r/horsecommunity • u/MarinaCh23 • 8h ago
two long riding tours in Iceland
Kjolur with Eldhestar (big well established company) vs
Arctic North with Islandshestar (operated by families of Icelandic local farmers ) (both riding tours are 6 riding days, advanced riders only).
Below is my personal review (and some riders might actually like what I did not and the other way around ..)
1. Horses - health, tack, training, gates, gate transitions, tolt or flying walk gates are much better with Islandshestar. Their horses are just probably the best you can get for 6 day long riding tour in Iceland ( the owner has two flying gate Icelandic champions ). Eldhestar has some really good horses but company leases a big number of horses of farmers so horses are of very different quality. Also Eldhestar is using sinches which rub skin on sensitive horses and vaseline was frequently used to cover wounds. Also Eldhestar split rain coat and snack between so called riding bodies so you are not allowed to have your own snack and rain coat on your horse (or you have 2 rain coats behind the saddle or you have two snacks in your saddle bag ,, that results into very inconvenient situation when your riding boddie is up front and you are at the back …,)
2. Islandshestar makes it up to advanced riders with speed that is fast (everyday uphill gallop, almost no walk and tons of tolt ) ,In contrary Eldhestar riding group had beginners with zero experience of canter but they could learn on the way and were always given appropriate horses. Mostly walk, some tolt and canter only on the very last day and only for riders who wanted to try it for 5 minutes (so advanced riders requirement is very soft here….)
3. Guides are way more professional with Eldhestar and the tour description does describe the actual riding tour (like 99 %), Guides of Eldhestar are very knowledgeable and will enjoy learning about history, biodiversity and geology of Iceland, long informative debriefings every morning with a lot of stories during breaks. For Islandshestar the description of the tour Is more like a sketch of options (I am not even sure that 50% of the description was actually followed I think the owner played by ear everyday and because he does not speak English it was absolutely unclear what the day plan is …like everyday is a surprise …).
4. Both Eldhestar and Islandshestar provide really good quality food and accommodations are exactly the way they are described. For Arcric North it was too much time on the bus: everyday on the bus in the mornings for an hour to get to horses and on the bus at the evenings to get back to the farm house. Also the owner wants to control his horses and he keeps lunch snacks on the bus so lot of riding are along the roads which are not busy roads but I would not call it wilderness.
5. Free herd riding experience is way much better with Eldhestar. This was true learning to be front or back rider. We were allowed to help to herd free running horses and took amazing videos of riding with free running horses in true Icelandic wilderness. Free herd experience with Islandshestar was next to nothing, very limited basically these were only guides to control free running herd and back riders were almost always slowed down and cut off the free running horses with very limited time even to take pictures or videos ..
As one can see my experience was very different and my advice go with Islandshestar is you value speed and good tolting horses above true tour description and free running herd experience and go with Eldhestarr if you want to learn riding with free running horses, want professional guides and ok with long time walks instead of canter.