r/fantasywriters 13h ago

Discussion About A General Writing Topic What do I do next?

Post image
20 Upvotes

Got a flip phone 2 years ago, got laid off one year ago, spiraled, and wrote a book. After 3 rounds of edits and feedback from 7 test readers, I just got this feedback.

I genuinely don’t know what to do next, besides cold-reach out to literary agents. I haven’t been on Instagram/TikTok/etc. for two years because stepping away gave me the headspace for my creative projects, and I don’t want the pressure of trying to build an author platform. I did use AI when writing at first, because it started as my DND character backstory so it wasn’t going to be anything professional, and don’t know if that would blacklist me from anything, or turn off literary agents. It has gone through heavy editing and changes since then.

I’m almost leaning toward just putting it online for free, to keep this hobby low pressure/fun, but I have no idea how to get it in front of people who might actually enjoy it. I’d love any advice. Thanks friends!


r/fantasywriters 3h ago

Discussion About A General Writing Topic What's one fantasy trope that you'll never get tired of, no matter how often it's used?

17 Upvotes

I've noticed that discussions about fantasy tropes usually focus on the ones people dislike, but I'm curious about the opposite. There are some ideas that appear in countless books, games, and movies, yet they still manage to work when they're handled well. Personally, I don't think a trope becomes bad simply because it's common. For me, the execution is usually much more important than the idea itself. A familiar concept can still feel fresh if the characters, worldbuilding, or conflict are compelling. I'm interested in hearing different perspectives because everyone seems to have at least one trope they genuinely enjoy despite seeing it over and over again. What's one fantasy trope you'll never get tired of, and what makes it work for you?


r/fantasywriters 14h ago

Discussion About A General Writing Topic What pulls you in?

13 Upvotes

Hey guys I have been writing a story for the past 5 ish years 3 of those years was just for fun but I’ve gotten pretty serious about it lately. Even creating a d&d campaign based off the world and magic. Without going too deep on my story I was curious on what hooks a series in. I’ve written several versions on how to start but I’m not sure what to go with. I was curious when you pull up a new series what hooks you in? Like an immediate action scene? Story starts with history or what kind of magic you see? The antagonist?
For example I love it when a series starts with no dialogue or monologue. Just a characters actions showing who they are before a a word is uttered.


r/fantasywriters 8h ago

Writing Prompt I don't know what to do with this

8 Upvotes

This story idea randomly popped in my head around a year ago and it won't leave me alone. I'm not a writer so I don't know what to do with this. I feel like I need to get it out there somehow, so I made this account specifically for it.

Things in parentheses are because I can't figure out what word to use. Also punctuation will probably be weird.

The problem with a dying planet is that it doesn't happen quickly, (Planet name) has been dying for a few hundred years. We have the privilege to watch our home and people slowly waste away. Around two hundred years ago some of the younger warlocks got together and tried to make a new spell that would save (the people of planet). The spell was supposed to take us from here to another habitual planet. It did not work. The planet was too weak to support the magic and the warlocks were executed. After the experiment the failing of our planet sped up, we don't have much time left.

Shortly after the doomed experiment the zips started happening. Originally (the government) had a different name for it, but someone jokingly called it zip and it stuck. So yeh, you can be talking to your neighbor and ZIP the just disappear into nothing. At a picnic talking to your auntie showing off her new baby and ZIP she's gone, you better hope you can catch that baby before it hits the ground. No one knows what happens to (people) that zip, they're just gone. (government) has done extensive research as to where (people) go, but nothing has come of it.

I now know what happens when a zip occurs. I was enjoying a rare storm free day, on my way to talk to my commander and now I am floating in a never ending expanse of disgusting water. There is nothing as far as the eye can see except this blue, everything is brighter here. There are creatures swimming beneath me, they do not seem like a cavillation though. I wonder how long I can float here, I wonder how many more of my kind are here, wherever here is.

*some key points *

Character arrived in the ocean on earth

There are small communities of their kind scattered across the planet, so goes to say that there are others on other planets.

Thanks for reading this mess


r/fantasywriters 21h ago

Critique My Story Excerpt Chapter One of my sci-fi fantasy novel, ‘Dormant Saga’ [Sci-Fi Fantasy, 2200]

Thumbnail gallery
6 Upvotes

This is the first chapter of my multi-POV sci fi novel, ‘Dormant Saga.’ I sent the prologue to this yesterday. I would love any feedback you guys have about this chapter, and let me know if you would continue reading! Also, you can ignore the “Four hundred years later” thing, as that pertains to the prologue.

This first chapter follows Finn, a Gai-Truvian boy on a ceremonial hunt to finally “abridge” him into adulthood.

It’s not too long, but hopefully you can flow through it.
I hope the cliff hanger leaves you wanting more as well, let me know if it does!

Any feedback is greatly appreciated, and I will always return the favor if needed.


r/fantasywriters 23h ago

Discussion About A General Writing Topic Any recommendations for translation sources?

5 Upvotes

So, I replied to an announcement a couple days ago about the subreddit’s policy against AI, and they mentioned that Google Translate uses that slop now as well. That comment was made kinda hastily because I am also VERY staunchly anti-AI, and I was irrationally worried that I accidentally committed an oopsie. The actual uses of Google Translate I used for a brainstorming Google Doc I made in November of last year could be very easily replaced, as it was only looking at word translations in other languages as inspiration for names, but I was wondering if anyone had recommendations for translating services that can also be used for simple sentences. I’m only adding on the simple sentences thing because one of the two names I came up with was a Latin translation of “Slayer of the Impure” for a fancy name for a major bad guy’s claymore. I don’t know if I’m overthinking this, but I figured I’d ask for any better translation apps I can use as an alternative.


r/fantasywriters 8h ago

Discussion About A General Writing Topic What are some things that you hate about Fantasy tropes and what would you rather see?

2 Upvotes

I'm interested in what people like and don't like in Fantasy writing these days since i don't like the trope of Demi humans or Beastfolks just being humans with animal ears and maybe a tail or occasional anthropomorphic animals that seem to just replace humans rather that have a unique society like Harpies instead of just building high in the sky but i would rather read how Harpy society is based on appearance and like how well the male birds can dance to attract mates if you get what i mean.

Or like the Elven races being mostly Humans with pointy ears. Give me a story where elves have weird builds like they're feet are Built for actual traversing of woods and more actual accurate physics for people living in the Wild!


r/fantasywriters 8h ago

Discussion About A General Writing Topic Do you ever just... have to draw your MC?

5 Upvotes

I'm kind of an artist anyway, so I've been drawing longer than I've been writing. But at some point in my stories, I just start to draw. This is my most recent sketch

:

Like, it's one thing to describe your characters in book, but for me eventually I feel the need to kind of see it come to life in some way shape or form. I have plans to digitize this (scan it into my computer, use the bamboo tablet blah blah blah), I probably won't add any color, and add it to my character lineups for when I publish, along with the map etc. I know that fantasy writing doesn't absolutely REQUIRE illustration because that's what the prose should be doing. But, just curious if any other writers out there also do their own art and what their process is like.


r/fantasywriters 18h ago

Critique My Story Excerpt Chapter 1 - Inviting Trouble (Mystery Fantasy, 2700 words)

3 Upvotes

Hey guys, I am 19 years old (Just turned 19 yesterday!) and as far back as I remember I've always wanted to write fantasy novels. This started when I was young I read the Mistborn Series, Harry Potter, The Burning series, GreenBone Saga, Discworld and even a bit of Dresden files!

I tried to write what seems to be an idea which has been looming in my head for about 8 years, but I have never been able to properly put into words and pen it down with characters, or a world rich enough to fit a story which I wanted to write.

But recently I have actually written something down.

In this chapter, I actually aimed for 3 things :

  1. Give the characters their separate personalities, voices and biases so that they feel alive, and also seem realistic to exist within the circumstances of that world.

  2. Make the dialogues as a way for there to be more exposure to the world rather than infodumping.

  3. To make more questions arise as more information gets revealed, and to have good pacing in it.

I am young and Ik I have a LOT to improve, so I would like to know about you guys' opinion on this, no matter how good or bad it may be, so don't be hesitant to tear me to pieces in case something is wrong! Either mechanical issues such as grammar or just the way the thing is written itself!

I hope for good feedback from the kind members of r/fantasywriters !

Below is the link.

Here's where you can read it.


r/fantasywriters 13h ago

Discussion About A General Writing Topic Has this ever happened to you?

2 Upvotes

So, I have been going through some complications this last time, and that has complicated many things (I have something that's kinda like OCD, I'm not saying I have that bc I never went to a mental health worker,but I mean that the mechanisms and experience is very similar to that) and it's like I read and nothing stays.

I read, but when I try to write is like all of the things I read disappear and I don't remember anything and everything I can do. i read to learn, and its like all my learning just goes blank. It doesn't stay in my head.

Besides asking you if this ever happened to you, I was also interested in getting your opinion about something.

I came with a method for this complication, which is that I take something i read and underlined and mix it.

an example so u don't misunderstand me: A) I looked to the sun, and saw nothing. B) He was the only one I could smile to. Theres nothing left for me.= I looked to the sun and saw him. everything I could do was smile to him/ I looked to the sun and knew there was nothing left for me/I look to the sun and know it's empty, he's all is left for me.

I would took two things and mix them and then think different versions. and the thing to make my former point clearer is that I used to do this and I think everyone does this, the problem is it's not longer natural to me. It doesn't appear spontaneously and is like I'm in a state of oblivion every time I want to write. It's like I lost the instinct.


r/fantasywriters 20h ago

Critique My Story Excerpt What in God's name is this creature? (low fantasy, 777 words)

Thumbnail gallery
0 Upvotes

About a month ago, I had posted the opening to one of my chapters to rather polarizing reception. Here is a non-sequitur excerpt from the middle of the same chapter (a chapter which I'm still working on, as I'm just that much of an underwriter).

Just in case you got tripped up by the number of named characters, Orlon is the POV character here. The excerpt opens with one of his cousins, having set off alone after a boar earlier, riding back to camp with a mysterious boy who later happens to recognize Orlon by name.

I'd appreciate your feedback on the prose and especially the dialog.

*I'm an ESL writer, and none of this is AI-assisted or translated.


r/fantasywriters 23h ago

Critique My Story Excerpt Critique this passage from my debut fantasy novel [Litrpg, 682 words]

Thumbnail gallery
2 Upvotes

This book has been 4 years in the making. I am now months away from release (working on 3rd draft). It has taken so long because i taught myself to write along the way and rewrote as I learned. Also, if you have any tips for marketing, ide be happy to hear them. I will self publish. I plan to spend around $3000 on ads and also plan to reinvest every penny it ever makes (if any).

As for critique: does my dialog style work for you? Would you even read a book with a dual female protagonist? The book was inspired by the primal hunter series. I wanted something similar but not so devoid of romance and youthful exuberance

Edit: pls ignore any formatting critique. The formatting is raw. I write in docs (there is no procedural formatting for novels). When I am finished editing the procedural formatting will be accomplished in a novel-facing editor.


r/fantasywriters 18m ago

Critique My Story Excerpt Wrote a chapter that attempts to convey a deep moral complexity and conflicted feelings - did it intrigue you? Upon the Foot of a Crow [Grim fantasy - 1300 words]

Thumbnail gallery
Upvotes

r/fantasywriters 13h ago

Critique My Story Excerpt The Bargain [Dark Fantasy, Short Story, 2689 words]

1 Upvotes

Hello all! I have started to dip my toes in fiction writing and I want to get my reps in before utilzing my own setting. So this short story is based in the Warhammer Fantasy world, just a vignette to start fleshing out my voice and style of writing. I would love to get some critiques on the piece and potentially share more of my writing if people are interested enough to give me a chance. I just used the setting since the themes I wanted to evoke fall in line with the setting. I'm not sure if this is dark fantasy or grim dark, so I apologize if I mislabeled my story.

I have been told that I tend to over write and lose readers with my writing. I wanted to see if that is the case or the people that I shared it to were not vibing with my style/content. Any feedback is appericated, most of my experience in writing is academic writing and writing ficition is more of a hobby that I would like to explore.

Thank you for you time!

https://docs.google.com/document/d/10tSSYwsjFCtUxuswGlv5PSzo85m3tkio6vZf7CiGluY/edit?usp=sharing


r/fantasywriters 18h ago

Critique My Story Excerpt (Edited) Idra (grimdark,1018 words)

Thumbnail gallery
1 Upvotes

I uploaded one page earlier and recieved some constructive critism and have now edited plus written more and hope to get feedback on it. Hopefully i made it better. Please be rather harsh and honest than positive but untrue. Would like to know if the story is interesting, if it feels too fast paced, if its obvious that english isnt my native language and if i succeded in giving Idra more personality/thoughts/emotions and whatever came to mind while reading. Now after hours on this i will watch anime and wait for notifications, thanks a lot and if i can return the favor just holler (:


r/fantasywriters 1h ago

Critique My Story Excerpt First page feedback? [Fantasy, 350words]

Upvotes

I’d appreciate some feedback on the first page(and a half) of my novel. Silk Road fantasy, student/mentor dynamic, character study. I'm specifically looking for thoughts on:

​Proper Nouns: Am I pushing the proper nouns right to the edge or over? Related to this so that I have a gauge, your favorite author?​

Fatigue and POV: I drop the father's name (Gedran) in the fourth paragraph. Should I restructure to avoid dropping his name to mitigate cognitive load with regard to proper noun fatigue? That is, until my mentor character (Tzeb) references him later? I realize I never really thought of my own father by his first name, so I'm wondering if using "Gedran" here breaks Telun's close POV, or if it works at signaling their cold relationship.

- - -

The sun bore down, pinning Telun against the rock, the crevasse’s shadow thinning to a useless line. Better cover lay west along the ridge. Deeper cuts of shade, less exposed shelves to watch the eastern approach. Move, then. But reaching them required breaking cover, and Tzeb had hammered the lesson deep: the eye catches motion. Three months ago, scouts had watched the horizon for him. Now he crouched on hot stone, dreading a question.

​What did you do wrong? The question worked at him the way grit works inside a boot. This was the longest he had survived the fox’s daily hunt. Somewhere in the fractured country around him, that Ashen mercenary waited for the rabbit to misjudge a silence. The question had been his father's verdict. But Tzeb had stolen it with a snort, expecting a man to answer better tomorrow. For that, Telun had let the alleys of Chandra close without him.

​He tugged at his waterskin. The water came warm and leather-tainted and did nothing for the dust lining his throat. He pressed the stopper into the neck. Soon the caravan would appear. The first camels would break the heat haze and draw the rest after them.

​His father had bought him this road to light a fire in him, naming the return—season and sum—at the gate, bangles clattering before the investment even cleared the yard. But Telun had planned to slip the column in the temple crowds, sell his silk, and the crest at his chest after it, and vanish into alleys no horse could reach. Instead, he had sealed the crest into his pack, intending to toss it at his father's feet. The silk was still in his pack. The crest was not. Fourteen days now, since he had gone to the seam where he'd hidden it and found the fraying mouth empty. Behind him lay the whole of the desert, no stretch of it more guilty than another. His father, still in his tent in the ordu’s prized inner ring, did not yet know. Ahead of him waited that reckoning, patient as everything else Gedran owned.


r/fantasywriters 18h ago

Writing Prompt Looking for a few beta-readers.

0 Upvotes

Hello thank you taking the time to read this post, I'm looking for a beta-readers to test out the first 3 chapters of this current project I'm working on called "Frontier Escapade." if you enjoy the first three and would like to beta read the other 7 please let me know,. this is what the project is about below.

(For 18+ Mature Audience Light Novel/Manga readers.)

SETTING THE STAGE: In the late 1880s, in the brutal, lawless frontier of Arizona, a young 19-year-old woman named Soluna Moreno lives a triple life: first as a serial killer known as the Demon of the West, second as a missionary bartender who runs her father's saloon, and third as a mother to an adopted child who lost his parents to lynching. The escapade starts on October 13th, 1889, when a strange meteor shower which, according to sources, happens only once every millennium begins to fall. A golden meteor crashes in front of Soluna, emitting a shockwave across the entire West Coast, and she gains a power called a Core. This makes her a contestant in a death game for a wish, and she is chosen as the Host of the Meteor, meaning other contestants will be hunting her down to kill her so the host's power can transfer to them. Soluna must now fight and survive until she is able to find the other half of the meteor and is the last contestant remaining.

(WARNING!) WHAT TO EXPECT: CREATIVE BATTLES
DEEP LORE AND WORLDBUILDING 
GORE/ BRUTAL AND HISTORICAL RACIAL TENSION (18+)
SENSITIVE TOPICS ABOUT RELIGION.
UNHINGED CHARACTERS AND UNSETTLING CHARACTERS.
NO ONE GETS AWAY UNSCATED, THAT MEANS CHILDREN, ANIMALS ETC.


r/fantasywriters 18h ago

Brainstorming So we all know about Omniscience, Omnipresence, but what would the other terms be?

0 Upvotes

So in my ability system, users are given a fraction of my god's power, which are distills of different aspects of Omnipotence.

So abilities that affect speed and range are two sides of omnipresence

The ability to know unobtainable knowledge or predict outcomes is omniscience.

The ability to construct or change something about the natural world Omnificence.

Struggling to figure out terms that sound right for the other aspects.

I have tried looking for terms, but none of them have the same ring as the others.

Now what I need is the following:

The ability to destroy anything

the Ability to Protect from anything

Insidious, eternal hatred

the ability to force anything to submit to your will/Control anything (I think Omnidominance sounds good but dunno)