r/centrist Jan 12 '26

Meta Discussion

22 Upvotes

Greetings r/Centrist members, With the new year, we figured now would be a good time for a Meta thread. The goal of this post is to clarify some of our updated rules, provide transparency, and give the community at large an opportunity to share input and feedback for the sub. It seems most of our regular members are familiar with the posting requirements, but there has been some lingering ambiguity concerning several of our rules, particularly rule 3. The language has changed a bit over the past several months, but we have settled on the current verbiage and are happy with it. When it comes to rule 3 (articles and videos), we’re simply looking for a neutral summary to accompany any article or video. It doesn’t need to be a college dissertation or a PhD thesis, but we’re also looking for more than just rewording the title. A basic overview highlighting the relevant portions of the article is all we ask, the intent being to facilitate a quality discussion. Every mod here is a volunteer, and none of us has any desire to nitpick every summary as if we’re a high-school debate teacher.

……………

We also ask that for the summary, you avoid copying large portions of the article. Since there has been some confusion over this in the past, I want to clarify that this does not preclude you from utilizing direct quotes or information which is public domain. In other words, if an article quotes an individual, you may use that excerpt in your summary. If an article is discussing a public document (i.e. the Constitution), and the language of that document is included in the article, you are allowed to use it. This is related to DMCA violations, so as long as you’re not just plagiarizing the author’s narrative, you should be fine. But please use these excerpts to complement your summary as opposed to just posting a bunch of quotes without any context. The summary aside, if you want to include your own commentary, that is perfectly fine. Concerning the use of archived links, the intent is to prevent people from bypassing the rules. As long as they’re not the primary link when you post, you can include them in the body text or a comment. Also, please note the rule requiring any post titles to match the article. It’s far easier for us to consistently apply that than debate if someone is editorializing. Regarding long form discussion posts (rule 4), I’ll just say that they should be a legitimate attempt to start a quality discussion. If you come in guns blazing with a biased or overtly antagonistic post, it’s gonna get removed. If it’s low-effort (super basic questions, baiting users, etc.), it’s gonna get removed. There is obviously more moderator discretion involved here than for news articles, but if you put some effort into your post, keep it neutral, and make sure it’s relevant to politics, you should be fine. As it relates to AI, Chat GPT generated long-form discussions may be removed at mods discretion. They can help supplement your post, but shouldn't be most of your post.

………….

Moving on, a quick note about the mod team. Being a political sub, it’s a delicate balancing act between letting people express their views, while also trying to maintain civility. Last year, there were complaints that the sub wasn’t moderated enough, so we’ve been trying to consistently enforce the rules for everyone. All that to say, we do our absolute best to remain fair and impartial. If there is a post or comment which toes the line, it’s not unusual for us to discuss it behind the scenes before taking action. Every mod action is logged as well. If I remove a comment or post, the other mods can see it. If another mod approves a comment or post, I can see it. If we ban anyone, the other mods see it. If we get a modmail, all mods can view it. We’re not a hive mind, but we strive to be as consistent as we can. The comments section is open, so feel free to add your two cents. The rest of the mod team and myself will be checking in periodically to answer questions as we can. Depending on how much attraction this gets, I’m not sure we’ll get to everyone, but the mod group will discuss any inputs and critiques we see users bring up. Please keep comments respectful and constructive. Thanks all.


r/centrist Aug 31 '25

Long Form Discussion What is exactly centrism ?

42 Upvotes

I honestly do not know what is exactly centrism. Are Starmer and Macron centrist ? Is centrism any ideologie but moderate (for example christian democracy instead of conservatism, social-liberalism instead of social democracy and liberalism) ? Can centrisme work with any ideology ? I am not a centrist, I am a libertarian and i honestly don't know much about centrism. I would be very grateful if you could answer my questions !

Edit: do you guys think technocracy is centrism ?


r/centrist 1h ago

US News/Current Events Oil surges past $95 as U.S. downplays Iran diplomacy and 2nd key trade route is disrupted

Thumbnail
nbcnews.com
Upvotes

Due to a recent escalating of weapons fire in the wake of the weekend attack on a Jordanian base that killed multiple US Soldiers, and a threat from the Houthis targeting the Bab el-Mandeb strait, the price for a barrel of International Brent crude oil reached $95 for the first time in a month and a half. This has pushed the average gasoline price in the US to over $4 per gallon

With traffic in the strait of Hormuz ground back to a stop again, the President has gone back to threatening to destroy bridges and power plants when boats are struck

All of this comes as the Trump admin is requesting billions more dollars to cover the cost of this war, which at this point a majority of Americans expect to go on for at least 3 months


r/centrist 16h ago

Trump Plans 100% Tariff on Generic Drugs From August 2028

Thumbnail
finance.yahoo.com
84 Upvotes

r/centrist 18h ago

The DSA sweet spot: highly educated, downwardly mobile

60 Upvotes

Summary: The rise of the Democratic Socialists of America is rooted less in the traditional working class than among highly educated people with modest incomes. Education and income are not interchangeable measures of class: many college graduates possess cultural status but remain indebted, economically insecure, or excluded from the professional success they expected. Voters with postgraduate degrees and household incomes between $30,000 and $60,000 are among the most Democratic and liberal groups in the country, and they closely resemble the DSA’s base of teachers, nonprofit workers, social workers, and public employees.

This explains why economic socialism and cultural progressivism overlap so strongly. Highly educated, lower-income liberals are especially engaged by immigration, race, LGBTQ rights, environmentalism, and Israel–Palestine, while successful non-college voters are often more Republican. The central political divide is therefore not simply rich versus poor, but cultural status versus economic position. Socialism gives economically disappointed graduates an explanation for their frustration, while cultural conflicts provide the moral identity and political energy that draw them into the movement.

Personal Note: This may seem like rage bait to poke at the DSA crowd, and honestly it probably is. But it is also, in my opinion, very useful and enlightening to know where the 'extreme leftist' energy is coming from, and why it won't work. People don't want priveliged PhD's that failed in the private sector being their political leaders.

https://substack.com/home/post/p-207869387


r/centrist 1d ago

Elections / Voting Error led to 6600 non-U.S. citizens being registered to vote in NJ, Gov. says

Thumbnail
nbcphiladelphia.com
112 Upvotes

r/centrist 1d ago

Trump's Iran nightmare deepens as damning poll reveals Americans' brutal verdict with war nearing five months and US death toll rising

52 Upvotes

Summary: A recent Daily Mail/JL Partners poll reveals that only 32 percent of voters approve of President Donald Trump's handling of the war with Iran, bringing his overall approval rating down to 44 percent. Nearly half of respondents believe the decision to launch military action was wrong, particularly as the American troop death toll reaches 18 alongside over 100 casualties. Public optimism for a quick resolution remains low, with 58 percent of voters expecting the conflict to last over a year or unsure how long it will continue. While U.S. strikes expand and international mediators attempt to broker a ceasefire, public backing for further military escalation remains strictly limited.

https://www.dailymail.com/news/us-politics/article-15991575/americans-brutal-verdict-trump-iran-war.html

Commentary: one of the friendliest maga media publications is reporting on the huge split among this administration's supporters. They feel furious about the war they were promised would never happen. They are furious they never experienced a single second of economic relief before being volunteered into a war on behalf of another country, according to our current department of State. They are furious about being crushed by the current economy, the billions and billions going to foreign countries and the slow moving agenda even with complete control of the house Senate sc and presidency. People aren't happy.


r/centrist 1d ago

Long Form Discussion Question for centrists who are "Trump neutral" or MAGA allies neutral- what do you like about them/why aren't you concerned?

23 Upvotes

This is specifically for folks who struggle to choose between MAGA conservatives and liberals, as many centrists I know tend to lean to "one party is insane and one is simply unappetizing" but for those who struggled to choose between Trump and Harris, or would struggle in elections between MAGA aligned conservatives and democrats, I have always been curious about your value system. What makes the choice hard, and what do you admire about MAGA to make that choice hard OR why don't you stress about their actions as threats to democracy and human rights like many of us do?

SPECIFICALLY this wouldn't be about non aligned/rogues (Romney, Massie) but as most conservatives in major elections are MAGA aligned, I am speaking about them.

I strongly struggle to understand it and want to see where the logic is coming from.

Also hoping folks don't blindly downvote, I feel like we rarely see this perspective and I don't want to discourage folks from sharing it.


r/centrist 1d ago

US News/Current Events The economic fallout from Trump's long string of strategic mistakes is here

55 Upvotes

Neutral summary: Multiple sources are raising alarms about US strategic oil reserves, which have fallen to around 300mm barrels of oil. For reference, this is the lowest level since 1983. A chart reflecting historical US strategic reserve levels can be found at this link: US Crude Oil in the Strategic Petroleum Reserve Stocks (Wee….

While it is true that Trump seems to have never seen a "footgun" he did not love, this aimless Iran war must take the cake even beyond the tariff "misadventure." The "bill" for this one will be huge, and I predict the vast majority of Americans do not feel they should have to pay for any of it, nor are most able to pay any more for goods and services than they do today. We are looking at a collision with reality in the very near future for pretty much everyone in the USA.

To level set, Trump inherited an economic mess. That is objectively true. But Trump has come to so many forks in the road since taking office and primarily chosen to go "off-roading" and in the case of both the (illegal) tariff scheme and the Iran war, just driven right through the guardrail to see how steep a cliff lies on the other side.

US debt markets continue to heave and buckle, and while that is a complex topic, it has fairly simple (and unpleasant) effects for every American. Markets do not require many things, but some level of predictability is required for the economic and social systems our lives are built around to function at all. The net effect of this level of chaos and "strategic unforced error" on Trump's part is increased costs to do ANYTHING. It costs more for Americans to borrow. It costs more for us to transact, to gather, to organize, to celebrate, to mourn, the list goes on. There is nowhere in our lives the net costs economically and socially are not coming back to find us under this administration.

One does wonder how much further this all must go before there is yet no one who can defend or stand behind the actions of this administration. Trump wants to point the finger at the last administration now that his economic woes are coming home to roost. Fine, there was mismanagement then. But every move Trump has made since then has been ruinous to the nth power. Saying the building already had foundation issues which you campaigned to fix for your constituents can hardly excuse burning the entire place down, and that is what it appears to me that this President is bent on doing. Not to worry, of course, because Trump is hard at work undermining confidence in the election that placed him in the White House for a second term, so we know he is laser focused on preventing an energy supply shock that would bring our entire domestic economy to its knees...


r/centrist 1d ago

North America Trump to hit Canada with new 50% tariff

91 Upvotes

Trump to hit Canada with new 50% tariff

Neutral Summary: President Trump announced new 50% tariffs on many Canadian imports, arguing Canada unfairly discriminates against U.S. goods through measures involving alcohol, dairy and auto trade. The tariffs would use a different legal authority than his earlier tariffs, which were struck down by the U.S. Supreme Court. Canada says its measures were retaliation to earlier U.S. tariffs and has indicated it will keep negotiating while considering its response. The move escalates the ongoing trade dispute and raises new legal and economic questions.

Let me get this straight.

Trump's started tariffs on Canada (which were ruled illegal). Canada retaliated (legally). Now Trump is pointing to Canada's retaliation as the justification for a new 50% tariff under a completely different law. (Section 338 was meant to deal with countries that unfairly discriminate against US goods, not countries responding to tariffs a US court already said were illegal).

So he's basically putting a different illegal tariff because his original illegal tarrif caused reciprocal tarrifs.

Does that sum it up?


r/centrist 1d ago

Pentagon Withheld Dozens of U.S. Military Injuries in Iran War (Gift Article)

Thumbnail
nytimes.com
65 Upvotes

r/centrist 1d ago

Podcasts / Politics Am I the only one who thinks we (those of us on the moderate left) need to start taking HasanAbi & co a bit more seriously, and maybe time for parents to get involved?

73 Upvotes

I don't want this to sound like a snark post. If you like Hasan, I'm sorry, these are my opinions of him. I do not want this to devolve into streamer drama. Assuming we are all adults here.

I have been growing increasingly concerned with HasanAbi, his brand of politics, and the cult following of teenagers he has groomed into a fairly powerful voting block, that will continue to grow in size.

I don't even know where to start with this man. It's just bad. We are at the point now where he is essentially reading off Qatari-scripted propaganda speeches to his audience of tens of thousands of children, who view him as the capital T Truth, as a deity, and as an absolute compass of morality and truth. It is truly bizarre. Every single sentence that comes out of his mouth will be whatever most weakens the USA and the west. It is calculated, it is sinister, and I genuinely do not believe he is writing these speeches.

And then when you meet people who subscribe to this brand of politics, it genuinely comes across as if they are suffering from religious psychosis. I have received a wide eyes, blank stare, "that's not what Hasan says".

It's scary, the anti-western sentiment in young leftists is truly scary to me. It concerns me to see Hasan having positive relationships with other popular political figures.

I live in Seattle. The politics of young people in this area are BONKERS. They truly believe we are headed toward a prisonless, policeless, anarchist, communist, islamic society. Like this is truly what the majority of young people I talk to in this city envision.


r/centrist 2d ago

US News/Current Events Congress rejected some of Trump’s proposed budget cuts. OMB is making them anyway.

Thumbnail
thehill.com
83 Upvotes

r/centrist 1d ago

2026 U.S. Midterms Will a Sex Scandal Matter in an Arizona House Race?

Thumbnail
nytimes.com
20 Upvotes

r/centrist 2d ago

Mayor Mamdani signs executive order to help NYC small businesses

Thumbnail
pix11.com
31 Upvotes

r/centrist 1d ago

"STOP! STOP!" Krystal HEATED DSA Debate w Top Dem Rep Adam Smith to discuss Israel, the DSA and more!

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes

Submission statement:

This video features a conversation between Krystal Ball and Representative Adam Smith (the ranking member of the House Armed Services Committee) regarding the state of the Democratic Party, U.S.-Israel relations, and policy disagreements with the Democratic Socialists of America (DSA).

Key discussion points:

  • U.S.-Israel Relations & Military Aid: Adam Smithdiscusses his evolving views on military aid to Israel. While he maintains that Israel has a right to defend itself against threats from HamasHezbollah, and Iran, he explains his recent vote for the Thomas Massie amendment (which sought to block aid) as a necessary message to the Netanyahu government (10:33 - 11:15). He also outlines his opposition to specific NDAAprovisions that would further integrate U.S. and Israelimilitary co-development programs given the current political climate (0:31 - 2:44).
  • Divisions within the Democratic Party: The discussion delves into the tensions between the Democratic establishment and the DSASmith expresses frustration with what he characterizes as "illiberal" tactics used by some activists, such as shouting down speakers at town halls or protests (39:18 - 40:10). He also critiques the DSA platform on issues like defense spending and immigration policy, while clarifying that he remains open to some economic populist ideas (22:35 - 25:10, 27:36 - 28:58).
  • Economic Populism and Governance: Smith highlights his agreement with some socialist-aligned governance, pointing to Zoran Mandani in New York City as an example of effective, practical problem-solving that focuses on tangible results like infrastructure and child care rather than strictly ideological exercises (33:24 - 36:30).
  • Campaign Finance: The conversation concludes with a debate on the influence of outside money in Democratic primaries, specifically mentioning the role of AIPACSmithadvocates for reforms to limit independent expenditure groups (42:22 - 44:10).

r/centrist 3d ago

Black and Hispanic Enrollment Drops, Asian Enrollment Rises for Harvard’s Class of 2029

Thumbnail
thecrimson.com
96 Upvotes

Submission statement : The proportion of Black and Hispanic students enrolled in Harvard College’s freshman class dropped in the second year after the Supreme Court overturned race-conscious undergraduate admissions, according to data released by Harvard on Thursday.


r/centrist 3d ago

Two U.S. Troops Were Killed, One Is Missing After Iran Missile Attack in Jordan

Thumbnail wsj.com
36 Upvotes

Summary: Two US service members were killed and several injured in an Iranian attack. One service member is missing. These are the first U.S. deaths since the cease-fire. The US is retaliating with attacks on Iran to 'punish' the Iranian regime. The Iranians have adapted their tactics to counter US defenses, resulting in the success of this attack.


r/centrist 3d ago

Trump zeroes in on election security. His team has cut thousands of election-focused federal workers.

Thumbnail
cbsnews.com
101 Upvotes

r/centrist 2d ago

Explosion outside New York federal building in Manhattan apparently caused by fireworks, sources say

Thumbnail msn.com
0 Upvotes

Neutral Comment - A subject carrying either BB guns or airsoft guns set off an incendiary device outside of the Federal Plaza in New York City. Four people suffered minor injuries. According to the article, sources described the subject who did this as an "anti-ICE activist." The cart that he had with him had "ICE off our streets" written on it.

My Take - I'm sure that there will be people, even in these comments, who try to downplay the incident saying that it was "only fireworks." Sorry, no. This is where it starts. The non-violent left strikes again.


r/centrist 3d ago

Mamdani Says He May Still Order Netanyahu’s Arrest

Thumbnail
nytimes.com
43 Upvotes

Summary:

Mayor Zohran Mamdani stated in a New York Times interview that he is still evaluating whether he has the legal authority to order the NYPD to arrest Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu if he visits New York for the U.N. General Assembly. He believes Netanyahu should face charges at the International Criminal Court, though legal experts note the U.S. does not recognize ICC jurisdiction and that Netanyahu has head‑of‑state immunity. Mamdani said he is in active discussions with the city’s Law Department, acknowledging uncertainty about whether a mayor can legally detain a foreign leader. The article also covers broader political topics, including Mamdani’s views on Israel, national politics, immigration, crime, and media scrutiny of his wife.

Analysis:

Federal supremacy and federal diplomatic immunity statutes make it flatly illegal for a mayor or local police to arrest a protected foreign leader. Under the U.S. Constitution’s Supremacy Clause, federal law overrides state or municipal authority, and diplomatic immunity (including head‑of‑state immunity) is governed by federal statutes and international agreements administered by the State Department. Even if a mayor ordered an arrest, federal law would render the arrest unlawful, and federal authorities could intervene immediately. Nor does the US recognize the authority of the ICC, or acknowledge its jurisdiction. Furthermore, the US has its own laws that would allow it to use military intervention to extract Americans held by the ICC.

All of this means that this is pure demagoguery from Mamdani, aimed at feeding red meat to his base of anti semitic and DSA extremists. He can later throw up his hands and use it as a critique of US policy to score points with his fans.


r/centrist 4d ago

Trump says these documents prove his false claims of election fraud. Here's what they really say

124 Upvotes

https://www.pbs.org/newshour/amp/politics/trump-says-these-documents-prove-his-false-claims-of-election-fraud-heres-what-they-really-say

Neutral summary

President Trump in an attempt to provide a factual basis for his most recent speech that was widely criticized for lacking any factual basis releases a number of released a number of documents that allies had hyped as a smoking gun that would prove his long-debunked allegations of mass voter fraud.

This article investigates the documents and nothing in them backs up the Preston’s claim. In fact, there are some previously unreleased documents in there for confirming that Russia was helping Trump win.

My question for the sub is where is their red line on a politician or political nominee on this? I believe anyone still supporting Trump’s clear lies here should not be in office. I believe anybody afraid to say who won in 2020 should not be in office.


r/centrist 3d ago

Could political classes be forming partisanship problem?

0 Upvotes

I initially thought that political education can cut partisanship and to ensure centrists are more representative and vocal. But in reality however, it certainly looks otherwise.

Of course, we are in a democracy, we can have any views as long as they are ethically justified and not dangerous (e.g. fascist level). However, it does feel like some partisanship is being indirectly placed on students.

Here in the UK there is the Education Act of 1996, in which sections 406 and 407 address the issue. Nevertheless it looks like classes are forming part of the us vs them action. I have an A-Level Politics teacher who acts, quite frankly, very charismatic and in a partisan tone, because the way she speaks and acts does sound like she has an indirect political perspective and often generalizes things e.g. all negatives of dictatorships - don't get me wrong, dictatorships these days are dangerous and corrupt, this is a cause of undevelopment in many nations but historically there were some dictators that kept the country stable and progressive for example Bangladesh's Hasina regime was one prominent example. Some irony is there because I remember one time when our lesson discussed about voting behaviour, she asked us to put our hands up if we are more centrist and i proudly admitted to say so and I was the only one to admit, likely most of the others are left leaning. Again, not an issue, but I seem to be treated like the third wheel because of this.

On another occasion, someone in my Politics A-Level class made an allegation against me of apparently searching up far right content and advice on google. This was obviously not true because I know what I was doing, because as a moderate I have a mix of both right and left wing views and I frankly have right wing views on immigration, multiculturalism and the economy (I believe in a multi ethnic society than a multicultural one while favouring progressive meritocracy) and I googled to ask if I would get sanctioned if I were to express a view that is centre right or right wing. Likely my teacher was the one behind it because she had gotten so condescending towards me whenever she speaks to me - on top of talking over me when I did not even finish my spoken statement. And whenever we contribute, classmates often speak as if they want to go against other nations. I understand many other nations are dangerous but soapboxing makes things worse and it looks like my teacher has favourites on the soapboxing partisan ones.

I picked politics because one of my careers is to be a home affairs or social affairs news reporter, not to forcefully become an MP or to join a political party - besides, there are no political parties that match my political perspectives, I thought the Liberal Democrats or the Conservative Party under Kemi Badenoch would do so but the Lib Dems favour more open borders while the other party is more paternalistic and patriarchal.

This is also why in the United States there is the divide between democrats and republicans, as if the borders are like the electrical telephone wires on the London Underground - if a republican or democrat date one another, riots will occur likely.

Really, being educated does not necessarily mean you would become a good person. I guess your centrist views remain intact if you choose a variety of subjects for your careers because I do Politics, Sociology and Economics A-Levels - many economic students are centre to right wing. Even though Sociology is mainly left leaning students and teachers, my Sociology teacher, who is very lovely and supportive, understands my perspectives, both left and right wing views so this is not an issue.


r/centrist 4d ago

Two US service members killed, one missing following Iranian strikes in Jordan

Thumbnail
cnn.com
53 Upvotes

r/centrist 3d ago

The Israeli Government Installed and Maintained Security System at Epstein Apartment | Security equipment and alarms were installed by the Israeli government at a notorious Manhattan residence frequented by former PM Ehud Barak

Thumbnail
dropsitenews.com
21 Upvotes