r/evangelion • u/elvisfinalflush • 1h ago
Manga Changed opinion on Sadamoto’s manga after most recent read-through.
I adore Sadamoto’s Manga adaptation of NGE, as someone who got into Evangelion close to two years ago now (when I was just seventeen), I even considered it to be my favourite re-telling of NGE for a while. But with my most recent read-through, there’s so many glaring issues that just don’t make sense to me, and I fear on subsequent read-through’s they’ll only become more abundantly clear.
The Characters themselves are stripped of some defining traits, and though they are still themselves in foundation, some characters feel hollow compared to the original Series iteration. I always adored how Sadamoto was able to bring Rei and Kaji to the forefront of the story, even Gendo more so than the Series, but the price paid are weaker versions of characters like Asuka and Misato.
I’ll be using Misato as an example, as I feel I can actually articulate what I mean while sounding (somewhat) smart and not like the total idiot I am.
The Manga has a very healthy dynamic between Misato and Shinji compared to the anime, it’s a joy to see Misato achieve becoming a motherly figure for Shinji as she had failed to do in the anime, but it makes so many moments seem out of character for both her and Shinji for it. After Rei II’s death, we don’t get the infamous “This is all I can do for you” scene between Shinji and Misato, in fact there is hardly any Sexual Frustration in Misato’s character whatsoever, not only does this make Shinji’s rejection of staying in Misato’s apartment just seem strange and un-explained, but it makes the “Grown-Up Kiss” she has with Shinji in her final moments seem less like her facing the truth, and rejecting the illusion of being a Mother in favour of pushing Shinji towards his REAL mother (EVA01), and more like “Welp, I’m dyin’ time to French-kiss a child.” (Exactly how certain people like to simplify her actions in EOE)
The ending too, it just seems like such a cop-out. Everything is back to normal pre-Second impact save for some funny Eva statues, like what? I assume that’s exactly why Sadamoto didn’t care to truly give some key characters their well deserved developments and tragedies, because we’d be getting a happy ending anyway.
I’ve gone from totally adoring the Manga to now viewing it as an obligatory “Happier Ending” for Evangelion to purely satiate those who didn’t want the Post-Third Impact world. Can anyone else relate?