarks about her body, or reducing her to something sexual. It doesn't matter whether she's talking about fitness, education, travel, comedy, or simply sharing a moment from her life. Time and time again, I see the same kind of comments. I've always found them revolting.

My girlfriend has told me about the messages she receives and the things women deal with online, and I've always believed her. What happened on Reddit wasn't an eye-opener. It was a reminder of just how deeply rooted and relentless this behaviour has become.

The more I thought about it, the more I realized how differently we experience the same world.

If I want to step outside at 11 PM to grab something from a nearby store, I just go. I don't stop to ask myself if it's safe. I don't wonder if someone will follow me. I don't think about whether I'm wearing the "right" clothes. I don't have to justify why I'm going somewhere.

For her, one of the first questions is often, "Is it safe?" Sometimes it's, "Will I be allowed to go?" Sometimes it's wondering how she'll get back home, whether it's too late, or whether she should just stay home instead.

Those thoughts rarely even cross my mind.

The same difference exists online.

When I make a Reddit post, I expect people to answer my question.

She has to wonder whether someone is going to turn a completely normal conversation into something disgusting.

The Reddit incident wasn't unique. It was just another example of the same mindset that shows up in Instagram comments, unsolicited DMs, and countless stories women share every single day. The platform changes, but the behaviour doesn't.

This is why I say we as men have failed women.

Not because every single man behaves like this.

But because this behaviour has become common enough that women expect it. They expect creepy DMs. They expect strangers to cross boundaries. They expect disgusting comments. They expect to think twice before going somewhere alone.

The part that disturbed me the most wasn't reading that message. It was realizing that the woman I love saw it as just another day on the internet. That should never be normal. No one should have to accept harassment as the cost of participating in online communities or simply existing in public.

If you're a man reading this and you've never behaved this way, then this isn't an attack on you. It's a reminder that our experience isn't universal. Just because we don't experience something ourselves doesn't mean it isn't happening every single day to the women around us.

And to every woman reading this, I'm sorry.

I'm sorry that so many of you have had to grow up believing this is normal. I'm sorry that a simple act of kindness can turn into harassment. I'm sorry that you have to think twice before replying to a message, walking home at night, or simply existing online. Most of all, I'm sorry that so many of you have reached a point where you're no longer surprised when it happens.

You deserved better.

You still do.


r/india 2h ago

Politics Why You Should Not Vote for BJP (Part 1): Education

22 Upvotes

India saw rapid change in the 21st century, which I will always be grateful to, for it gave me this lifestyle, and the audacity to write this post. It won't be wrong to say that for a large part of history we as Indians lived with the mindset that as long as the society functions smoothly, stably we will grow. This idea of dharma or social duty is the very atom of our civilization, and it prioritizes such stability and order over individual rebellion. For millennia, our society relied on self-regulating mechanisms that isolated daily life from the chaotic rise and fall of political dynasties, making large-scale anti-systematic revolts rare until the disruptions of British colonial rule. But then things settled after independence and while countless problems arose, my country thrived.

Growing up I learnt how important education and scientific temperament is. That was perhaps the sole vision or philosophy that I thought India was driven by. But then what is this "scientific temper"? Jawaharlal Nehru famously coined it in the Indian context in his famous book "The Discovery of India" in 1946. I will be honest, I could not care less about that book, even though when I was young, I would see it in bookshelves of professors and teachers who I would often idolize. But today that book is like a torch towards an ideology that doesn't exist in India, and I regret not picking it up on time. What Nehru wanted was that the young Indian develop the attitude that involves logical reasoning, refusing to accept claims without evidence and the willingness to discard preconceived notions in the face of new facts. His era saw tremendous push in reallocating civilizational reverence from traditional religious shrines to technological and scientific projects. Under his leadership, national funding for scientific research expanded exponentially, growing from ₹24 million in 1947 to ₹550 million by 1964 [1]. He went on to establish the IIT network and deliberately sourced distinct institutional structures and faculty support from the United States (IIT Kanpur), the Soviet Union (IIT Bombay), and West Germany (IIT Madras) to expose Indian students to varied global scientific methodologies [2]. He also realised that this might not be enough as education typically does not trickle down from specific metropolitan areas to every state. So he promoted the Regional Engineering College network, now pridefully called the NITs [2]. He then went on to establish the Council of Scientific and Industrial Research (CSIR) where he served as the ex-officio President and started rapidly setting up a chain of National Laboratories across the country dedicated to optics, metallurgy, chemicals and food technology. He was not satisfied with this though, in 1945 with Dr. Homi J. Bhabha he established the Tata Institute of Fundamental Research in Mumbai, that still functions as India's best fundamental science research institute. Then in 1948 again with Dr. Bhabha he established the Atomic Energy Commission (later turned into DAE) and in 1954 the Atomic Energy Establishment in Trombay (later evolved into BARC). Finally in 1962 with Dr. Vikram Sarabhai he established the Indian national Committee for Space Research (INCOSPAR) which later evolved into ISRO [3]. He was perhaps the only Prime Minister who actively pushed for international scientific conferences to be organized and hosted by India. This led to India becoming the host of 1963 International Cosmic Ray Conference, which Nehru attended in person [4]. He was deeply enthusiastic of research and the scientific process, to the extent that to bridge the gap between state authority and the scientific community, Nehru made it a point to personally attend and address the Indian Science Congress every single year during his tenure. He used this national platform to speak directly to researchers, reminding them that their ultimate duty was not just to produce academic papers, but to use the spirit of skepticism and experimentation to help emancipate the ordinary Indian citizen from social stagnation [5].

Honestly the more I write this paragraph the happier I feel realizing how powerful Nehru's philosophy was, which he tried to impact to the masses. And to some degree he succeeded as soon after India saw the Kolar Gold Fields Neutrino Experiment in 1965 detecting the first atmospheric neutrinos where the group in TIFR beat a similar South African experiment by just a few weeks, placing India at the forefront of global experimental particle physics [6]. During this time India saw the breakthrough in electronic digital computing where the TIFRAC was created in TIFR in the 1956-1960 period. We also saw the Narasimhan-Seshadri Theorem in 1965 which later became the foundational cornerstone for modern theoretical physics, specifically in String Theory and quantum field theory [7]. Dr. Govind Swarup walking on the footsteps of Dr. Bhabha under the Nehruvian philosophy, constructed the massive Ooty Radio Telescope in 1970 and later the Giant Metrewave Radio Telescope (GMRT) near Pune. GMRT remains one of the largest and most powerful low-frequency radio telescope arrays in the world. It has allowed global astrophysicists to discover the farthest radio galaxies and map the evolution of the early universe. When in the 1960s we saw the Green Revolution, led by Dr. M.S. Swaminathan at the Indian Agricultural Research Institute (IARI). This scientific intervention fundamentally broke India’s structural reliance on food aid, transforming a famine-prone country into a food-surplus nation [8]. We also saw the designing of Asia's first nuclear reactor in Trombay called the Apsara in 1956, which was later scaled up to Cirus (1960) and Zerlina (1961) [9]. In 1964, BARC designed and built a highly sophisticated facility to reprocess spent fuel and extract weapons-grade plutonium. This facility was built without any foreign assistance, making India one of the few nations capable of fuel reprocessing, a capability that directly paved the way for the Smiling Buddha peaceful nuclear test in 1974 [10]. If we look at space program of India, on November 21, 1963, India launched its very first sounding rocket, a US-made Nike-Apache from the Thumba Equatorial Rocket Launching Station (TERLS) in a tiny fishing village in Kerala, after which Indian space scientists designed and launched the Rohini-75 (RH-75) in 1967 [11].

While India did drastically change entering the 21st century, one thing still remained dominant, and that was Nehru's philosophy of scientific temperament. Politicians came and went by, but nobody ever disagreed with that philosophy or tried to disrupt its propagation to the newer generation. A consequence of this was the creation of the Indian Institutes of Science Education and Research (IISERs) and the National Institutes of Science Education and Research NISER in 2006 by UPA-I [12]. Another consequence of this was the fact that to build a scientific temperament at the school level, the government revived the Central Advisory Board of Education (CABE) and tasked the National Council of Educational Research and Training (NCERT) with rewriting school curricula in 2005. This was called the National Curriculum Framework (NCF) which became a watershed moment in Indian schooling as it explicitly moved away from learning by rote. Instead, it introduced child-centric pedagogy that encouraged inquiry, skepticism, questioning of dogmas, and connection of school knowledge to life outside the classroom. Textbooks were re-designed to make students actively question phenomena, which is the baseline of scientific thought [13, 14]. In 2004, the government introduced a 2% education cess on all central taxes. This dedicated pool of funding directly bankrolled the Sarva Shiksha Abhiyan (SSA) and institutionalized the National Mid-Day Meal Scheme, which drastically brought down school dropout rates. This period also saw the launch of the Innovation in Science Pursuit for Inspired Research (INSPIRE) scheme targeted youth aged 10–32 by the Department of Science and Technology (DST) in 2008. It provided cash awards for school science projects, undergraduate scholarships, and doctoral fellowships, making pure science a viable, well-funded career path. Then the Kishore Vaigyanik Protsahan Yojana (KVPY) received substantially enhanced funding and promotion to identify and nurture students with a talent for research early on. And finally in 2009 the Right to Education Act was passed that make education a fundamental right for children aged 6-14 [15].

I grew up in an India which was striving to be educated, unaware of what it was trying to grow out of. While such naivety is still strong in the young and the elderly population of India today, there is a fundamental difference in it now. Previously I was unaware because the society back then had started to realize that the knowledge of what India was trying to run away from was not important anymore, as it had run far ahead and the next generation did not need to carry that burden. Then on May 26, 2014, Narendra Modi became the Prime Minister of India. I would occasionally see my mother panic, and my father celebrate, but the reasons were never clear. I lived my life blissfully unaware of the existence of the other philosophy, the one which demands fundamentalism in the name of "National Character". While Nehru believed India's primary challenge was material and social backwardness, which could be solved by looking forward through the lens of modern science, a different school of thought also existed in that era. This school of thought believed that India's primary challenge was moral degradation and internal fragmentation caused by centuries of foreign rule, which could only be solved by looking inward and reviving civilizational pride.

The premise of this other philosophy stemmed from Vinayak Damodar Savarkar and his contemporaries and it is important to understand it before we realize how we ended up in the situation we are in 2026. In 1923 Savarkar published in book "Hindutva: Who Is a Hindu?" where he declared his own definition of cultural nationalism. This book influenced Dr. K.B. Hedgewar to establish the RSS in 1925 to turn Savarkar's theory into a disciplined, grassroot organization. Later, the organization's second chief, M.S. Golwalkar further systematized and codified the philosophy into an institutional blueprint through his books, We or Our Nationhood Defined (1939) and Bunch of Thoughts (1960). Savarkar drew a line and defined a "Hindu" as someone who considers India to be both their motherland (Matribhoomi) and their holy land (Punyabhoomi) while Golwalkar praised the extreme, ethno-nationalist models of 1930s Europe (specifically Nazi Germany's treatment of minorities) as a textbook example of "race pride" that India could learn from. Their philosophy further stated that a nation is an organic, ancient cultural entity (Rashtra), rather than a political entity created by a legal document like a constitution [16, 17, 18]. Because Hedgewar and Golwalkar believed that political power was meaningless without internal social reform and character building (Vyakti Nirman), the RSS as an organization officially refrained from participating in major anti-British mass movements, like the Quit India Movement of 1942. In that regard, the British government archives and political historians note that the RSS, under the leadership of M.S. Golwalkar, officially stayed aloof from the Congress-led struggle, adopting a stance of extreme caution to avoid colonial retaliation [19]. Savarkar was not completely on board with that stance and himself mocked the RSS's slow, "purely cultural" orientation, famously remarking that an RSS volunteer’s life could be summarized as: "He was born, he joined the RSS, and he died without accomplishing anything" [20].

In 2008, after his second assembly election win in 2007, Narendra Modi wrote a book titled Jyotipunj in which he described the story of sixteen members of RSS who inspired him. Among them was Golwalkar as the "Pujniya Shri Guruji" (meaning teacher worthy of worship). From a translation of his text, Modi writes about Golwalkar, "We think of him as many things—a leader, a scientist—and we wonder if he was ever spiritual" [21]. I am pointing to this specific quote because I want to prepare you for the modus operandi that followed after 2014 regarding scientific temperament in India.

It took time for me to notice the change, I will be honest, I was not looking, and I think many of you didn't either. The second tenure of BJP brought them 303 seats and with the NDA having 352 seats bringing them painfully close to the 2/3 majority in parliament. Then in 2022 KVPY Fellowship was scrapped and the official argument was that it cost the state more money to conduct the exam than the actual monetary value of 250 to 300 fellowships awarded annually, so they decided to merge it with the broader INSPIRE-SHE scholarship. KVPY used to be a specialized aptitude test, which was a standalone, high-difficulty exam designed by IISc to test research potential, critical thinking, and non-rote problem solving. It was open to students from Class 11 (Stream SA), Class 12 (Stream SX), and 1st Year UG (Stream SB) and historically included an interview by top scientists to gauge research temperament for admission in IISc, IISERs, NISER, UM-DAE CEBS, IIIT Hyderabad and IACS. Needless to say, it gauged out the best candidates from a pool of brilliant young minds for a very bright future in science. When it was merged with INSPIRE-SHE the selection was based on either top 1% of class 12 board exams, or on top 10,000 Rank in JEE Main/Advanced or NEET. It is open to students in the age range of 17-22 years who have already completed Class 12 and are entering/pursuing undergraduate studies. There is no interview involved. To understand the issue here one needs to ask, is the fellowship reaching its target population as before? KVPY questions were unique; they required identifying patterns and deriving formulas, not just applying them. When one switches to board marks, the system now rewards rote memorization and high-scoring diligence rather than scientific creativity. A student with 99% in Boards is diligent, but not necessarily a good researcher. Thus, the abolishment of the KVPY exam did not merely dissolve a financial fellowship; it choked an elite, alternative pipeline for higher education admissions. Closing it forced all pure science aspirants back into the very same cookie-cutter engineering and medical filter systems. In this regard, Prof. Dipshikha Chakravortty from the Department of Microbiology at IISc, said, “The students who clear the test and the interviews and are admitted to IISc and other institutes make their mark and I have not seen such kind of students from any other exams” [22]. The government further argued that the INSPIRE-SHE (as was the previous INSPIRE scholarship) will be offered to order of 1000 students but then the Department of Science and Technology (DST) did not release fresh registration notifications for the 2025 and 2026 entry cycles [23].

The BJP government systematically phased out the NCF 2005. During the 2022–2024 NCERT "rationalization" drives, the government introduced sweeping textbook revisions. Notably, chapters on the Periodic Table, Evolution (Darwin's theory), and environmental sustainability were drastically trimmed or completely dropped from the Class 9 and 10 science curricula. In history and social science books, significant sections covering the Mughal era, Mahatma Gandhi's assassination, and the 2002 Gujarat riots were omitted [24,25]. Additionally in 2018, the original, standalone structural identity of the SSA was quietly retired. The BJP government argued that merging the SSA along with Rashtriya Madhyamik Shiksha Abhiyan (RMSA) and Teacher Education into a unified scheme called Samagra Shiksha would streamline effort, however, this diluted the legally protected primary focus of the original SSA budget. The lack of transparency soon evolved into serious accusations of political coercion via fund withholding and direct embezzlement of public money where in 2025-2026 major opposition-ruled states like Tamil Nadu, West Bengal, Kerala, Punjab, and Delhi reported receiving zero funds under Samagra Shiksha for extended periods [26]. Then in mid-2025, a massive fraud was exposed where nearly ₹4.6 to ₹5 crore was siphoned directly from the Goa Samagra Shiksha Abhiyan bank accounts [27]. After that, in 2026, in a shocking case in Bahraich, UP, over 15,000 brand-new Hindi textbooks meant for free distribution to poor children under Samagra Shiksha were intercepted while being sold as scrap paper (raddhi) for just ₹4 per kg [28]. Investigations (notably in UP) also flagged instances where Samagra Shiksha funds were diverted into the bank accounts of deceased pensioners or unrelated private individuals, with audit reports showing crores of rupees misappropriated through reopened closed accounts [27]. A recent CAG report highlighted that nearly 50% of Samagra Shiksha funds lay unspent/idle while schools faced massive shortages of books and uniforms. The audit pointed to a complete disconnect between the funds "released" on paper and the actual assets on the ground [29]. Earlier if you understood the modus operandi of those that rule over India from 2014 onwards, this should not come as a surprise. In January 2019, the BJP government passed an amendment that fundamentally diluted the UPA's core RTE framework by scrapping the No-Detention Policy. States were given the power to hold regular examinations in Class 5 and Class 8 and fail students, a move that went directly against the original, inclusive philosophy of the 2009 Act that wanted to prevent high dropouts [30].

The situation is not much better in higher education either. In December 2022, the Ministry of Minority Affairs officially discontinued the MANF scheme a UPA era initiative. The government defended the move by claiming it overlapped with other research fellowships (like UGC-NET). However, higher education watchdogs observed that this move deeply damaged the ability of researchers from marginalised, minority backgrounds to pursue advanced research in science and humanities [31]. Then under the New Education Policy 2020 the Four-Year Undergraduate Programme (FYUGP) was introduced around 2023. This allowed students to exit after Year 1 with a certificate, Year 2 with a diploma, or Year 3 with a basic degree. Soon higher student dropout rates were seen compared to the older Choice-Based Credit System (CBCS) as many socio-economically marginalized students utilize the early "exit routes" to leave higher education prematurely [32].

The government has systematically tightened the financial independence of public universities, driving them toward commercialization. One such step was when they replaced direct budgetary infrastructure grants to central universities with the Higher Education Funding Agency (HEFA) in 2017. Instead of receiving government money to build laboratories or libraries, universities must now take out loans from HEFA. To repay these commercial loans, public universities have been forced to hike student tuition and hostel fees, pricing out poorer students [33,34,35]. Perhaps the scariest blow that BJP is planning to throw at education would come through the Viksit Bharat Shiksha Adhishthan or VBSA bill. NEP recommended dissolving the UGC and AICTE to set up a single, unified "super-regulator". In December 15, 2025, Union Education Minister Dharmendra Pradhan introduced the VBSA Bill, for that purpose. It immediately got enormous pushback notably from IITs, leading to formation of a 31-member Joint Parliamentary Committee (JPC), chaired by BJP MP Daggubati Purandeswar to thoroughly audit the bill and consult academic stakeholders. The government prepares to table and pass the VBSA Bill during the high-profile Monsoon Session of Parliament [36]. The bill suffers from the same issue that many other bills from BJP cabinet suffers. It lacks nuances and this time IITs and IIMs had to point it out. Their argument is that the bill tries to group everything under one regulation, which means institutional statutory autonomy will be affected. Additionally, the VBSA Bill requires institutions to seek centralized regulatory approvals to launch online programs or open new cell extensions. IIT Madras specifically argued that requiring an external commission's approval for tech-driven innovations would severely slow down their agile operational model. Under the current draft, the VBSA can formulate new rules and standards and apply them to all technical institutions across India without a statutory mandate to consult the individual boards of the IITs [37].

A lot has been said on the erosion of education in India under the philosophy of RSS and BJP so far and yet I have not talked about the elephant in the room, the National Testing Agency (NTA). So, let's finally put all our focus into that. We should first understand that from a constitutional and administrative standpoint, the NTA is not a statutory body created by an Act of Parliament (like the UPSC), nor is it a constitutional body (like the Election Commission). It was registered in 2017 as a Society under the Societies Registration Act, 1860, the exact same legal framework used to register non-governmental organizations (NGOs), residential welfare associations (RWAs), and charitable trusts [38]. The NTA exercises immense sovereign power deciding the academic destiny of nearly 10 million students every year through exams like NEET, JEE, and CUET. Yet, because it is structurally just a "Society," it operates without the stringent legislative oversight that governs true public institutions. As a registered society, the NTA’s internal bylaws and executive decisions are insulated from direct, day-to-day parliamentary scrutiny. It answers to a Governing Body dominated by bureaucrats rather than to the elected representatives of the people. Given that NTA was envisioned as a "self-sustained, premier testing organization," its financial model mimics a corporate NGO. This financial model drives the NTA to act like a mass-volume corporation. To cut costs and maximize efficiency, it outsources its core public duty, the physical conduct of exams, invigilation, and computer server management, to private vendors (like TCS iON) and sub-contracted private schools. Most scams (like the 2021 JEE remote-hacking or the NEET leaks) occurred precisely at these outsourced, third-party centers where the NTA had zero direct administrative control. If a paper leaks under the UPSC, it becomes a constitutional crisis, and the President of India can intervene. If an issue occurs within the NTA, its "NGO-like" structure allows it to investigate itself which should sound absurd to anyone and ring alarms of internal scam.

But then in 2024 the NEET UG paper got leaked. Then in leaked again in 2026. In both years, highly accurate "guess papers" circulated on Telegram and WhatsApp hours before the exam. Investigations revealed these were actual leaked questions. In 2026, leaks were traced to the Oasis School in Hazaribagh, where the paper was illegally accessed [39]. Then in 2026, a massive digital leak forced the cancellation of the entire NEET UG exam after it was found that 100+ questions matched a pre-circulated PDF [40]. NTA had the audacity to repeatedly denied leaks initially, calling them "rumors" or "isolated incidents" until police evidence (burnt papers/digital footprints) made denial impossible [41]. This however wasn't the only exam leaked or suffered from other issues under NTA. In 2021 JEE Main, at specific compromised centers, security software was bypassed, allowing a remote "solver" to take control of the candidate's computer via LAN and answer questions in real-time. The CBI arrested NTA insiders and private center owners, proving the digital fortress was porous [42,43]. There were also issues with "Solver Gang" and impersonation rackets, where they operated successfully despite biometric checks and frisking (notably in NEET 2021 and 2024), leading to allegations that NTA officials at centers were bribed to bypass identity verification [43]. Then in June 2024 the UGC-NET "Darknet" leak happened. The Ministry of Education cancelled the exam one day after it was held because the paper had been leaked and sold on the dark web/Telegram for ₹5,000–₹10,000 [44]. This shattered the perception that only "pen-and-paper" exams leak; even the credibility of the NTA’s flagship eligibility test for professors was destroyed.

If I leave aside exam leaks, NTA's exams often suffer from catastrophic management failures. One such example is the "grace marks" fiasco in NEET UG 2024 where NTA arbitrarily awarded "grace marks" (up to 70-80 marks) to 1,563 students to compensate for "loss of time". The formula was opaque and borrowed from a CLAT (Law) judgment, which was mathematically inapplicable to a medical entrance. This artificially inflated ranks, causing 67 students to get a perfect 720/720 score, which statistical can be argued as impossible [45]. Then there are the server meltdown and glitch that happened in CUET-UG 2022 where thousands of students reached centers only to be told the "server is down" or the "wrong paper was uploaded". This led to cancellation of exam in some centers [46]. Then again in May 2026, biometric verification servers failed, locking thousands of students out of the exam hall, leading to panic and police intervention [47]. There are also some systemic criticisms that NTA faces. In multi-shift exams (JEE Main), NTA uses a "percentile" system to normalize scores across difficult and easy shifts. Students in "easy shifts" are brutally penalized. A student scoring 200/300 in an easy shift might get a lower percentile than a student scoring 150/300 in a hard shift. The NTA is also notorious for opaque operations. It rarely reveals the raw data of how many students appeared in each shift (crucial for verifying normalization). It has frequently fought against revealing "question paper setting" protocols under the RTI Act, claiming "intellectual property" [48].

All of this should make you ask, is there something internally rotten within NTA? Well CBI gave the answer 6 days ago where they alleged that an NTA insider on the official paper-setting panel (identified as P.V. Kulkarnney) directly leaked highly confidential chemistry questions before the exam. Investigators traced a financial transaction where the owner of a Latur-based coaching center chain (Shivraj Raghunath Mote) paid a bribe of ₹5 lakh to the NTA paper setter to illegally procure the questions. Digital forensic analysis of seized mobile devices revealed a mirror image containing 111 leaked questions matching the NTA's master paper set, which were then compiled into handwritten notes and sold. [49,50]. I should point out that perhaps the coaching mafia and the enormous crime network that exists to profit from paper leaks, always existed but it was the NTA's opaqueness, corporatization and its incompetence that led to them growing so blatantly in this country.

Now look back and ask yourself who is to be blamed for this? One thing is certain that NTA in its current form cannot exist. But NTA is only a small marble in the monument of accountability. Exactly who created NTA and whose responsibility was it to stop NTA from becoming what it is today? Zoom out a little and you will see the education minister Dharmendra Pradhan but if you zoom out a bit more you will realize that you are struggling to get educated under a regime that never understood the true meaning of education, that never had an ounce of scientific temperament and will never make it their priority. So, the truest accountability is to remove them from power, not just because of anti-incumbency, but because a large majority of India who voted against that ideology still believes in scientific temperament, in the philosophy of progress. A large majority of India still wants to be civic, and evolve into a civilization of the future, rather than living in the shams of a glorified past. The question is, will that India be vocal?


Feel free to copy/share/post/re-post this wherever you want.


[1] https://www.academia.edu/105372525/Jawaharlal_Nehrus_Attitude_towards_Science_and_Technology

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Science_and_technology_in_India

[3] https://www.jlls.org/index.php/jlls/article/viewFile/5297/1857

[4] https://nehruarchive.in/documents/in-jaipur-cosmic-rays-conference-14-december-1963-kyex2

[5] https://theprint.in/feature/around-town/nehru-saw-scientific-temper-as-inextricably-linked-to-freedom/2459598/

[6] https://www.tifr.res.in/maincampus/full_sci_news.php?id=ajhGeFRTK0x3S2FjbzVZUGNUenI3QT09

[7] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tata_Institute_of_Fundamental_Research

[8] https://frontline.thehindu.com/science-and-technology/india-at-75-timeline-science-and-technology-75-years-of-independence/article65731123.ece

[9] https://www.barc.gov.in/publications/apsara.pdf

[10] https://www.barc.gov.in/randd/rwm.html

[11] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rohini_(rocket_family)

[12] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Indian_Institute_of_Science_Education_and_Research,_Kolkata

[13] https://frontline.thehindu.com/the-nation/education/article30211241.ece

[14] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Curriculum_Framework_2005

[15] https://archivepmo.nic.in/drmanmohansingh/ebook/2004-2014/ebook-2004-2014.pdf

[16] https://www.britannica.com/topic/Rashtriya-Swayamsevak-Sangh

[17] https://caravanmagazine.in/history/rss-golwalkar-links-nazism

[18] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rashtriya_Swayamsevak_Sangh

[19] https://www.epw.in/engage/article/early-history-rss-reading-list

[20] https://aeon.co/essays/how-savarkar-invented-hindu-supremacy-and-its-cult-of-violence

[21] https://caravanmagazine.in/vantage/modi-golwalkar-part-1

[22] https://science.thewire.in/education/kvpy-scheme-fellows-react/

[23] https://m.thewire.in/article/education/inspire-she-scholarship-for-the-brightest-science-students-will-not-be-renewed-this-year

[24] https://thefederal.com/news/ncert-drops-democracy-periodic-table-energy-sources-from-class-10-textbooks

[25] https://www.thehindu.com/education/ncert-drops-chapters-on-periodic-table-democracy-political-parties-from-class-10-syllabus/article66919444.ece

[26] https://www.thehindu.com/news/national/kerala-tamil-nadu-west-bengal-have-received-no-funds-under-samagra-shiksha-for-fy2024-25/article69409044.ece

[27] https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/goa/samagra-shiksha-fraud-accused-had-13-bank-accounts-68-complaints-nationwide/articleshow/121700451.cms

[28] https://www.ndtv.com/education/over-13-000-school-textbooks-meant-for-2026-27-session-sold-as-scrap-in-uttar-pradesh-11124690

[29] https://cag.gov.in/ag1/odisha/en/audit-report/details/123477

[30] https://www.drishtiias.com/daily-updates/daily-news-analysis/centre-scrapped-no-detention-policy

[31] https://www.deccanherald.com/india/govt-discontinued-maulana-azad-fellowship-as-it-overlaps-other-schemes-1187342.html

[32] https://ijirt.org/publishedpaper/IJIRT203856_PAPER.pdf

[33] https://www.newsclick.in/modi-government-years-marked-attacks-higher-education

[34] https://indianexpress.com/article/business/budget/union-budget-2018-arun-jaitley-education-loans-to-replace-infra-grants-to-iits-and-iims-5048413/

[35] https://theprint.in/india/du-doubles-components-of-annual-charges-second-time-in-a-year-following-hefa-loans/1873135/

[36] https://www.thehindu.com/news/national/vbsa-bill-a-solution-to-current-challenges-catalyst-for-growth-ugc-tells-joint-panel-of-parliament/article70736311.ece

[37] https://www.thehindu.com/education/iits-iims-push-back-against-vbsa-norms/article71207083.ece

[38] https://sabrangindia.in/nta-ki-chronology-samjhiye-then-attempt-to-answer-my-three-non-mcq-questions/

[39] https://medicaldialogues.in/news/education/was-the-nta-website-hacked-officials-refute-claims-130753

[40] https://www.shiksha.com/news/medicine-health-sciences-neet-2026-paper-leak-rajasthan-sog-finds-100-matching-questions-nta-issues-clarification-blogId-229641

[41] https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/delhi/neet-ug-2026-nta-calls-paper-leak-claims-false-fraudulent-warns-of-action/articleshow/131553738.cms

[42] https://theprint.in/india/this-is-how-jee-mains-was-manipulated-solvers-hacked-into-computers-to-write-papers/731636/

[43] https://www.inventiva.co.in/stories/nta-a-system-built-on-scams/

[44] https://www.newsclick.in/everything-went-wrong-ugc-net-2024-anybody-even-answerable

[45] https://www.ndtv.com/india-news/neet-row-supreme-court-neet-ug-retest-why-so-many-neet-ug-toppers-exam-bodys-reply-to-big-question-in-supreme-court-6079899

[46] https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/education/news/cuet-phase-4-exam-2022-cancelled-at-few-centers-due-to-technical-glitches-read-more-here/articleshow/93620660.cms

[47] https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/education/news/cuet-ug-2026-glitch-over-3700-students-who-left-exam-centres-to-get-another-chance-says-nta/articleshow/131411768.cms

[48] https://forumias.com/blog/national-testing-agency-functioning-challenges-explained-pointwise/

[49] https://www.wionews.com/india-news/rs-5-lakh-for-neet-questions-cbi-uncovers-conspiracy-behind-paper-leak-1784186292410

[50] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Whns-3QQFqI


r/india 8h ago

Politics Don’t go to Jantar Mantar…

Thumbnail
hindustantimes.com
0 Upvotes

r/india 20h ago

Politics Pradhan Resigns Tomorrow... Nothing Changes? My Take as a Student Stuck in the Middle of CJP Protests

0 Upvotes

Hey guys, fellow student here who's been grinding through the same broken system. I've been watching the CJP protests and honestly I'm kinda on both sides.

Big respect to the actual students out there. The frustration over paper leaks, coaching scams, suicides, and zero accountability is completely valid. A lot of us are struggling hard with this education mess and uncertain futures. That part hits deep.

But mistakes happened on both sides too.Some of the protest stuff turned messy with the march and police crackdown. Violence doesn't help anyone and just distracts from the real issues. At the same time, the government ignoring the systemic failures isn't right either.

And this one thought keeps coming up: imagine Pradhan resigns tomorrow. Headlines explode, everyone celebrates "victory"... then what? The same leaks, same opacity, same deep problems stay. One guy gone doesn't fix the fundamentals. We need actual reforms – better exam security, real punishment for the mafias, more opportunities. Not just political theater.

As a student, I want real change that actually helps us, not temporary wins.What do you think? Especially other students – how do we push for stuff that lasts? Let's keep it civil.

TL;DR: Support the cause but question the methods and end goals. Tired of this cycle.