Hi all - I’m a single 30 year old guy (no family or kids) and looking to buy my first car (been living in nyc). I would really appreciate everyone’s advice here because threes so many options and I’m all over the place! The only things I want are cars that have wireless CarPlay, a nice touch screen, leather seats, AWD for snow in the northeast and will last 5 years and 80k miles. Here’s the cars I looked at and am seriously considering. Would love to hear your thoughts!
New Kia K5 GT-line - I love the interior and how it looks. Very sporty and great technology. This is also about $32k so the cheapest car on this list. My only worry is it’s a Kia but I saw people said they are better now? Also I saw insurance rates are high because these are stolen like crazy (or attempted to be stolen because of Kia boys).
Used 2023 Lexus ES 250 AWD - this is luxury and quiet ride. Looking at around 20-30k miles which comes out to $35-$37k. Nothing else to say here.
New Toyota RAV4 XLE Premium - this seems to be the hot car right now and one that I assume will have amazing resale value. I found this at MSRP ($39k) but only thing that worries me is road noise. Still, knowing it holds its value is very attractive to me.
New Honda CRV EXL - unlike the RAV4, this is the gas version. Cheaper than RAV4 at $36k. Honestly drove this and the RAV4 and didn’t notice a difference. Leaning RAV4 just because of resale value.
Used 2023 BMW 3 series - I would buy this car if it wasn’t for the high maintenance cost. I called a bmw dealer and replacing engine mounts ($3000-5000), brakes ($3k) and transmission fluid ($1800) moved this into the $10k range just for maintenance before I even hit 100k miles. The one I’m looking at has 36k miles and sells for $31k.
Used 2025 Crown Signia - this seems like an upscale pick which costs about $40k. However, these seem to depreciate fast for a Toyota.
As you can see, I have a wide array of options so could really use your help! What would you do? In case it matters, I won’t be financing (paying cash) so interest rates don’t matter to me. This is truly what’s the best car. I’ll be in the northeast (Mass) which is snowy but near Boston. Thanks for your help!