I wrote this because I’m caught between accepting that it’s over and still loving someone I know I can’t chase. I’m not looking for advice on how to get her back. I’m wondering whether anyone else has felt this split between what the mind knows and what the heart still holds.
I Left Because I Loved You
I did not leave because I hated you.
At least,
I don’t think I did.
I left because staying felt impossible,
but leaving did too.
I knew that if you came back
and said,
“Let’s try again,”
I probably would have dropped everything.
And I don’t know
if that means I loved you
or if I just didn’t know
how to let the future I imagined die.
So I deleted the pictures.
Blocked the pages.
Erased the number.
Changed the city.
I thought distance
would make things clearer.
But somehow,
you stayed.
In flowers.
In songs.
In places that did nothing wrong
except remind me of you.
And every time my heart remembers,
my mind argues with it.
It says,
“Don’t you remember how she hurt you?”
And I do.
I remember the silence.
The distance.
The confusion.
The way someone else received
everything I thought
we were still trying to become.
So why do I still miss you?
Why does part of me still wonder
what I would say
if you came back?
Why can I understand
that it is over
and still feel like something
inside me never got the message?
I don’t know.
That is the truth.
I have spent years
being strong for everyone else.
“Can you help?”
“Can you fix this?”
“What should I do?”
And I helped.
Again.
And again.
I became a home
for people who never asked
where I went to rest.
Then you came along,
and for a moment,
I thought maybe I had found it.
Someone beside me.
Someone to grow with.
Someone who saw me
before I had everything figured out.
Or maybe I only thought I did.
Maybe that is what hurts most.
I still don’t know
what was real,
what changed,
or when I stopped being
what you said you wanted.
And my prayers
keep changing their minds.
First:
“God, bring her back.”
Then:
“God, give us one more chance.”
Then:
“God, if she is gone,
please take the memory too.”
I pray for reunion.
Then I pray for forgetting.
Then I feel guilty
for wanting either one.
I ask God to bring you close.
Then I ask Him
to pull you out of me.
And when prayer feels like silence,
I carry my wishes somewhere else.
I leave them beneath trees.
I write them onto paper
like maybe the branches
understand something I don’t.
I think about wishing wells,
quarters falling through darkness,
each one carrying
a different version
of the same confused request:
Let her return.
Let me forget.
Let her choose me.
Help me stop hoping.
Tell me it mattered.
Tell me why it ended.
Tell me what I am supposed
to do with all this love
now that it has nowhere to go.
I don’t hate you.
Sometimes I wish I did.
Maybe anger would be easier
than this strange mixture
of grief, hope, love, and knowing better.
Maybe letting go
is not forgetting.
Maybe it is not having an answer
and still choosing not to chase one.
Maybe it is leaving the note
on the tree.
Dropping the coin
into the well.
Saying the prayer
without knowing
which ending I actually want.
Maybe it is admitting:
I loved you.
I may still love you.
I know it is over.
And somehow,
I still do not understand
why my heart keeps asking
if it really is.
So every day I keep walking,
not because I am certain,
not because I am healed,
not because I finally understand—
but because I don’t know
what else to do.
And maybe,
somewhere in all that confusion,
I'll find clarity
Did letting go ever start to feel real for you, or did it happen so gradually that you only noticed later?