I've been thinking about Ofmatthew's final moments, and I honestly understand both sides.
June had every reason to resent Ofmatthew. She reported the Martha, which led to Hannah's Martha being executed, and June's hopes of getting closer to Hannah were shattered. In Gilead, that betrayal is devastating.
But I also think people overlook what happened afterward.
Once June learned what Ofmatthew had done, she completely isolated her. She encouraged the other handmaids to shun her, leaving Ofmatthew with no one. In a society as psychologically abusive as Gilead, that kind of isolation can push someone over the edge. It felt like the final straw that sent her into a complete mental breakdown.
What makes it more tragic is that I don't think Ofmatthew saw herself as the villain. She genuinely believed she was protecting June. From her perspective, June constantly took reckless risks that could have gotten her executed. Reporting suspicious behavior was exactly what Gilead had conditioned her to do, and she likely believed she was saving June from making an even bigger mistake.
That doesn't excuse what she did. Her actions had horrific consequences.
But June's campaign to ostracize her also had consequences. By the time Ofmatthew snapped, she had been stripped of any support system she had left.
It's one of the saddest storylines in The Handmaid's Tale because Gilead created both women. One became rebellious, the other became completely indoctrinated, and in the end they destroyed each other while the regime remained untouched.
I'm curious how everyone else sees it. Was June justified in shunning Ofmatthew, or do you think that was the point where things went too far?